Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.
Learn more
American Restaurant Favorites in NYC
Union Square Cafe is one of American Restaurant Favorites in NYC.

1. Union Square Cafe

We are moving to 19th Street and Park Ave South in spring 2016!, New York
American Restaurant · Union Square · 147 tips and reviews

Valerie S.Valerie Seckler: Skip the reservations needed months in advance and pull up to the bar at USC, where the staff is warm+knowledgable about Danny Meyer's excellent food and wine. Fellow diners and environs are friendly.

2. Gotham Bar and Grill

12 E 12th St (btwn University Pl & 5th Ave), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 220 tips and reviews

Valerie S.Valerie Seckler: Greats can come-and-go in a flash, but Gotham lives on first-class food+drinks. A splendid vodka gimlet was paired with mixed nuts, a rarity at the bar in 2011. Decor has gone stuffy, crowd classic.

North Square is one of American Restaurant Favorites in NYC.

3. North Square

6.9
103 Waverly Pl (at MacDougal St.), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 29 tips and reviews

Valerie S.Valerie Seckler: Fish+seafood lovers will find several choices on a tight, creative menu, whose dishes are designed by Mexican born, French trained chef Yoel Cruz. Cruz says he brings both influences to the table.

4. Knickerbocker Bar & Grill

7.8
33 University Pl (at E 9th St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Greenwich Village · 69 tips and reviews

Valerie S.Valerie Seckler: Old New York flavor is sealed by specialties such as steaks, daily oysters, smoked salmon, pre-brunch homemade mini-muffins. Choose wine from a long list. Soak up the vintage photos + posters.

5. Strip House

8.7
13 E 12th St (btwn 5th Ave & University Pl), New York, NY
Steakhouse · Greenwich Village · 176 tips and reviews

Valerie S.Valerie Seckler: The namesake steak at Strip House Grill, 11 E 12 St., is flavorful&less chewy than some of its brethren. Homemade ice cream is memorable. Service is good, as is the overall effect, in clubby environs.

Untitled is one of American Restaurant Favorites in NYC.

6. Untitled

945 Madison Ave (at 75th St.), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Meatpacking District · 54 tips and reviews

Valerie S.Valerie Seckler: Danny Meyer's outpost at the Whitney Museum offers local + regional food that is at once familiar + new. Go back to basics w/a notable burger, chef's salad, microbrew soda. Check the food origins map.

7. NYY STEAK

7.7
One East 161st Street * Gate 6 * Yankee Stadium (E 161st St), Bronx, NY
Steakhouse · Concourse Village · 17 tips and reviews

Valerie S.Valerie Seckler: What better way to spend a rain delayed ALDS game vs Detroit than sharing a 3-tier raw bar sampler? Lobster, oysters, clams, crab, shrimp + good service. The Yankees memorabilia is as good as dessert.

8. NoHo Star

330 Lafayette St (at Bleecker St), New York, NY
American Restaurant · NoHo · 123 tips and reviews

Valerie S.Valerie Seckler: The go-to groups of food (burgers, omelets, salads) belie the wide variety of choices and flavors served up at this longtime NoHo presence. Quality was up-and-down in '11, but mostly a winning choice.

9. Elephant & Castle

8.2
68 Greenwich Ave (btw 11th St & Perry), New York, NY
Breakfast Spot · West Village · 111 tips and reviews

Valerie S.Valerie Seckler: Simple food, well prepared is the winning way of this downtown fixture. E&C gets a bum rap as omelet joint, but has long served inventive eats that sometimes surprise. Coffee is bottomless and good.

The Beagle is one of American Restaurant Favorites in NYC.

10. The Beagle

162 Avenue A (at E 10th St), New York, NY
Cocktail Bar · Alphabet City · 65 tips and reviews

Valerie S.Valerie Seckler: Great place for a memorable cocktail, fine for a meal. The space is cozy, with a limited number of tables and chairs. It was buzz busy in summer 2011. In a retro mood, attitude comes with the service.

Hard Rock Cafe Yankee Stadium is one of American Restaurant Favorites in NYC.

11. Hard Rock Cafe Yankee Stadium

7.5
1 E 161st St (Gate 6), Bronx, NY
Theme Restaurant · Concourse Village · 62 tips and reviews

Valerie S.Valerie Seckler: A surprisingly good refuge from the cold, rain, or too many hot dogs. Food is well done, service is gracious. Menu choices go well past burgers+sport calorie counts. Dylan, Lennon artifacts included.

Malibu Terrace Deck is one of American Restaurant Favorites in NYC.

12. Malibu Terrace Deck

Yankee Stadium, Bronx, NY
Bar · Concourse Village · 16 tips and reviews

Valerie S.Valerie Seckler: How different can one ballpark frank be from the next? The well-grilled Hebrew National hot dogs on Malibu Terrace are tops at Yankee Stadium. So's the view of the nearby Manhattan skyline.