Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
  • Photo taken at Sallys Sweet Shoppe by Ep W. on 9/14/2011
  • Photo taken at Sallys Sweet Shoppe by Jayson M. on 9/10/2013
  • Photo taken at Sallys Sweet Shoppe by Mary Jane S. on 9/10/2011
  • Photo taken at Sallys Sweet Shoppe by scrapchick on 11/22/2013
  • Photo taken at Sallys Sweet Shoppe by Ep W. on 9/1/2011
Sallys Sweet Shoppe

Sallys Sweet Shoppe

Bakery$$$$
Genesee Depot
Save
Share
Sallys Sweet Shoppe
8.2/10
12
ratings
Photos5 Photos
MenuMenu
Menu 9
Breakfast Pastries‏
We bake everything from scratch, w/ our own hands & recipes, right here in our kitchen. We need 24 hours notice in most cases, sometimes longer, but we can also accommodate some orders in as little as a half an hour! We have a zillion flavor ideas, so just ask
Large Baked Donuts
0.60 .70 each
Muffin Tops
1.75
Jumbo Cheesecake Muffins
2.50
Bear Claws/Turnovers
2.50
Kringle, Whole
7.95
5 pieces
Baked Donuts
.30 each
Muffins
1.00
Jumbo Muffins
2.00
Scones
2.25
Kringle, Piece
1.70
Breakfast Cakes
Sour Cream Cinnamon
2.95
Oatmeal Applesauce Cake
2.95
9” (Whole) Breakfast Cake
15.00
Monkey Bread
1.95
Stuffed Croissants
3.20
Fruit & Oatmeal Crisp
15.00 - 19.50
Bread Pudding Choc, Cinn
2.25
Buttermilk Crumb Cake
2.75
Cinnamon Crumb Cake
2.75
¼ Sheet Breakfast Cake
19.50
Sticky Buns
1.90
Cinnamon Roll Croissants
2.60
Chocolate Hazelnut Pillows
1.95
Mini Banana Bread
2.25
Desserts‏
We make them all! You never know what you’ll find in our cases & we’d be happy to make anything for you – yes anything! Please call for suggestions, ideas, inspiration, pricing & of course, to place your order
Pies
Tiramisu
Tortes
Cream Puffs
Pastries
Cheesecakes
Cupcakes
Crostadas
Cakes
éclairs
Specialties
Cookies, Regular
0.50
Cookies, Large
1.00
Cookie Cupcakes, Large
1.95
Brownies
3.00
Fudgey, blonde, Mexican chocolate, etc
Marshmallow Treats
2.25
Kit Katty Bars
2.50
Turtles
1.50
Pretzel, pecan, walnut, cashew, almond
Sally's Whoopee Pies
3.75
Granola
6.50
Honey, peanut butter, chocolate
Cookies, Regular, Dozen
4.95
Cookie Cupcakes, Regular
0.75
All Butter Cut Outs
2.00
Prices, shapes vary
Real Lemon Bars
3.00
Snickery Bars
2.50
Peanut Butter Bars
2.50
Cake Truffle Balls
1.75
Alfred Lunt's Fudge Cake
3.25
Beverages‏
Coke (24 Oz Btl) Products
1.75
Ass’T Teas
1.50
Water Bottle
0.95
Starbucks House Blend Coffee
1.50
Milk
1.75
1% by the glass
Breads
We make our breads from scratch & each batch. Each day, we make soft white & english muffin bread & up to 3 other kinds. We make 1 pound loaves, but can make any size. Call for today’s flavors!
3 Oz. Sandwich Rolls
3.25 - 6.00
Hard Rolls
3.25 - 6.00
Cranberry Walnut or Sunflower
5.25
Foccacia
4.50
Oatmeal Applesauce
4.75
Cinnamon Swirl
4.25
W/ raisins, or prices vary
Savory Monkey Bread
4.75
Challah
6.00
Mulit-Grain
5.25
Soft White Bread
3.25
English Muffin Bread
3.25
Honey Whole Wheat Bread
4.75
Dill Cottage Cheese Bread
5.25
Italian &/or French
4.25
Cardamom Bread
4.50
Rye or Twisted Rye
4.75
Brioche
6.00
Kolache
6.00
Cheese
4.75
Asiago, cheddar
Special Occasion Cakes & Cookies‏
Novelty & drawing charge of 5-10 for character cakes
All of our cakes are made from scratch, by hand, for your order. Therefore, we require no less than a 4-day notice to prepare your cake. Now, we should probably tell you, we make cakes. Not sculptures, cakes. Our cakes are big, & heavy, & full size & do not require a second mortgage. It’s a cake
6”, Round
12.00 - 15.00
9”, Round
18.00 - 27.00
12”, Round
22.00 - 48.00
½ Sheet Cake
32.00 - 43.00
8”, Round
16.00 - 21.00
10”, Round
19.50 - 35.00
¼ Sheet Cake
22.00 - 23.00
Cupcakes
We have created dozens & dozens of fun flavors like turtle, dark chocolate truffle filled, peanut butter cup, chocolate cream pie, black forest, cookies & cream, cheesecake, boston cream pie, & pumpkin
We make three sizes: mini, regular, & jumbo & they range from.75 - 4.25. order times vary greatly. Our website has some great creations or give us a call & we’ll chat about what you’d like us to create for you

Problem with this menu?

Related Searches

  • sallys sweet shoppe genesee depot •
  • sallys sweet shoppe genesee depot photos •
  • sallys sweet shoppe genesee depot location •
  • sallys sweet shoppe genesee depot address •
  • sallys sweet shoppe genesee depot •
  • sally's sweet shoppe genesee depot •
  • sallys sweet shoppe genesee depot •
  • sallys sweet stuff genesee depot •

Foursquare © 2024  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA

Compass icon
Sallys Sweet Shoppe
S42W31370 State Hwy 83
Genesee Depot, WI 53127
United States
Get directions
Information icon
A small batch, from scratch little bakery in the heart of historic Genesee Depot. We start each day fresh with breakfast pastries, 3-4 different breads, cookies, bars, cupcakes, desserts, candies, and we also make celebration cakes & cookie cakes!
Clock icon
Open until 2:00 PM (Show more)
  • Tue–Fri
    • 6:30 AM–2:00 PM
  • Sat–Sun
    • 8:00 AM–Noon
Phone icon
(262) 968-1803
World Wide Web icon
Facebook icon
Sally's Sweet Shoppe
Twitter icon
@sallyssweetshop
Features
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
See More

Appears on 1 list

United States » Wisconsin » Waukesha County »

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.