Important Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.RedEye Coffee Midtown
Coffee Shop and Café$$$$
Tallahassee
Ranked #4 for coffee shops in Tallahassee
"Top 3 drinks in order: Cafe con leche, Cortadito, Cafe Cubano."(5 Tips)
"They also serve cafe cubano and cortadito."(3 Tips)
"Best coffee (and chai!!!) and best baristas in town."(15 Tips)
"... money to put toward humanitarian efforts."(3 Tips)
57 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- coffee
- chai
- café
- cortadito
- bagels
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Corinna HoffmanAugust 2, 2013On the way to Jacksonville & I needed a caffeine fix for the road. I wanted a local business instead of Starbucks. Glad I found this place! Cafe con leche is SO good and wakes you up! Nice staff too!
Upvoted Sep 7
Convenient location. Good coffee. I like their sushi, too. I try to ignore the fact that by going here, I'm financially supporting a church that likely fundamentally disagrees with my lifestyle.
Sarah TMarch 19, 2014If you get the chai latte, you won't regret it. And use a for-here cup if you can! Less waste and it's a cute mug :)
Stella G.February 18, 2016Best cafe con leche north of Miami. And the staff is great. Non of that coffee snobbery stuff.
Jonathan WebberAugust 28, 2014RedEye's dark roast coffee is very good. Recommended if you are just looking for a cup of black coffee. I'm always looking for a cup of black coffee.- One of the few places in town with cafe con leche worth drinking. They also serve cafe cubano and cortadito.
- Give back your cup sleeve when you're done. They'll reuse it, save on supply costs, and have a little more money to put toward humanitarian efforts.
Specialty drinks and the Nitro brew are fantastic. But I usually just go for a brewed coffee
Open 6:30 a.m.-10 p.m. daily & closed Sundays. Relaxing atmosphere away from the jumble of Starbucks without the "scenester" crowd of All Saints. Perfect for studying, chatting with friends or a profe
Tim NettlesNovember 2, 2014Best in town! The only place I know of that lets you toast your own bagel if you want to. This place is great!
The chai latté is fantastic. Great place for meetings and study time.
Rebecca MorseSeptember 9, 2010Go to Red Eye and get yourself a coffee or tea. By patronizing Red Eye you're supporting humanitarian efforts as well. It's a great way to drink a coffee while you save the world.
Love the chai latte! Sweet with a hint of spice. Blows star bucks version out of the water
Andrew LittlefieldOctober 27, 2012You could try a cortadito or a con leche...if you're a weakling. Cafe Cubano will make you an immortal. Make it a double.- Alex WorkmanAugust 7, 2014Great coffee. Loud environment. Can't wait till the fall so it is cooler to sit outside.
Victoria LubachMarch 19, 2017Has really been a hit or miss for me. Had the nitro brew each time I've been here and the last few times it tasted burnt?? Bitter?? Just off.
Sophie HartApril 20, 2015Yes the blueberry bagel was exceptional. I liked the ice coffee but it wasn't anything remarkable. Inside was very noisy and outside wasn't much better. Service was very friendly.- Wi-Fi tends to be very spotty. Hangs and resets connection every few minutes. Happens on my phone, tablet, and laptop.
One of the few places in town to get almond milk in your coffee. That's a win for me!- Best coffee (and chai!!!) and best baristas in town. Also great live music some weekends!
This is my favorite coffee place in Tallahassee. So much better than Starbucks. I love the chai latte and the blueberry bagels.
How about trying an Italian Soda. My favorite = Mango w/ half the amount of syrup they would use conventionally. So refreshing!
redeye was my second home in tallahassee. i love this place. get the chai and the vanilla muffin.
If you need a caffeine fix, I suggest the cafe con leche or cortadito...both are delicious and can keep me going for hours!!
Try the Cortadito! In a for-here mug you might get some artistic love.
- Top 3 drinks in order: Cafe con leche, Cortadito, Cafe Cubano. Tasty!!!!
- The best thing to get here is a Chai Latte with soy milk. So goood!
Coffee of the Day! Usually 2, Go with which ever they suggest! :-)- Dan MeyerFebruary 24, 2012throw some cash in the "humanitarian efforts" bin and help build a house in Guatemala.
Zack JohnsonMarch 17, 2011Coffee here is not so good. Been disappointed on many occasions. Got a French press that was weak and swimming with grounds. Espresso drinks are okay, for the most part.
- Julie RobertsFebruary 3, 2010try the hot chocolate - great when you want something warm, but not the caffeine
86 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
RedEye Coffee Midtown
1122-7 Thomasville Rd (5th Ave)
Tallahassee, FL 32303
United States
Tallahassee, FL 32303
United States
Drink coffee locally. Change lives globally.
Open until 10:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 6:30 AM–10:00 PM
(850) 425-5701
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
See More
You might also like
- 8.2
"The english muffin with sausage is great for breakfast"
Joel McAllister - 7.1
"The Toffee Nut/Hazelnut Italian Soy Cream Soda is amazing."
Desirée Amadeo - 9.0
"This is a place to buy whole bean coffee roasted on site. A full espresso and brew bar is available for drinks, but the focus is on home coffee supply. Come here for the freshest coffee in Tally!"
Colin Frew
Places people like to go after RedEye Coffee Midtown
Appears on 39 lists
Created by Amanda Thomas
14 items • 7 followers
Created by Joel Scott
28 items • 11 followers
Created by Morgan B
99 items • 175 followers