Times Square Pizza
(Now Closed)Pizzeria$$$$
Walker's Point, Milwaukee
30 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Try the Duck Po Boy - holy damn i should've bought two. any sane carnivore in the greater MKE area: if you're smart, you'll come out and grab one before they run out of duck!
Gotta try the Flat Bread Salad. It's the best of both worlds! A salad and some cheesy pizza dough. :)
Jeighsen ChristiansenOctober 9, 2013Try a couple of different pieces of hand made Atomic Chocolate Company, for a chocolate buffet.
If the weather is cooperating and there are peanut butter cups (that tricky caramel!) you must eat one!!... with pretzel is best.
Amazing pizza. Sean owns the place, and totally knows what he's doing. His hand made chocolates are incredible too! Give it a shot. Well worth it!
Everything I've tried here is spectacular. Partial to the meatball and chicken carciofi sandwiches. Delish!
Stephanie CombsOctober 26, 2011Everything is AMAZING. Plus the owner(sean) very cool dude and makes awesome chocolates too!
If the slice of the day is baked potato, dance like you just won the lottery... because you just did.
Carissa GingrasMay 18, 2010Times Square Pizzeria -- also home of Atomic Chocolate Company. Sean's chocolates are awesome, but I'm particularly fond of sea salt caramels. Read more
Daily specials are innovative and incredible. Location is very strange! This place also makes some awesome chocolate!
Jim SchenkelbergOctober 28, 2010Get the Szechuan wings! Even better than the pizza. Also, don't forget a sea salted caramel.
I agree that the pizza is amazing, but try the lasagne. Truly addictive.
55 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
New York style pizza! Whole pies or by the slice. Also home of the Atomic Chocolate Co. Handmade single origin chocolates.
(414) 224-6300
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
See More
You might also like
- 8.0
"One of the best pizzas in town. Call ahead, plan ahead - wait times can be long... but worth it. Get the stuffed pie."
Rob Dusseau - 8.3
"My family has been coming to this location since they opened and the original location off Center St. since I was born (over 40 years!). The best pizza in town. Very fair prices especially w/ coupons."
Jennfer Michel - 9.2
"Excellent pizza, divine salmon bruschetta, super strong martini's and the service was top notch too!"
N G
Places people like to go after Times Square Pizza
- 7.4
"Great happy hour Monday-Friday with cheap drinks, great music and a wacky, yet inviting, atmosphere."
Spike - 8.2
"Happy hours rock. The DJs are good. They have drag shows too, which can be super lively. Bartenders are always cute."
Billie Hawkins - 5.4
"Good in a pinch. The Mac junior is just the right size."
jiresell
Appears on 8 lists
Created by Best of Foursquare
10 items • 25 followers
Created by Best of Foursquare
10 items • 1 follower
Created by Aryn Zahnow
40 items • 16 followers