See all
62 photos

The Guthrie Inn

Cocktail Bar$$$$

East Harlem, New York

Save

The Guthrie Inn

8.3^/10

120

ratings

Ranked #10 for authentic places in East Harlem
"This place is awesome, try the gin sling or the sharpie mustache."(2 Tips)
"If you find yourself uptown - nice little hidden spot near our apt."(3 Tips)
"Great little date spot or catchup spot..."(3 Tips)
"They are the only legit cocktail bar open late during weekends."(2 Tips)

35 Tips and reviews

Filter:

good for dates
sharpie
sling
trendy
hole in the wall
bar
great value
restaurants
music
gin
hospital
(6 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Kevin AppelMay 11, 2012
Been here 10+ times
The menu drinks are all phenomenal, but if you can't quite decide, ask the knowledgeable staff for a recommendation or try some of their unusual, amazing spirits. They'll find you the perfect drink!
Andrew TayoMay 25, 2013
Been here 10+ times
This place is a hidden neighborhood gem with a nondescript door next to Earl's beer & cheese. The bar is small, dark, and intimate. Tino is an expert barman. Ask him about his pooch @ home.
GothamistFebruary 5, 2015
East Harlem's not known for harboring sexy date spots, but this relative newcomer's a pretty good neighborhood spot to bring a special someone. Check out cocktails like the Sharpie Moustache, Read more
Harlem AmbassadorJune 4, 2013
This place needs outdoor seating desperately as it can only fit a few friends with dates in tow. Notable wines and beers. Gets quite crowded in the evening hours so prepare yourself. Hip and fun vibe.
LoveLiliSeptember 5, 2013
Great little date spot or catchup spot... Warm hospitality, Vintage feel and unique spirits make this place a little gem.
CompassApril 25, 2014
Blink and you’ll miss the bright red door, old-fashioned cocktails, and crowd-pleasing mac ‘n cheese at this tiny drinking gem.
Sandro LipariApril 26, 2015
They are the only legit cocktail bar open late during weekends. The bartender is legend, excellent music selection
Leanne ZDecember 17, 2015
Good cocktails and a friendly atmosphere. Good for groups and late night.
Allison JonesJune 8, 2013
If you find yourself uptown - nice little hidden spot near our apt.
Tom GuthrieApril 9, 2017
Great drinks, fun bartender, good music. Go here.
Kay NguyenSeptember 29, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Great hidden gem of a cocktail bar in East Harlem.
Christophe JammetMay 13, 2016
Been here 10+ times
The best cocktail bar north of 96th Street.
Peter ElbaorDecember 16, 2017
Intimate, low key, solid cocktails
Renae MasonAugust 18, 2016
Great cocktails and friendly bartenders!
Renae MasonJuly 23, 2015
Nice craft beer on tap and friendly bar staff.
Ashley ChaseJuly 25, 2012
Amazing cocktails! Perfect place to catch up with a someone.
Onyi NwosuAugust 24, 2013
This a proper bar with a proper bartender that actually makes proper drinks.
Peter ZanghiAugust 1, 2017
hidden gem. great cocktails.
John MarksFebruary 12, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Order the Manhattan, and ask for a Heineken!
Shamil TurnerJanuary 19, 2013
Head to the back room, really chill communal spot.
Stephen D'AmicoJuly 28, 2013
This place is awesome, try the gin sling or the sharpie mustache.
Ethan MennenJuly 8, 2012
Order the Expat. Perfect for summer.
Ethan MennenJuly 8, 2012
Great bourbon selection.
AmateurConciergeFebruary 8, 2015
The perfect Harlem hole in the wall cocktail joint
Ryan GallagherJanuary 12, 2016
Cool little cocktail spot.
Jeffrey RSeptember 10, 2013
Min of 20 to use card, small place, no food, meh good beer and drinks
Samantha NowakMay 27, 2012
Awesome cocktails. Great spot.
Jimmy MurphyFebruary 4, 2015
The porcellina is crazy good.
Dartagnan DelgadoSeptember 18, 2013
Porcelains, need I say more!!
Greg ServisJanuary 7, 2015
Whiskey and cocktails
Hayley D.September 29, 2012
Leather room!
Dartagnan DelgadoSeptember 18, 2013
Porcelinas, need I say more!
Carlos RodriguezApril 17, 2013
Fantastic White Russian.
Christophe JammetSeptember 26, 2013
Been here 10+ times
This bar is dope!
GeorgeJanuary 27, 2019
Looking closed.

62 Photos

The Guthrie Inn

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after The Guthrie Inn

Appears on 232 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.