Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
  • Photo taken at Sandwich Theory by Phynjuar P. on 6/13/2012
  • Photo taken at Sandwich Theory by Nina W. on 7/6/2013
  • Photo taken at Sandwich Theory by Alexi-Rae W. on 4/26/2014
  • Photo taken at Sandwich Theory by Nina W. on 7/6/2013
  • Photo taken at Sandwich Theory by Alexis B. on 8/29/2013
  • Photo taken at Sandwich Theory by Marybeth H. on 7/17/2013
  • Photo taken at Sandwich Theory by Nina W. on 7/6/2013
  • Photo taken at Sandwich Theory by Marybeth H. on 6/26/2013
  • Photo taken at Sandwich Theory by Nina W. on 7/6/2013
Sandwich Theory

Sandwich Theory

(Now Closed)
Sandwich Spot and Deli$$$$
Montclair
Save
Share
Sandwich Theory
Photos9 Photos
MenuMenu
Daily Special 6Beverages 19Daily Specials 5Breakfast 6Lunch 5Snacks & Sweets 11Beverage 12Full Menu 8
Breakfast‎
Turkey Sausage
5.95
Provolone and mushroom omelet with home fries and toast
Egg Whites
4.95
Turkey bacon, cheddar cheese and salsa in a wrap
Potato
3.25
Egg and cheese on a round roll
Vegetable Cream Cheese on Choice of Bagel
2.75
Flavored coffee of the day orange cappuccino
Lunch‎: Soup
Split Pea Small
3.35 - 4.35
Spinach mushroom barley large chicken orzo
Turkey and Black Bean Chili
4.75
Lunch‎: Sides
Grilled Organic Tofu and Vegetables
Beet Salad
Grilled Asparagus
Lunch‎: Salad
Grilled Chicken Over Romaine
7.75
Applewood bacon, avocado, grilled green beans, tortilla chips with ranch dressing
Lunch‎: Sandwiches
Grab and Go – ½ Black Forest Ham
6.95
Swiss, lettuce and tomato with dijon mustard on peasant with choice of small soup or small garden salad
Grilled Salmon
8.40
Arugula, avocado, roasted red pepper with oil and vinegar on multi-grain hero
Grilled Flank Steak with Muenster Cheese
7.25
Sauteed‎ mushroom and onions on a baguette
Grilled Chicken
7.95
Fresh mozzarella, avocado, hot banana peppers with herb mayo on ciabatta (pressed)
Smoked Turkey
7.45
Applewood bacon, avocado, roasted red pepper with ranch dressing on whole wheat ciabatta (pressed)
Fresh Mozzarella with Tomato
5.75
Fresh basil and olive oil on ciabatta
Fresh Brewed‎
Organic Iced Tea
Iced Coffee
Fresh Squeezed‎
Orange Juice
12 and 20 Oz
Lemonade
(Seasonal) 16 • 20 • 24 oz
Juices‎
Nesquik
Chocolate 16 oz
Apple and Eve
16 Oz apple juice cranberry concord grape ruby red grapefruit pomegranate blueberry strawberry mango passion
Poland Spring
Sparkling water 16.9 oz original lemon lime orange
Poland Spring Water
Apple and Eve
Juice box 6.75 oz very berry fruit punch apple
San Pellegrino
Sparkling water 8.5 oz
Smart Water
24 Oz
Drinks‎
Horizon
Chocolate milk 8 oz
V‐8
12‎ Oz
Naked Smoothie
10 Oz berry blast green machine mighty mango
San Pellegrino
(Can) 11 oz aranciata limonata
Fiji Water
Tropicana
Orange juice 14 oz
Zico Coconut Water
14 Oz natural tao mango
Orangina
16 Oz
Vitamin Water
20 Oz essential power‐c revive xxx
Soda‎: Soda
20 Oz
Diet Coke
Pepsi
Sprite
Canada Dry Ginger Ale
Diet Dr. Pepper
Coke
Caffeine Free Diet Coke
Diet Pepsi
Sprite Zero (Diet)
Dr. Pepper
Fresca
Soda‎: Stewart's
12 Oz
Diet Root Beer
Root Beer
Soda‎: Boylan's
12 Oz
Birch Beer
Diet Creme
Orange
Black Cherry
Creme
Ginger Ale
Cane Cola
Soda‎: Mash
20 Oz
Pomegranate
Lemon Peel
Ripe Mango
Grapefruit
Soda‎: Izze
12 Oz
Grapefruit
Clementine
Blackberry
Iced tea‎: Snapple
16 Oz
Peach Tea
Green Tea
Diet Lemon Tea
Diet Raspberry Tea
Diet Half and Half
Diet Plum‐a‐Granate Tea
Kiwi Strawberry
Mango Madness
Orangeade
Pink Lemonade
Raspberry Peach
Lemon Tea
Raspberry Tea
Lemonade Iced Tea
Diet Peach Tea
Diet Green Tea
Diet Trop‐a‐Rocka Tea
Snapple Apple
Lemonade
Diet Noni Berry
Peach Mangosteen
Pomegranate Raspberry
Iced tea‎: Organic Honest Tea
16.9 Oz
Peach White Tea
Honey Green Tea
Half and Half
Iced tea‎: Body Armor
16 Oz
Cherry Citrus
Strawberry Banana Guava
Tropical Mandarin
Iced tea‎: Joe Tea 20 Oz
Lemon Tea
Peach Tea
Lemonade
Peach Half and Half
Ginseng Green Tea
Raspberry Tea
Lemon Half and Half
Raspberry Half and Half
Iced tea‎: Joe Tea
16 Oz
Low Sugar Green Tea
Unsweetened Black Tea
Diet Lemon Tea
Iced tea‎: Inko's White Tea
16 Oz
Lemon
Blueberry
Unsweetened Original
White Peach
Honeydew
Iced tea‎: Sweet Leaf Organic Tea
20 Oz
Peach Tea
Mint and Honey Green Tea
Lemon Tea
Half and Half Lemonade Tea
Iced tea‎: Steaz Organic Tea
16 Oz
Peach
Mint
Blueberry
Apple & Eve Fruitables‎
12 Oz
Tropical Orange
Berry Berry
Breakfast‎
Spinach, Mushroom, Provolone Omelet with Home Fries and Toast
5.95
Egg White, Turkey Bacon, Salsa in a Wrap
4.75
Flavored Coffee of the Day
Super chocolate supreme
Potato, Egg, Cheese on Round Roll
3.75
Vegetable Cream Cheese on Choice of Bagel
2.75
Lunch‎: Soup & Chili
Potato Leek
3.35
Small (12 oz. )
Spinach Mushroom Barley
Chicken Rice
4.35
Large (16 oz. )
Turkey and Black Bean Chili
4.75
Large (16 oz. )
Lunch‎: Sides
Beet Salad
Grilled Green Beans
Tomato and Cucumber Salad
Salad
Sautéed jumbo shrimp over romaine, roasted red peppers, grilled asparagus, avocado, balsamic vinaigrette
Sandwiches‎
Grab and Go – ½
6.95
Tuna salad, jarlsberg, lettuce, tomato on peasant bread with choice of small soup or small garden salad
Grilled Salmon
8.40
Roasted red peppers, arugula, avocado, dill sauce on ciabatta
Roast Beef Sloppy Joe
7.95
W/swiss, coleslaw, russian dressing on rye
Grilled Chicken Wrap
8.25
W/pepper jack cheese, avocado, sour cream and salsa
Smoked Turkey
6.95
Brie cheese, honey mustard, lettuce, tomato on multi grain
Eggplant Cutlet, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers, Sun Dried Tomato Pesto on Whole Wheat Ciabatta
7.45
Specialty Breakfast Sandwiches‎
Scrambled Eggs, Black Forest Ham and Swiss on a Croissant
3.95
Scrambled Eggs, Pepper Jack and Bacon with Salsa in a Wrap
3.75
Healthy Wrap
4.95
Four egg whites, roast turkey, havarti in a whole wheat wrap
Fried Eggs, Sausage and Cheddar on an English Muffin
3.75
Taylor Ham, Fried Egg and American Cheese on a Bagel
3.75
Whole Wheat French Toast with Egg Whites and a Side of Fresh Fruit Salad
4.95
Specialty Omelets‎
All omelets are served with home fries and toast (substitute fruit salad for 1.00 more)
Pico De Gallo Omelet
6.25
Mushrooms, hot peppers, onions, tomato and provolone
Western Omelet
6.75
Diced ham, mixed bell peppers, red onion and cheddar cheese
Greek Omelet
7.25
Grilled chicken, tomato, onions, avocado and feta cheese
Mediterranean Omelet
6.95
Fresh mozzarella, roasted red pepper and spinach
Veggie Omelet
6.25
Grilled vegetables and swiss cheese
Cereal‎
Homemade Oatmeal Made with Brown Sugar and Cinnamon with Your Choice of Fruit
2.50
Apples, bananas, blueberries, dried cranberries, raisins or strawberries
Organic Granola with Fresh Blueberries and Milk
3.50
Starting at
Bagels‎
Plain
Everthing
Sesame
Cinnamon Raisin
Poppy Seed
Whole Wheat
Muffins‎
Served with your choice of spread
Banana Nut
Cappuccino
Corn
Raisin Bran
Plain Cream Cheese
Olive Cream Cheese
Honey Walnut Cream Cheese
Peanut Butter
Apricot Preserves
Strawberry Preserves
Blueberry Crumb
Chocolate Chip
Cranberry Walnut
Vegetable Cream Cheese
Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese
Butter
Grape Jelly
Raspberry Preserves
Specialty Sandwiches‎
Smoked Turkey and Havarti
6.25
With honey mustard on peasant bread
Black Forest Ham and Brie
6.45
With honey mustard on a baguette
Roast Beef and Havarti
6.75
With herb mayo on peasant bread
Black Forest Ham and Jarlsberg
6.75
With honey mustard on whole wheat ciabatta
Roast Beef and Brie
6.75
With honey mustard on a baguette
Tuna Salad and Jarlsberg
6.45
Served‎ on peasant bread
Tarragon Walnut Chicken Salad
6.75
Served on ciabatta
Smoked Turkey and Jarlsberg
6.45
With herb mayo on peasant bread
Genoa Salami and Provolone
6.25
With roasted peppers and herb mayo on a baguette
Mozzarella and Prosciutto
6.75
With roasted peppers on a baguette
Blackened Chicken Salad
6.75
Served on peasant bread
Mozzarella and Sun Dried Tomatoes
5.95
Served on a baguette lettuce, tomato and onion added upon request
Grill Pressed Sandwiches‎
Cuban
6.95
Roast pork, ham and pepper jack cheese with pickles and russian dressing on a baguette
Grilled Chicken Panini
7.25
With mozzarella, roasted red peppers and pesto on peasant bread
Avocado Dream
7.25
Grilled vegetables, ripe avocado, provolone cheese, tomato with pesto on multi-grain
Panini Capresse
7.45
Fresh mozzarella, arugula, grilled vegetables, sun dried tomatoes on whole wheat ciabatta
Black Forest Ham and Gruyere
6.95
With dijon mustard on peasant bread
Reuben
6.45
Corned beef and swiss with sauerkraut and brown mustard on rye
Smoked Turkey
6.95
With brie cheese, sliced apple and honey mustard on multi grain
Grilled Cheese
4.50
With choice of cheese and bread
Wraps‎
Turkey Club Wrap
6.95
Smoked turkey, bacon and cheddar with lettuce, tomato and herb mayo
Asian Grilled Chicken Wrap
6.75
With‎ scallions, cucumber, romaine lettuce, cilantro, tomato and hoisin sauce
Chicken Caesar Wrap
6.75
Grilled‎ chicken with bacon, tomato, romaine, parmesan and caesar dressing
Veggie Wrap
6.95
Grilled‎ vegetables, havarti cheese, sun dried tomatoes, arugula with balsamic vinaigrette
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
6.75
Grilled chicken with bleu cheese, celery, lettuce, tomato and spicy mayo
Roast Beef Wrap
6.95
With cheddar, red onions, lettuce, tomato and horseradish mayo
Sloppy Joe Wrap
6.95
Roast beef, roast turkey, swiss, coleslaw and russian dressing
Choice of Wraps
Whole wheat • sun dried tomato • spinach
Salads‎
Garden
4.95
Mixed greens, shredded carrots, cherry tomatoes and cucumbers with balsamic vinaigrette
Goat Salad
8.95
Mixed greens, grilled chicken, goat cheese and walnuts with balsamic vinaigrette
Greek Salad
5.95
Romaine, feta cheese, black olives, red onion, green peppers, cucumbers and tomatoes with balsamic vinaigrette
Blackened or Tarragon Walnut
7.95
Garden salad topped with one of our specialty chicken salads
Soups
3.35 - 4.35
Choose from our daily selection
Bleu Salad
8.45
Mixed greens, grilled chicken, bleu cheese and walnuts with balsamic vinaigrette
Asiago Salad
7.95
Mixed greens, grilled chicken, asiago cheese and sun dried tomatoes with balsamic vinaigrette
Chicken Caesar Salad
7.75
Grilled chicken, romaine, parmesan cheese, home-made croutons with caesar dressing
Cobb Salad
8.95
Grilled chicken over romaine with hard boiled eggs, bacon, avocado, tomato and bleu cheese with mustard vinaigrette
Chips‎: Small (2 Oz.)
Sea Salted (Plain)
Sea Salt and Vinegar
Sour Cream and Onion
Funky Fusion
Cracked Pepper and Sea Salt
40% Reduced Fat Sea Salted
Mesquite B.B.Q.
Sweet Potato
Jalapeno Heat
Maui Onion
Sundried Tomato Basil
Chips‎: Smart Fries
Classic Sea Salt
Garlic Rosemary
Whole Wheat
Multi Grain
Vinegar Splash
Pretzels
Oat Bran
Chips‎: Large (5 Oz.)
Sea Salted (Plain)
Sea Salt and Vinegar
Mesquite B.B.Q.
Chips‎: Pop Chips
Origina1
Sour Cream and Onion
Pop Corners
Kettle
Barbeque
Cheddar
Sea Sa1T
Butter
Chips‎: Nuts
Pistachios
Health Mix
Lay's Baked Potato Chips
Wasabi Peas
Hippie Mix
Chips‎: Cookies
Chocolate Chip
Oatmeal and Raisin
White Chocolate Macadamia
Heath Bar Crunch
Oreo Crush
Chips‎: Brownies
Plain
Pecan
Coconut Dream
Walnut
Cappuccino
Cookies and Cream
Chips‎: Misc
Lemon Squares
Cheese Sticks
Rice Crisps
Chips‎: Candy
Tic Bans
Skittles
Swedish Fish
Gum
Go Lean Bars
Starburst
Lollipops
Tic Tac
Chocolate‎
Equal Exchange Organic Chocolate Minis(Milk/Dark)
Ghiradeli Squares (Carmel/Mint)
Lindt Chocolate Truffles (Milk/Dark)
M and M's (Peanut)
Fresh Brewed‎
Small 16 oz • medium 20 oz • large 24 oz
Iced Coffee
Organic Iced Tea
Fresh Squeezed‎
Orange Juice
12 and 20 oz
Lemonade (Seasonal)
Juices & Drinks‎
Nesquik Chocolate 16 Oz
Very Berry
Apple
Apple Juice
Naked Smoothie 15.2 Oz
Green Machine
San Pellegrino Sparkling Water 16.9 Oz
Original
Lime
Raspberry Lime
Poland Spring Water
Chocolate
Vanilla
V-8 12 Oz
Natural
San Pellegrino (Can) 11 Oz
Limo N at A
Vitamin Water 20 Oz
Essential
Revive
Fiji Water
Apple and Eve Juice Box 6.7S Oz
Fruit Punch
Apple and Eve 16 Oz
Cranberry
Blue Machine
San Pellegrino Sparkling Water 8.5 Oz
Poland Spring Sparkling Water 16.9 Oz
Lemon
Mandarin Orange
Smart Water 24 Oz
Horizon Milk 8 Oz
Low Fat
Tropicana Orange Juice 14 Oz
Zico Coconut Water 14 Oz
Orangina 16 Oz
Aranciata
Aranciata Rossa
Energy
Power-C
Xxx
Small 5Ee Ml • Large 1 Liter
Soda‎: Soda 20 Oz
Coke
Coke Zero
Seagram's Ginger Ale
Diet Dr. Pepper
Diet Coke
Sprite
Dr. Pepper
Fresca
Soda‎: Mash 20 Oz
Ripe Mango
Grapefruit
Pomegranate
Lemon Peel
Soda‎: Stewart's 12 Oz
Root Beer
Boylan's 12 Oz
Diet Black Cherry
Creme
Orange
Diet Root Beer
Black Cherry
Birch Beer
Diet Creme
Cane Cola
Soda‎: Izze 12 Oz
Clementine
Blackberry
Grapefruit
Soda‎: Snapple 16 Oz
Lemon Tea
Raspberry Tea
Half and Half
Diet Peach Tea
Diet Green Tea
Diet Trop-a-Rocka Tea
Snapple Apple
Lemonade
Orangeade
Pink Lemonade
Raspberry Peach
Peach Tea
Green Tea
Diet Lemon Tea
Diet Raspberry Tea
Diet Half and Half
Diet Plum-a-Granate Tea
Kiwi Strawberrry
Mango Madness
Peach Mangosteen
Pomegranate Raspberry
Cranberry Raspberry
Soda‎: Joe Tea 2E Oz
Lemon Tea
Unsweetened Black Tea
Low Sugar Green Tea
Raspberry Tea
Lemon Half and Half
Raspberry Half and Half
Lemon Zero Tea (Diet)
Ginseng Green Tea
Peach Tea
Lemonade
Peach Half and Half
Soda‎: Inko's White Tea 16 Oz
Unsweetened Original
Blueberry
Organic Honest Tea 16.9 Oz
Peach White Tea
Sweet Tea
White Peach
Honeydew
Honey Green Tea
Half and Half
Soda‎: Body Armor 16 Oz
Strawberry Banana Guava
Snacks and Sweets‎
Dirty Chips
1.26
Penny Stick Pretzels
1.75
Fresh Baked Cookies
0.55 each
Brownies 1.50
Lemon Squares
2.00
Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Oreo, or 3 for White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, Heath Bar
1.50
Snacks and Sweets‎: Bottled Drinks
Snapple
1.86
Water - 16Oz
1.00
Joe Tea - 16Oz
1.75
Sodas
1.86
Juices
2.25
Water - 1 Liter
2.00
Joe Tea - 20 Oz
2.25
Breakfast‎
With your coffee
Scrambled Eggs, Black Forest Ham and Swiss on a Croissant
3.95
Scrambled Eggs, Pepper Jack and Bacon with Salsa in a Wrap
3.75
Healthy Wrap - Four Egg Whites, Roast Turkey, Havarti in a Whole Wheat Wrap
4.95
Bagels and Spreads Choice of Bagels: Plain, Sesame, Poppy, Cinnamon Raisin, Whole Wheat, Everything
1.00
Assorted Muffins
1.50
Blueberry, cranberry orange, banana nut, cappuccino, carrot cream cheese, corn, french vanilla or croissant
Fried Eggs, Sausage and Cheddar Cheese on an English Muffin
3.75
Taylor Ham, Fried Egg and American Cheese on a Bagel
3.75
Whole Wheat French Toast with Eggwhite and Side of Fresh Fruit Salad
4.95
Scones
2.00
Cranberry-orange, blueberry
Specialty Sandwiches‎
Smoked Turkey and Havarti
6.25
With honey mustard on peasant bread
Black Forest Ham and Brie
6.45
With honey mustard on a baguette
Roast Beef and Havarti
6.75
With herb mayo on peasant bread
Black Forest Ham and Jarlsberg
6.75
With honey mustard on whole wheat ciabatta
Roast Beef and Brie
6.75
With‎ honey mustard on a baguette
Tuna Salad and Jarlsberg
6.45
Served on peasant bread
Tarragon Walnut Chicken Salad
6.75
Served on ciabatta
Smoked Turkey and Jarlsberg
6.45
With herb mayo on peasant bread
Genoa Salami and Provolone
6.25
With roasted peppers and herb mayo on a baguette
Mozzarella and Prosciutto
6.75
With roasted peppers on a baguette
Blackened Chicken Salad
6.75
Served on peasant bread
Mozzarella and Sun Dried Tomatoes
5.95
Served on a baguette
Specialty Sandwiches‎: Wraps
Turkey Club Wrap
6.95
Smoked turkey, bacon and cheddar with lettuce, tomato and herb mayo
Asian Grilled Chicken Wrap
6.75
With scallions, cucumber, romaine lettuce, cilantro, tomato and hoisin sauce
Chicken Caesar Wrap
6.75
Grilled chicken with bacon, tomato, romaine, parmesan and caesar dressing
Veggie Wrap
6.95
Grilled vegetables, havarti cheese, sun dried tomatoes, arugula with balsamic vinaigrette
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
6.75
Grilled chicken with bleu cheese, celery, lettuce, tomato and spicy mayo
Roast Beef Wrap
6.95
With cheddar, red onions, lettuce, tomato and horseradish mayo
Sloppy Joe Wrap
6.95
Roast beef, roast turkey, swiss, coleslaw and russian dressing
Grill Pressed Sandwiches‎
Cuban
6.95
Roast pork, ham and pepper jack cheese with pickles and russian dressing on a baguette
Grilled Chicken Panini
7.25
With mozzarella, roasted red peppers and pesto on peasant bread
Avocado Dream
7.25
Grilled vegetables, ripe avocado, provolone cheese, tomato with pesto on multi-grain
Panini Capresse
7.45
Fresh mozzarella, arugula, grilled vegetables, sun dried tomatoes on whole wheat ciabatta
Black Forest Ham and Gruyere
6.95
With‎ dijon mustard on peasant bread
Reuben
6.45
Corned‎ beef and swiss with sauerkraut and brown mustard on rye
Smoked Turkey
6.95
With‎ brie cheese, sliced apple and honey mustard on multi grain
Grilled Cheese
4.50
With choice of cheese and bread
Grill Pressed Sandwiches‎: Salads
Garden
4.95
Mixed greens, shredded carrots, cherry tomatoes and cucumbers with balsamic vinaigrette
Goat Salad
8.95
Mixed greens, grilled chicken, goat cheese and walnuts with balsamic vinaigrette
Greek Salad
5.95
Romaine, feta cheese, black olives, red onion, green peppers, cucumbers and tomatoes with balsamic vinaigrette
Blackened or Tarragon Walnut
7.95
Garden salad topped with one of our specialty chicken salads
Bleu Salad
8.45
Mixed greens, grilled chicken, bleu cheese and walnuts with balsamic vinaigrette
Asiago Salad
7.95
Mixed greens, grilled chicken, asiago cheese and sun dried tomatoes with balsamic vinaigrette
Chicken Caesar Salad
7.75
Grilled chicken, romaine, parmesan cheese, home-made croutons with caesar dressing
Cobb Salad
8.95
Grilled chicken over romaine with hard boiled eggs, bacon, avocado, tomato and bleu cheese with mustard vinaigrette

Problem with this menu?
Compass icon
Sandwich Theory
590 Valley Rd
Montclair, NJ 07043
United States
Get directions
Information icon
Serving an enticing array of sandwiches, soups, salads and entrees, Sandwich Theory has a formula for everyone. You can experiment with something new everyday with our great daily specials.
Clock icon
Permanently closed (Show more)
  • Mon–Fri
    • 7:00 AM–6:00 PM
  • Sat
    • 8:00 AM–5:00 PM
Phone icon
(973) 746-5666
World Wide Web icon
Twitter icon
@sandwichtheory1
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch
See More

You might also like

Places people like to go after Sandwich Theory

Appears on 6 lists

See all
United States » New Jersey » Essex County » Montclair »

Is this your business? Claim it now.

Make sure your information is up to date. Plus use our free tools to find new customers.