Important Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.The Hideaway
Mexican Restaurant and Breakfast Spot$$$$
Montauk
"Mexican corn w mahi mahi tacos w nachos w spicy peach margaritas."(7 Tips)
"Get the fish tacos but beware, they cost about a thousand dollars"(9 Tips)
"Best mole ever and chicken tinga rocks"(2 Tips)
"The pulled pork tacos and margaritas make a great Saturday."(6 Tips)
41 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- Mexican corn
- margaritas
- chicken tinga
- sangria
- quesadillas
- (9 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Raj S.August 6, 2012Incredible Mexican food tucked away from the street. Truly a gem. Came here for breakfast one day and was blown away. Everything tasted so fresh. Will be coming back here for sure.
christian svanes koldingJuly 12, 2017the kind of place that white people call "authentic." décor provided by modelo while the only mexicans present are working behind the counter. on the plus side, not a single finance bro or hipster.
Elyse EstradaJuly 12, 2017Get the quesadilla it's incredible! The nachos are amazing but huge so def go splitty splitty with a friend.
Lydia Li EnglishSeptember 8, 2019Great little spot. We went on a Saturday night and there was lively ambience. Margaritas are amazing!!!!!
Shiri LaraJuly 3, 2016Good tacos and corn. It's a pricey divey spot but it's Montauk. I would say go for the ambiance.
Maria AydagAugust 9, 2013Nachos with chicken Tinga- Mexican Corn- the kids loved the steak tacos and burritos
Zack BeattySeptember 29, 2014Grilled veggie taco were excellent, but ask for a side of refried black beans.
- Noah XifrAugust 27, 2015Mexican corn w mahi mahi tacos w nachos w spicy peach margaritas. #WonderFULL #food #joy
It's all about the pulled pork tacos & getting a snarky retort from Sushil.
James MacfarlanJune 28, 2015Food portions are on the small side but high quality. Coffee is average, small and no refills. Music is cool
Prices have jacked up. No longer a secret. Nothing special anymore :'( Still good for a margarita tho
Emily WilsonJuly 4, 2017Mexican corn, chips and guac, fish tacos. Relaxed, local vibe. Nice little hideaway in Montauk (see what I did there? ;))
Heather FinkJune 12, 2012Meh. Not sure why the rave reviews but it's def not bad and I quite appreciate the foursquare drink special.
- Emily WilsonJuly 4, 2017Mexican corn, chips and guac, fish tacos. Relaxed, local vibe. Nice little hideaway in Montauk (see what I did there? ;))
106 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Authentic Mexican Food, St. Louis Style Barbecue, and Steamed Local Seafood.
Closed until Noon tomorrow (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- Noon–11:00 PM
(631) 668-6592
Features
Reservations
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.3
"Fluke Ceviche + Duck Fried Rice Barbacoa + Tres Leches Cake"
Rachel W. - 6.6
"Delicious and cheap Mexican breakfast - a must try! A definite hidden gem. Homemade spicy sauce is the icing on the cake"
Jennifer Cacace - 8.0
"This place is amazing! Can't go wrong w really anything but the nachos and quesadillas are my favorite!"
Olivia Fabbro
Places people like to go after The Hideaway
- 6.9
"Fat Radish chef is doing good work. Kale Caesar, Burger, and Swordfish come highly recommended. Don't forget to say hi to Colin behind the bar."
jared zlotnick - 8.2
"Great burgers and great ice cream. Get here early they run out of flavors."
Ryan Gallagher - 8.1
"Beautiful views! The bartenders are great!!"
Jennifer Giardina
Appears on 177 lists
Created by Kortney B
199 items • 25 followers
Created by Samantha
121 items • 17 followers
Created by Andrea Barrezueta
53 items • 22 followers