Old Man Rafferty's
American Restaurant, Bar, and Bakery$$$$
New Brunswick
Ranked #4 for American restaurants in New Brunswick
"Tomato basil soup,baked apple pie and steaks are superb."(8 Tips)
"The tomato soup is to die for!"(9 Tips)
"Rocky road cake is in my Top 2 of allllk time."(2 Tips)
"Great bar service and amazing dessert selection (very yummy to boot)"(13 Tips)
81 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- desserts
- burgers
- good for dates
- cake
- sandwiches
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Ryan HartleyDecember 17, 2013I travel the usa trying restaurants. This place has a great atmosphere. Went with local the recom. Of basil soup. It tasted like homemade from a recipe. Delicious The burger was alright, dryish
Johnika DMarch 16, 2013I really enjoyed this place. The menu is diverse like the Cheesecake Factory. The Pastrami Ruben was GREAT! Service was outstanding. The dessert bar is out if this world. You have to get something!
Nicky PetroniAugust 23, 2014Great pub style food. I recommend trying a burger. If anything come for their extensive dessert menu!
Peter PalumboAugust 10, 2014Everything is good! Food portions for appetizers could be a little bigger but the entrees are generous and tasty
Sarah ESeptember 11, 2011I like this place a lot. I have done a birthday dinner here. The food is good, and they do have a decent selection for dessert. Bar is nice, and so is their service.- My last 2 visits have been disappointing. I just had the chicken fingers and fries today. Blahhh, lacked flavor. The 2 side sauces helped a bit. Dessert was the only saving grace!
D Moni ClarkeFebruary 10, 2017Been here twice. First time by chance, 2nd time on purpose lol. Short rib appetizer is to die for!!
douglas adamsDecember 13, 2015The food was unbelievably good. Service was above par, and the price was right. We may be looking for excuses to come to New Brunswick
Try the Blue Cheese Burger - Burger with blue cheese at Old Man Rafferty's in #NewBrunswick, #NJ (via @Foodspotting)
Lady BlackDecember 26, 2011Tomato basil soup. So tasty. DON'T look up the calories. Way too many but it tastes so good so who cares.
Good food and pleasant service. A good bet for lunch or dinner.- Sarah ESeptember 14, 2011A place you can never go wrong with. Good food and service. I recommend ordering their desserts which are good.
Jorge AmadorMarch 6, 2010Excellent food here. Had clam chowder, stuffed chicken with risotto cakes, and a dark chocolate cake - all excellent!
They took hangar steak off the menu, that was the best thing- AJamiestarrSeptember 25, 2010Tomato basil soup,baked apple pie and steaks are superb. Crab encrusted Tilapia was like butta!
Myles MillerJune 6, 2011Good food at low prices. Make sure to chek out the store connected to it Read more
free apps at the bar and $5 martinis on Thursday and Friday!
hana pestleSeptember 19, 2011tomato basil soup is really not that amazing. grilled cheese was nummy though.
Kelly KathrynJuly 27, 2013The ranch dressing was watery and disgusting. I got the Thanksgiving Dinner in July and my cranberry sauce was missing and had to ask for it twice. Service was decent at best.
168 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
New Brunswick's favorite spot for a satisfying meal and a cold drink since 1984. Stop by for our generously portioned pub classics and more.
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 4:00 PM–11:00 PM
- Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
(732) 846-6153
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Diners Club & Visa)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Music
Live Music
Dining Options
Bar Service
Parking
Street, Public Lot, Private Lot
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, Happy Hour, Bar Snacks
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.2
"First place I ever went to in New Brunswick. Great food made even greater with good company. Try the Chicken and Spinach Boli!"
Dustin Ramsdell - 8.3
"BBQ Chicken Panini is my favorite, but everything on the menu tastes great, excellent service and only closed from 3-8 am!"
Eric James 
"This place is hugely underrated. Quality food & nice dining area"
Paul
Places people like to go after Old Man Rafferty's
- 8.4
"Super confortable! Very nice staff! Expensive popcorn!"
Erika Arrea - 7.9
"Beer selection is great, for a wed night after work client meeting-it was perfect! Not too loud. Calamari and tomato/portabello appetizers get an A+"
RJ - 8.5
"I've seen some of my favorite comics there, they get all the top comedians. Food wise their burgers and paninis are the best! (I usually get the Vinnie panini)"
Cyd Katz
Appears on 47 lists
Created by Jimmy Kastner
23 items • 68 followers
Must-visit Bars in New Brunswick
Created by Bansri Bhatt
17 items • 16 followersCreated by Krissy K
10 items • 6 followers