Star Tavern Pizzeria

Star Tavern Pizzeria

Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$
Orange
Save
Share
9.1/10
346
ratings
  • Tips
    Serious Eats
    "... pizza you will eat, Star Tavern is definitely worth the detour or trip,..."(5 Tips)
    Anthony C.
    "The best thin crust pizza in Northern New Jersey."(16 Tips)
    Greg L.
    "You also have to try the scampi wings"(3 Tips)
    Kenneth R.
    "This is the best thing crust pizza in Northern New Jersey."(2 Tips)
Tips and Reviews icon90 Tips and reviews
Filter:
  • pizza
  • star tavern
  • chicken wings
  • good for groups
  • casual
User icon
Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:
  • Popular
  • Recent
  • Serious Eats
    Serious EatsJanuary 2, 2014
    With some of the best bar-style pizza you will eat, Star Tavern is definitely worth the detour or trip, especially for the pizza enthusiast.
  • Kenneth R.heart icon on user image
    Kenneth RodriguezOctober 18, 2015
    This is the best thing crust pizza in Northern New Jersey. If you've ever eaten at Patsy's in NYC then you'll know what I'm talking about. The place has a laid back and comfy atmosphere. Food's great.
    Upvoted 5 days ago
  • Jason L.heart icon on user image
    Jason LinkinsNovember 29, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    You'll never know for certain if Jesus loves you unless you eat at Star Tavern and then you will always know that he loves you more than anyone because this pizza is DOPE AF!!!
  • Xavier J.heart icon on user image
    Xavier JenkinsSeptember 26, 2014
    Been here 25+ times
    Of course the pizza is kick a$$. But so is everything else. Calamari is really good. If you don't have the kids with you, try sitting at the bar. You'll save wait time on a busy night!
  • Jason G.
    Jason GelmanAugust 10, 2013
    Greatest thin crust pizza of all time. Get garlic and/or pepperoni for toppinga. Dont be afraid to use wing sauces (ranch or hot) on your pizza!
  • Tyrell B.heart icon on user image
    Tyrell BrownAugust 13, 2014
    Been here 5+ times
    This establishment has the BEST pizza in the area! I've been coming here for years, and no longer order from other local places or even the chains (i.e., Domino's, Pizza Hut, Papa John's).
  • Melissa S.heart icon on user image
    Melissa S.August 5, 2014
    Melt-in-your-mouth, ultra-thin, cheesy, savory goodness. On my short list of must-try pizza joints. Arrive early to avoid long wait for a table, but it's worth it.
  • Douglas M.heart icon on user image
    Douglas M.February 3, 2017
    Excellent thin crust pizza. Particularly liked the sausage. Be prepared to wait for a table..
  • Mary K.heart icon on user image
    Mary KJanuary 13, 2016
    Best pizza I've ever had, hands down. Plain, sausage, or pepperoni is where it's at.
  • Anthony C.
    Anthony CascioApril 22, 2012
    The best thin crust pizza in Northern New Jersey. They also make a mean peppers and eggs sandwich. Be prepared to wait 45 minutes. The place hasn't changed a bit in 50 years.
  • New Jersey Pictures
    New Jersey PicturesMarch 18, 2012
    Starving after seeing that Resnais triple feature? You can't beat Star Tavern pizza. Thin, crunchy with the perfect amount of cheese. Best pizza in NJ, hands down.
  • Marie D.
    Marie DesdunesAugust 22, 2010
    Best pizza I ever had. I no longer can eat pizza anywhere else local bc nothing compares. the eggplant parm dinner is the amazing also, its the eggy kind NOT to bready like some other places make it.
  • lisa D.heart icon on user image
    lisa DavisJune 10, 2016
    Pizza was great, the sauce is awesome. And if you like thin crust them this definitely the place for you
  • NJ.com
    NJ.comJanuary 13, 2014
    Don't be fooled by the sports-bar atmosphere. This is a Jersey pizza shrine. Read more
  • Jo-Ann M.heart icon on user image
    Delicious white pizza! Great eggplant parm.
  • Keith J.heart icon on user image
    Keith JohnsonJanuary 18, 2018
    Been here 5+ times
    Best pizza in the country!👍🏻
  • Laura C.
    Laura CrokerDecember 31, 2012
    Been here 10+ times
    Best pizza in the state but if you order more then one don't expect it to all come at once it almost never dose
  • Justine B.
    Justine BurkeFebruary 22, 2011
    Best thin crust pizza in NJ... the pizza is INSANE! and in Jan and Feb, Tues nights = $5 plain pie night! A STEAL if you can fight the lines!
  • Nick L.heart icon on user image
    Nick LeeApril 5, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    I've been coming here since I was a very young kid. Unparalleled.
  • Jack G.heart icon on user image
    Jack GashiNovember 30, 2014
    Legendary thin crust NJ pizza. A hungry 175 pound male can easily house a pie; order accordingly.
  • Matthew F.heart icon on user image
    Matthew FronheiserFebruary 25, 2016
    It's pretty good pizza. Atmosphere feels like a bar. We came on a rainy wed night and didn't have to wait at all.
  • Scott H.heart icon on user image
    Scott HollomanOctober 7, 2017
    Pizza is the Best in the state.
  • Scott H.heart icon on user image
    Scott HollomanOctober 7, 2017
    Hennesy and atmosphere pizza is top of industry.
  • Lesley
    LesleyJune 16, 2011
    The original thin crust tomato is heavenly. Also try the three cheese. The pizza here is the best pizza I have ever had.
  • Jeannette L.heart icon on user image
    Jeannette L.June 26, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Tip for the meal budget conscious - No free refills. You pay for each one. Keep that it mind.
  • Greg L.
    Greg LoughlinAugust 10, 2014
    Great thin crust pizza. You also have to try the scampi wings
  • Richard R.heart icon on user image
    Richard RevillaAugust 24, 2016
    Some very good thin crust pizza. Service could use an uptick.
  • Mike Mahdavi N.heart icon on user image
    Best Piza in the neighborhood for sure if it’s NOT the Best in Jersey
  • Michael C.heart icon on user image
    Michael CornerstoneAugust 2, 2016
    Come for the pizza, stay for the chicken wings!
  • Edd H.heart icon on user image
    Edd HannayDecember 22, 2017
    Really good thin crust pizza
  • Sadira H.heart icon on user image
    Sadira HassellJanuary 18, 2020
    Been here 25+ times
    Calamari is the best in town.
  • Vansiheart icon on user image
    VansiMay 21, 2019
    The ricotta no sauce one is great!
  • Terry
    TerryAugust 29, 2010
    Lost my virginity here tonight.. First time here, first time eating a pizza with anchovies and first time drinking rolling rock beer.. Anything on the menu is good
  • Leigh-Ann Z.
    Leigh-Ann ZaolinoJune 30, 2013
    Penne with vodka sauce and chicken is wonderful
  • Russell S.heart icon on user image
    Russell SiminoffDecember 21, 2018
    Been here 25+ times
    Best pizza in NJ!
  • Jeannette L.heart icon on user image
    Jeannette L.June 26, 2015
    Been here 5+ times
    Along with thin slice pizza, makes awesome hot wings. Yum!
  • Xavier J.heart icon on user image
    Xavier JenkinsFebruary 15, 2015
    Been here 25+ times
    Red spinach pie with added sausage. POW!
  • Gary S.heart icon on user image
    Gary SurvisMarch 18, 2018
    White pizza...spinach onion broccoli
  • Rell
    RellMarch 13, 2013
    Onion Blossom! Great appetizer!
  • D.j. C.
    D.j. CremeFebruary 23, 2012
    Whole wheat pizza thin crust in the best!! Ohh yeah and the buffalo wings!!
  • Jennifer
    JenniferApril 19, 2010
    You have to try ANY pizza from Star Tavern. They have the best thin crust pizza in NJ! Read more
  • Emily B.
    Emily BaerJanuary 6, 2014
    Can't go wrong with white clam pizza
  • Lauren D.
    Lauren DJune 22, 2011
    Pizza = AMAZING!!! Long lines on weekends but definitely worth the wait
  • Jonathan L.
    Jonathan L.December 4, 2022
    This place is a 1 & done for me. Extremely underwhelming pizza. Flappy crust, lackluster sauce, & lack of overall depth of flavor on the pizza. Crappy service too.
  • janelle g.
    janelle guntherNovember 25, 2017
    Arrive early. As in, well before 5pm on a Saturday.
  • Denise D.heart icon on user image
    Denise D.March 6, 2020
    Delicious thin crust pizza.
  • Mike R.heart icon on user image
    Mike RosenthalJanuary 21, 2016
    Pizza!! Especially Tuesdays in January
  • Adriane
    AdrianeDecember 9, 2013
    Make sure to order it well done!
  • Jala Y.
    Jala YoungOctober 28, 2014
    I luv the Caesar salads so amazing 😊
  • Justin B.
    Justin BrownMay 4, 2011
    Been here 10+ times
    Best damn pizza hands down, and the Bufflo wings rock!!
Photos181 Photos

Related Searches

  • star tavern pizzeria orange •
  • star tavern pizzeria orange photos •
  • star tavern pizzeria orange location •
  • star tavern pizzeria orange address •
  • star tavern pizzeria orange •
  • star tavern orange •
  • star tavern and pizzeria orange •
  • star tavern pizzeria orange •

Foursquare © 2024  Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA