See all
53 photos

Traders Store and Cafe

Seafood Restaurant$$$$

Sanibel

Save

8.0^/10

ratings

Ranked #4 for seafood restaurants in Sanibel
"Danny Morgan on Thursday nights for the best Island music"(3 Tips)
"My favorite dinner restaurant on Sanibel Island."(2 Tips)
"Grilled portabello and lobster ravioli"(3 Tips)
"... encrusted salmon and triple tail, we shared, and couldn't decide which was..."(2 Tips)

34 Tips and reviews

Filter:

danny morgan
good service
happy hour
great value
trendy
good for dates
discounts
good for working
island
dinner
music
bar
lunch
horseradish
good for special occasions
grouper
eateries
portobello mushrooms
gift shop
appetizers
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Jon ArendtApril 30, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Terrific food. Easily one of the top on the island. Fish specials are always good, as is the lobster ravioli that comes with some. Traders is one of the few consistently good ones here.
Andrea D'AmbrosioNovember 1, 2015
My favorite dinner restaurant on Sanibel Island. Everything on the menu is fantastic! And it has the best gift shop
Mindy PierceFebruary 13, 2013
Come when Sanibel legend Danny Morgan is performing! Oh- and the food is amazing too! We'll be back for Valentine's Day!
JerryNovember 17, 2016
Been here 10+ times
Traders Store and Cafe is one of the best eateries on Sanibel. Lunch and dinner is wonderful here. Eat in the bar area for a fun experience.
Jerry EdelmanOctober 31, 2013
This is our "favorite" restaurant on Sanibel. We eat there at least once a week. Great food and great service and then there's Leslie our greatest server. Going tonight, see you there.
Maurice SmithJanuary 3, 2013
Highly recommended and for good reason! The bartender remembered us and our drinks! LOVE this place!!!
Erin HelgrenJuly 6, 2013
Great place for family dinner. If the Shellfish Pasta is one of the daily specials, order it. Amazing. !
Kelly LilesMay 14, 2012
Grilled portabello and lobster ravioli isdelicious!! 3-6 happy hour and smaller portions make for perfect dinner and drink!
Lauren Lohmann HoeschenOctober 26, 2013
Shrimp and crab cocktail delish! But it is a huge portion
Christopher LongJanuary 3, 2015
In general, overpriced for the quality of the food. Oysters were good, as were the PEI Mussels. Scallops with Lobster Ravioli (pictured) was fine; Sea Bass was fishy and very disappointing.
Libby McMillanApril 8, 2010
Trader's has a great happy hour, fom 4-6 pm, with discounted appetizers and drinks. On Tuesdays and Thursdays island troubador Danny Morgan heats up the bar with live music til the wee hours.
MLe BAugust 18, 2013
Nice place! Went for lunch and got the grouper... Super yummy and good service.
Dale SuslickJune 1, 2012
Great dinner on 6/1/12!!! Wonderful service. BIG portion of lobster, shrimp & more that two of us spilt #Value
Ryan StonerOctober 28, 2012
Stoner family local favorite in the island. Enjoy great island food with friends.
Jeff BowserJuly 23, 2011
Some of the best fish entrees I've had anywhere, ever. Horseradish encrusted salmon and triple tail, we shared, and couldn't decide which was better.
Kim N CarswellJuly 8, 2013
Ask for Parmesan cheese to drizzle on fresh bread after a dip of spiced olive oil
NicoJanuary 7, 2013
Specials are always good. Gumbo is top notch. Ahi tuna is personal fav.
Cole SmithMay 23, 2018
A bit more of an upscale option, but the food is pretty excellent.
PowderfingerMarch 22, 2012
Ethan W. (who said this place wasn't very good) obviously has a stocked stuck up his ass. Food (and ambience) here is fantastic.
Doug CullenFebruary 1, 2012
Forget the apple crisp. Mud pie all the way. Wow. And I live apple stuff.
Marisa MacKayDecember 23, 2011
Been here 5+ times
Budget tip: go for lunch! (11am-2pm) great food with half the price and no crowd!
MAMA JJanuary 22, 2015
Awesome. Highly recommend !!!!
AcclaimPOS.com BjornOctober 2, 2013
Been here 50+ times
New RAW bar at Traders!
Chelle WaltonApril 13, 2012
We islanders consider this out go- to place for dependable excellence.
FLAfamilyguruOctober 18, 2014
Triple tail with sun-dried tomato sauce
Christina KDecember 17, 2011
Come for the oysters, stay for the port (30 yr).
Colleen BlackMarch 15, 2015
Yum ahi tuna is the bomb!
Mercedes McCay-ReadJanuary 29, 2012
The horseradish salmon was to die for!
AcclaimPOS.com BjornMarch 13, 2010
Been here 50+ times
Great Food and Service at a good price. Danny Morgan on Thursday nights for the best Island music
Marty HallNovember 6, 2016
Blue crabcakes were okay. Do not order the lamb. Looked like it was done in a vrockpot. No seasoning. Well done. Tasted like unseasoned roast beef. Very disappointed.
Marisa HathawayMay 18, 2015
Had jumbo stuffed shrimp
Ethan WestonMay 17, 2011
This place isn't very good. Definitely not the best on the island as is claimed.
Bob KingApril 7, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Best lunch om island.
Gadi ShamiaNovember 24, 2011
If you like overpriced, pretentious and mediocre food- this is your place.

53 Photos

Traders Store and Cafe

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Traders Store and Cafe

Appears on 26 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.