See all
256 photos

Old Homestead Steakhouse

Steakhouse and Bar$$$$

Atlantic City

Save

8.3^/10

166

ratings

Ranked #4 for steakhouses in Atlantic City
"enjoy the heavy cut bacon and mushrooms with the filet...devine"(2 Tips)
"Lobster mac n cheese is awesome."(5 Tips)
"Rib eye for two was delicious"(3 Tips)
"lobster bacon mash is amazing!"(3 Tips)

46 Tips and reviews

Filter:

good for dates
garlic mashed potatoes
good for groups
restaurants
trendy
prime rib
filet mignon
bacon
creme brûlée
big portions
dinner
bar
soup
alcohol
good for special occasions
pricey
fresh mozzarella
porterhouse
liquor
chefs
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Melissa FarrellJune 15, 2013
Best.steak.ever. 18oz filet with bernaise is heaven on a plate. Cooked exactly as ordered. Broccoli rabe could've used more garlic but overall an excellent dining experience w/ impeccable A+ service
MikeSeptember 27, 2019
I love coming here, the service was top notch and the food is just amazing. Blows the original Old Homestead in NYC out of the water!
Jason H.July 27, 2015
Wonderful cuts of steak and big portions. Side of Asparagus can feed the room! Service is impeccable as well. Special.
Theo VassilopoulosJanuary 2, 2014
Try the filet mignon 18 ounce steak and if you are into whiskey have a sip of the "Makers 46" smokiest bourbon ever.
Stacy R.August 17, 2011
key lime pie martini. east & west oysters served w horseradish & cocktail sauces. bacon wrapped filet served w a house hash brown & demi glaze. side of creamed spinach. old homestead cheesecake. YUM!!
Michelle LynnDecember 21, 2011
The porterhouse dry aged steak for 2 is very good and the garlic mash potatos. And for starters a MUST is the fried calamari!!!
AngelineSeptember 28, 2014
Came for friends' bday dinner;seated more than 1hr late-all obvi ordered steak-all were cooked incorrectly. A very rare steak had to be sent back 2xs for being overcooked. Steakhouse or fake-house?
Michele HughesJuly 26, 2016
Rib eye for two was delicious
Linda MillerApril 5
Absolutely the best!!! Pricey but well worth the experience!!!
Jessica FalcoSeptember 4, 2022
The best steakhouse I have ever been too 🥩
RickyMarch 1, 2013
The service is absolutely impeccable and the food is presented perfectly and divine. 5 stars.
Michele HughesJuly 26, 2016
This is a great red wine to have with dinner
Donovan MaguiganDecember 8, 2016
Amazing food. Filet was cooked to perfection.
PersephoneOctober 24, 2014
Wagyu beef or tower of raw clams for appetizer? Get both...you won't regret it
ian hallApril 28, 2012
Share a seafood tower with your friends, then lay waste to a 34oz. Gotham ribeye. Die happy!
StephenJuly 25, 2014
Petite filet always amazing.
Christopher PompeySeptember 12, 2012
This place is amazing!!! Excellent food and service! Highly recommended.
Brian BrennanJuly 13, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Save just enough room for dessert. The Drunken Banana is insanely good!
WandaOctober 23, 2012
Make sure you have a reservation - this place fills up and it may be difficult to get a table. They do not rush you out.
Didi MarieApril 11, 2014
The Bread Specialty is incredibly decadent...
Sean HuebschOctober 14, 2015
Try lobster mashed potatoes.
Stan FarynaSeptember 12, 2015
Prime rib, ribeye and lobster
Christine NolanAugust 10, 2013
Try the onion rings... They don't disappoint!
FarynaAugust 11, 2014
5lb lobster
Papi n DiegoOctober 13, 2010
Enjoy the thick bacon and the fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers...excellent
Kimberly LucastuApril 15, 2012
So great and the Chef is awesome!!!
GenevieveMay 7, 2015
Very good food here :)
Carolyn TedeschiNovember 13, 2018
Food was good, but I like Morton's better
Joe DosOctober 13, 2011
enjoy the heavy cut bacon and mushrooms with the filet...devine
Lauren CapriottiNovember 4, 2011
Just get 10 orders of the bacon appetizer and call it a day.
estha yim-*January 27, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Lobster mac n cheese is awesome. But idk if its worth $20..
Chris McfaddenAugust 21, 2010
Make sure you try the garlic bread appetizer with the Parmesan cheese sauce!!
Simmy PappachenJuly 2, 2012
The steak was great. the mac-cheese? no good.
Kal ElJuly 10, 2010
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake is one of the best I've had...
Tracey FerraraJuly 2, 2013
Loved the sea base
Lena SJune 23, 2010
lobster bacon mash is amazing!
Connie PFebruary 12, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Chilean sea bass is the best
Linnie DFebruary 14, 2015
Annoying that they won't check coats.
D. AlonsoMarch 28, 2010
You better have The Soup! It's awesome!
Glynis RocksJuly 13, 2015
Not as good as Manhattan
Jon LinJanuary 15, 2012
Service and consistency is poor. Long wait times and inconsistently cooked steaks. Bobby flays is leagues ahead. Go there
Sarah GrossSeptember 11, 2012
Ummm this Place is a sorry excuse for a Restaurant, Extremely Overpriced, Poor Quality. Just overall dissapointed. The Service was A ++ !!
ellen resnickMay 13, 2016
Awful, over price, unfriendly service, no baked potato, too chain like, NYC one is way better
s28January 6, 2011
The sign says they are closed til the 13th of jan.
Musa HoxhaAugust 2, 2010
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
Kal ElJuly 10, 2010
Heavy cut Bacon

256 Photos

Old Homestead Steakhouse

Related Searches

Other places inside Borgata Hotel Casino & Spa

You might also like

Places people like to go after Old Homestead Steakhouse

Appears on 45 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.