See all
400 photos

The Island Fish Company

Bar, Seafood Restaurant, and American Restaurant$$$$

Marathon

Save

8.4^/10

287

ratings

"Have you tried the Macho Chicken Nachos or the Grouper Sandwich?"(9 Tips)
"End the experience with the key lime pie, best I've had in the area."(5 Tips)
"Gotta try the deep fried key lime pie!"(2 Tips)
"... GOOD! Calamari, conch ceviche & fresh blackened fish sandwiches are tasty..."(2 Tips)

86 Tips and reviews

Filter:

seafood
grouper sandwich
key lime pie
scenic views
spicy food
conch fritters
casual
breakfast food
good for groups
good for dates
great value
healthy food
quiet
lunch
bar
dinner
wraps
brunch food
appetizers
parking
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Heather PommernelleFebruary 5, 2012
Conch fritters - lots of fried dough. Try the ceviche
Gilbert LApril 14, 2013
Gotta try the deep fried key lime pie!
Catherine MonkJune 17, 2013
The grouper sandwich is unbelievable!!!
Val PentonSeptember 23, 2016
The oysters are the best.
Carl RamalloMay 27, 2014
Nice hangout.
Debbie TramelJanuary 2, 2012
Great breakfast and bloody marys sitting on the dock!
Erin BiggMay 25, 2013
The grouper sandwich is awesome!
Chris TiedjeSeptember 7, 2013
Jalapeño corned beef hash FTW!
Joe GulinoSeptember 1, 2015
Grouper and Conch Ceviche
Lauren Santa CruzJanuary 3, 2011
Order the bloody Mary and add some tobasco!!! Amazing!
Carl RamalloMay 27, 2014
Nice place.
Gideon OlshanskyMarch 19, 2016
Good location. Decent food.
Tara GangiJanuary 22, 2011
Try the conch cerviche, it was reallllly good!
DilekAugust 30, 2023
Good view, good food
Philip RijkersJuly 13, 2016
Beware of the oysters
Kathy KerlickMay 6, 2017
The setting mostly
Cindy Guardado-ValenteAugust 12, 2012
Stuffed shrimp!! Omg luv'd it!!
Derek ScottJune 28, 2021
Clans are unreal
@SoFLBrgOverloadSeptember 21, 2012
Been here 25+ times
Yani & Tiffany are the best bartenders.
Carl RamalloMay 27, 2014
Nice Water View.
Leslie BakerFebruary 3, 2012
Excellent conch fritters!
Carla HeavenridgeAugust 4, 2013
Lobster sandwich rocks!!!!!!
Vanessa MolinaMay 10, 2011
Been here 5+ times
The fried calamari is to die for!
Jack SollowayNovember 3, 2015
Good food.
Kim MorrisMarch 7, 2013
Great food and atmosphere!!
J DMarch 3, 2011
The seafood combo is excellent!
Teesha Gilbert-KinseyOctober 16, 2015
Oyster shooter
Susan 🌸May 30, 2013
Great shrimp tacos
Carlos OspinaDecember 25, 2015
Bluecrab with shrips
Kyle GayDecember 24, 2013
Crab cakes!
Janne GravelSeptember 7, 2013
Food not that great. Baked oysters overcooked! Rudest waiter ever. A real jerk. Wouldn't go back!
Marc VazMarch 18, 2012
The calamari was nice
CJ WeeksJuly 27, 2011
The sweet tea taste like poo
Joe TaulbeeJuly 28, 2013
Eh... Expensive and food is so-so
Armando NascimentoOctober 24, 2016
Sensacional! Comemos o Stone Crabs e estava perfeito!
Dmitriy GolosnoyDecember 27, 2020
Отличный вид. Вкусная еда. Брал кашу с креветками, рекомендую.