Important Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
"Tried the lobster salad on a bagel finally, holy cow, so damn good."(17 Tips)
"White fish salad is really good too."(10 Tips)
"Get a bagel with cream cheese and lox! Heaven...."(4 Tips)
"super delicious and bagel with cream cheese/lox"(2 Tips)
40 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- bagels
- lox
- sandwiches
- chicken & waffles
- lunch specials
- (6 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
ZenFoodsterSeptember 22, 2014Reminder for next visit: don't get the whitefish salad one rye bread-it's too salty! On a toasted bagel is best. And a bialy possibly better? Nevertheless, the whitefish is like crack!
Lobster Salad Sandwich was kick ARSE! But the best item for me was the Lobster Clam Chowder, better then the soups you order from the majority of seafood restaurant PERIOD!- ZenFoodsterOctober 24, 2013I'm hooked! Love their whitefish salad & lobster salad (w/ bits of celery & not too mayoey) sandwich was a deal for $12.99! ;9
Sarina BloodgoodOctober 8, 2017Beet salad, with beets legit the size of a small child (they're massive!), and half-sours reign supreme at this UES staple.- Em LFebruary 11, 2012Everything I tried was delicious. The lobster salad super tasty can taste the lobster. The shrimp salad has whole shrimps. White fish salad is really good too.
- Andrew CMarch 21, 2016very expensive bagel / deli joint but super delicious and bagel with cream cheese/lox had so much spread onto it!!
HillelJanuary 7, 2018Lox, scallion cream cheese, bagels, pastrami, sable, herring and all the other smoked fish.
Get the whitefish salad to go and get bagels a couple of blocks south to H&H for a bagel.
Baked salmon salad on a bagel. Quarter-pound lobster salad on the side.
Claudia DavisAugust 4, 2012My fav is the crab salad but I also love the whitefish salad and lobster salad.
The Corcoran GroupMay 24, 2011Think out of the box and try the Lobster Sushi Roll. Or be more conservative and dive into their Famous Lobster Salad Sandwich.
Joanna ChuOctober 7, 2013Try the Lobster salad on a roll. Or crab salad on a toasted bagel. Both good.
Best lox in the city! Perfect for a NYC Sunday bagel breakfast!
Russell HirschornApril 21, 2013Lobster and whitefish salad delish. Salmon salad was too fishy for my liking.
Gansevoort Hotel GroupOctober 27, 2011The bagels are amazing but the spreads are unreal!! Try the whitefish salad!!!
- Sample of lobster salad tasted great, will try it next time, meanwhile the smoked salmon on a bagel was scrumptious.
- Tried the lobster salad on a bagel finally, holy cow, so damn good.
jake furstNovember 7, 2011ironic for a jew spot, but get the lobster salad. hat tip to @charlesbirnbaum
Kerrie MartinOctober 13, 2013Staff was rude, they also they didn't honor their special because I used a groupon to get my food. They also threw away my groupon & said I had to redeem it all at once which in my experience is a lie
67 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 8:30 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 8:30 AM–7:30 PM
- Sat
- 7:30 AM–7:30 PM
(212) 249-6177
See More
You might also like
- 8.7
"can't go wrong with any choice of salami. the portuguese rolls are my favorite. then the italian baguette, followed by the sourdough."
iza p - 8.9
"Best pickles NYC. The spicy spicy ones in particular. Closed on Saturday but open Sunday all day."
Emilie Futterman - 9.3
"Not just amazing bagels but perfect nosh for hosting, not to mention wonderful old-school service"
Jeremiah Baumann
Places people like to go after Sable's
- 9.7
"Great park to walk and bike. Enjoyable. Always something going on. Kayak, merry go round, zoo, concerts, playground"
Angi W - 8.3
"Love this place! Just gotta say a free pickle spear with my sandwich really would make this place that much more authentic."
Brad Emo - 9.5
"Awesome collection. You can spend days trying to see everything. Great accessibility."
Filipe Leite
Appears on 111 lists
New York City's Top 10 Lobster Rolls
Created by The Corcoran Group
10 items • 195 followers
The Best of the Upper East Side
Created by The Corcoran Group
25 items • 110 followers
Created by jake furst
18 items • 97 followers
