"Excellent Alfredo, huge ravioli, yummy meatballs!"(6 Tips)
"wood fired oven adds taste to every bit of pizza."(14 Tips)
"... The decor is fitting. Sangria was very good and the calamari was very..."(3 Tips)
"Seafood Portalino was wonderful"(6 Tips)
See what your friends are saying about Nonna Lisa's.
By creating an account you are able to follow friends and experts you trust and see the places they’ve recommended.
orSign up with email
46 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- sangria
- tours
- Stromboli
- good for groups
- meatballs
- (10 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- Douglas WaggonerAugust 6, 2013try their wood oven fired pizza. Its about the best pizza I have had, and the wood fired oven adds taste to every bit of pizza. get some when you are in mackinaw City, you wont regret it.Upvote4Downvote
Ava KeuschMay 4, 2018Everything I have eaten is excellent. Great service and portions are huge. The ambiance is relaxing at the same time. I have been here numerous times over the years and have never been disappointed.UpvoteDownvote- Jennifer BobergJune 18, 2014Looks like a hunting lodge but they know how to make good Italian food! Delicious Sangria, amazing crab stuffed portobello mushroom appetizer. Excellent Alfredo, huge ravioli, yummy meatballs!UpvoteDownvote
Camille McCombsSeptember 6, 2016The mussels are amazing! Great flavor. The chicken caesar was also delicious. We just stopped in for a light lunch, but we can't wait to go back for dinner!UpvoteDownvote
BrenJuly 3, 2012We had delicious food, the Noona's Tour was more than enough for 1 person. It is somewhat loud.The decor (you are in the north woods) was interesting, liked the ambience of the Christmas lights.UpvoteDownvote
Kellee AbozoglaiAugust 2, 2013Took 15 minutes to get waited on after we were seated... Had to go to the host stand to get a server.However, the calamari, sangria, chicken parm and pasta Alfredo were very good. Zachariah was great!Upvote1Downvote
Joe LeigebJune 22, 2017The atmosphere is really cool, the servers are very friendly, and the pizza looked pretty good. I had the chicken Alfredo, and minestrone soup. It sucked. Not homeade.UpvoteDownvote- Karen DavisJune 21, 2013This is Michigan. The decor is fitting. Sangria was very good and the calamari was very good too !! I think this is a great place to eat !!UpvoteDownvote
Jessie WSeptember 27, 2016Really cool lodge type atmosphere. Great Italian food and good service! Recommend the ravioli - they are huge!!!UpvoteDownvote
Debbie PAugust 16, 2012The food is very good , the portions were generous, waitstaff very knowledgable. We thought the prices were fair & the decor was lodge like.Upvote2Downvote
Bill OstrowskiAugust 19, 2014Pizza was very good. Also the garden salad that my wife ordered was very tasty too.Upvote1Downvote
Julie McMahonAugust 17, 2013They offer a Gluten free menu with a few options from each section if menu; ONLY place in Mackinac we found to do so.UpvoteDownvote
David RSeptember 9, 2013Get the Stromboli (regular or Lisa's special stromboli) and split it. It is huge!UpvoteDownvote
Julie WiebengaSeptember 11, 2013Spaghetti with marinara sauce is great. Menu is pricey.UpvoteDownvote
Evvia MarshallAugust 24, 2014The pizza was ok. Fried ravioli had no seasoning at all. Chairs are super painful, and the stuffed animals don't really seem to make sense.UpvoteDownvote
Bryan JacksonJuly 29, 2010Lasagna was good. Breadsticks were not good (they are fried kind of like donuts). Food is way overpriced, but I am sure this is to pay for the atmosphere (stuffed animals and wood) which is neat.UpvoteDownvote
Rich WireJune 17, 2014Chairs uncomfortable. Floor annoying because it bounces as people & wait staff walk back & forth. Food is good but overpriced & not worth it for the unpleasantness of this place!UpvoteDownvote
Jococo CMay 8, 2013Service was alright, my silverware was unclean and the Lasagna tasted like microwave meal. We only went there because it was the only place open.Upvote2Downvote
Jordan JewellMay 28, 2012Did I mention that by the time we got the pizza and took it home, it wasn't ours? Oy.UpvoteDownvote
Jacque BurkeAugust 27, 2011Bacon pizza tasted weird, like menthol or mothballs. My kids ate it but the rest of us couldn't. Our other pizza was bland- pricey for not great food. Liked the Christmas lights thoughUpvoteDownvote
Brad ZimmermanOctober 9, 2010Overpriced, but the pizza is great and if you split the Nonnas tour you will have plenty of food.Upvote1Downvote
- Jordan JewellMay 28, 2012Been waiting for an hour for one pizza, found out 40 mins in that they haven't even gotten to making it.. This place is a joke and the waitstaff is incompetent.UpvoteDownvote
- Kellee AbozoglaiAugust 2, 2013Might get served... Might not... 9 min at the table no one has come over yet....UpvoteDownvote
Andrea MJuly 22, 2011Bizarre decorating scheme. Food was ok. Generous portions. Not the place to go if you want a quiet place to talk.UpvoteDownvote
Serafina Ventimiglia-TaorminaOctober 26, 2013Got sat by the hostess...., waited 20 minutes never even got a water. We leftUpvoteDownvote
Nathan SmithMay 22, 2011If you like to wait hours for your food, small portions, & large prices...this place is for you.UpvoteDownvote
Ashley DurkeeAugust 26, 2011Chicken dry, breadstick tasted like a donut, wierd decor, over priced. Just try something else...please...UpvoteDownvote
Jim BurkeAugust 27, 2011Tip: Keep Walking. Overpriced and nothing special here. Pizza was good but weird decor and nothing special here.Upvote1Downvote- Sylvia WilliamsAugust 5, 2013Don't eat here. Such a rip off. Food is low quality and the meat is not seasoned. Yuck!Upvote3Downvote
39 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 11:00 AM tomorrow (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
(231) 436-7901
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dinner
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 6.6
"Good pizza, great prices. all the bridge stuff is really cool and fun!"
Courtney Kennedy - 8.5
"I love the cinnamon sticks. They are the best (when fresh). I usually get the buffet. Good price!"
Karen Gardner - 7.8
"Great pizza, decent prices, nice staff, super quick. Loved sitting at the hightop table by the window people watching!"
Emily Fabian Paffenroth
Places people like to go after Nonna Lisa's
Appears on 3 lists
Mackinac Island Dining Guide for Dummies
Created by Victoria Leonard
21 items • 6 followers
