- ice cream
- sandwiches
- good service
- family-friendly
- coffee
- (15 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- Joanna BonnerAugust 9, 2017Burger of the week was very juicy, fresh, and flavorful. The free ice cream at the end of the meal was a nice touch. The ice cream is available to purchase by the quart as well.
- My favourite sandwich is the Reuben - a must! With each order of sandwich, you get a sampler of their amazing frozen custard; just three flavours: vanilla, chocolate, and the flavour of the day!
- Brian K. GrimFebruary 3, 2013This isn't ice cream - it's custard, and it's amazing! A full food and coffee menu is available, but ask anybody who's visited Cumberland and they'll know the "ice cream" served at the Creamery!
- JeffJune 4, 2013The sandwiches are very good and big enough to be shareable, particularly to save room for the complimentary small ice cream cone. My 89 yo father-in-law loved this place as did we.
- CandyJanuary 3, 2014Awesome food! Love trying the flavors of the day whenever I can, but my favorite is Death by Chocolate!
- Georgia NasiosAugust 7, 2014I've only had the ice cream here - actually it's custard - and it's delicious!! Worth the stop and cost to try the custard.
- JMarch 27, 2016Panini of the week is almost always delicious, and the ice cream/milkshakes are incredible
- Nice people, good service, great ice cream. The sandwiches are meats and vegetables on a wrap. Extremely plain and not tasty. Soups are just cans heated up, unfortunately.
- The chocolate malts are so good that I almost have one a day when I'm in town!
- Allen GuarinJune 16, 2013I thought with "Creamery" in their name they'd have a plethora of flavors but they only have vanilla, chocolate and their flavor of the day. Oh and they serve custard not ice cream.
- Very good sandwiches and ice cream. They always have a new daily flavor and they are usually very tasty :)
- Get the Reuben... seriously... And the Ham and Bean soup, if available! The cornbread with it ROCKS!
- Good service, great ice cream and soups. Expensive but good. Sandwiches/wraps are so-so.
- The flavor of the day is almost always great! Today it's German chocolate cake. Bought some. Delishhhh.
- Carrie ZDMay 5, 2013They give you a little cone while you wait for your food - can it get any better?!?
- When winter comes around, grab a free travel cup or ice scraper!
- Love this place, but paying $10 for a chicken salad sandwich is nuts!
- Matty RyanJanuary 20, 2016This place used to be great a few years back. Now the portions are small, prices outrageous, and staff is very rude. Unfortunately, despite having been here a lot, I won't be returning.
- Victoria FrancesJanuary 9, 2013Raved to a friend about how amazing this place was. And it used to be. Paid 10$ for three milkshakes that were all really thin and super bland. Yuck! You have one more chance!
- While the food might be alright, the custards and ice creams are amazing!!
- Sachin DJune 5, 2012No ice cream here at all...just custard. If you're craving ice cream, don't come here, cause there's none.
- Just paid $10 for a turkey wrap. How is this place still in business!?