32 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
14850 DiningSeptember 16, 2013The square deep-dish pizza is the Nines's forte, with a broad array of toppings and a thick crust. The four square slices easily feed two or three people, four if you add appetizers.
Alexa SternSeptember 9, 2017Trivia is weirdddd but the deep dish is great! Beware that there is not AC so super hot when it gets crowded
Ukemeabasi EsietAugust 24, 2011The deep dish pizza is worth the wait. If the weather's nice get a seat outside and enjoy the sights and sounds of Collegtown
Daniel GasteigerOctober 9, 2014Place hasn't changed since I left Ithaca in 1983. For pizza it's pricey, but several cuts above competitors' product.
Corn nuggets: the most decadently scrumptious fried food on the planet! The regular pizza is just regular; you come to the 9s for the deep dish, which takes forever to cook, but worth it!
Tom GowingMay 21, 2011The place to go for deep dish pizza in Ithaca. Also toppings are done by the slice, so easy to split with friends!
Steph FellAugust 9, 2013Good food, cheap beer ($4-$5 16 oz and $12 for a pitcher). Check out the live bands playing here
- 14850 DiningAugust 3, 2011In a rush? Decide fast what you want and order as soon as you sit down. Better still, call in your order before you show up. Those pizzas take a while.
Corn nuggets ... Ithaca beer ... "Deep dish" pizza ... A wonderful trifecta!
Definitely go with the deep dish pizza! Try the nachos too!
Cesar R.August 18, 2014Corn nuggets + pints of Ithaca beer. Thank god the nines didn't go like the others..
Cornell UniversityMay 18, 2010Named for the truck that once occupied this former fire station, The Nines is the place for deep dish pizza in Collegetown. Read more
Jack HJuly 27, 2013Beer is warm and the food is cold! Watch as the patio turned over TWICE before we got our food. Over 2.5 hours for 3 pizzas. Manager thought %10 off and we should thank him.
Olivia JohnsonFebruary 25, 2012Don't get an appetizer. They don't bring it until after you get your pizza.
@mouselinkJuly 6, 2012Waiting an hour for a pizza when you are the only ones in the entire restaurant ordering ... I don't know how anyone can do business like that. Worst service in Ithaca?
Tyler SuessAugust 20, 2010Cheese garlic bread & meatball sub were good but nothing special... food took FOREVER... service ehhhh.
Nicole RodriguezApril 21, 2012Worst service ever.. We were seated and never got served.. Went on down the road to CTB! not worth the wait
Diane VinchDecember 31, 2012The service here always kills me. Always slow, and brush cut man with a beard behind the bar was so rude to my sister when they screwed up her order. But the deep dish pizza is so delicious.
92 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Great pizza, deep dish & regular. Full bar. Live music several nights a week
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 11:30 AM–1:00 AM
- Sun
- 3:30 PM–1:00 AM
(607) 272-1888
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Dinner
Drinks
Beer, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after The Nines
- 7.7
"Get basically every cookie, excellent all around!"
Thisfatkidtravels - 8.3
"Chicken Noodle(Poultry), Cream of Tomato with Basil(Cream and Veggie), and Chilled Gazpacho(Vegan)"
Collegetown Bagels - 6.8
"I LOVEEE this place!! Every time I am in Ithaca, I come to this Starbucks & only this one. The people are super friendly, and their coffee is delish!! Get the Chai, it's amazing!!"
Mike Mcfall
Appears on 26 lists
Created by Eating Ithaca
8 items • 8 followersPlaces I would like to eat in Ithaca
Created by Leonard S
41 items • 7 followersCreated by Chelsea Hartman
59 items • 9 followers