Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood
The Wright is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

1. The Wright

7.0
1071 5th Ave (Rotundra, Level 1), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · Carnegie Hill · 18 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: You can’t beat such visions as the pan-seared wild striped bass with baby calamari.

RedFarm is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

2. RedFarm

8.5
529 Hudson St (btwn Charles & W 10th St), New York, NY
Chinese Restaurant · West Village · 288 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: Fresh greenmarket sensibility meets modern Chinese, mixed with rustic decor. Chef Joe Ng offers enticing items such as marinated rib steak with steamed baby bok choy and spicy steamed sea bass.

City Hall Restaurant is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

3. City Hall Restaurant

131 Duane St (btwn Church & W. Broadway), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Tribeca · 31 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: This is the go-to power-lunching spot for top city officials. On the menu: oysters on the half shell; Ahi ginger tuna burger, a nice selection of entree salads and classic surf-and-turf dishes.

Quaint is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

4. Quaint

4610 Skillman Ave (at 46th St), Sunnyside, NY
American Restaurant · 26 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: All-you-can-eat mussels and fries on Monday nights ($18).

5. Paula at Rigoletto Ristorante

3706 Park Ave (37th St), Weehawken, NJ
Italian Restaurant · 6 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: This cozy Italian eatery is known for its appetizers, which include spicy fried calamari and grilled eggplant layered with ricotta and pecorino and topped with marinara sauce. There's also good pasta.

Ristorante Settepani is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

6. Ristorante Settepani

6.6
196 Malcolm X Blvd (@ 120th Street), New York, NY
Mediterranean Restaurant · Central Harlem · 53 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: The pastries are excellent and the pastas get creative too, in preparations like spaghetti with bottarga (a cured fish roe) and lasagna with mushrooms and truffle oil.

Red Hook Lobster Pound is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

7. Red Hook Lobster Pound

9.0
284 Van Brunt St (btwn Verona St & Visitation Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Red Hook · 171 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: Because sometimes we need to have a lobster roll at inconvenient hours, we love that Red Hook Lobster Pound sells their signature lobster salad and packages of J.J. Nissen buns from Maine to go.

A Salt & Battery is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

8. A Salt & Battery

7.7
112 Greenwich Ave (btwn Jane St. & W 12th St.), New York, NY
Fish and Chips Shop · West Village · 105 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: Nicky Perry’s popular fish-and-chips spot combines surprises such as deep-fried Cadbury creme eggs with more traditional fresh-from-the oven chicken and mushroom pies.

Traif is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

9. Traif

9.0
229 S 4th St (btwn Roebling & Havemeyer St), Brooklyn, NY
Tapas Restaurant · Williamsburg · 285 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: This restaurant has a menu devoted to the exploration of pork, shellfish and foie gras.

The Mermaid Inn is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

10. The Mermaid Inn

96 2nd Ave (btwn E 5th & E 6th St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · East Village · 284 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: It doesn’t have a dessert menu, but makes up for it with the luscious complimentary chocolate pudding that comes in a demitasse with a swirl of whipped cream, served with a little toy “fortune fish”.

Bridge Cafe is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

11. Bridge Cafe

279 Water St (at Dover St.), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Financial District · 37 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: The soft-shell crabs are almost as legendary as the spot itself, which dates back to the 1794. Try: soft-shell crab BLT ($22) and soft-shell crab cooked in a scallion beurre blanc ($17 to $28)

Bell Book & Candle is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

12. Bell Book & Candle

7.9
141 W 10th St (btwn Waverly Pl & Greenwich Ave), New York, NY
New American Restaurant · West Village · 94 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: Every Tuesday, executive chef John Mooney serves a special entree of crispy soft-shell crab with basil and fennel — grown in his aeroponic rooftop garden — along with grapefruit and hazelnuts.

Grand Central Oyster Bar is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

13. Grand Central Oyster Bar

7.6
89 E 42nd St (Grand Central Terminal), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Midtown East · 404 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: Picks: pan-fried baby soft-shell crabs with spring pea and mint sauce ($14.50), pan-fried Maryland baby soft-shell crabs with garlic herb butter ($28.95).

Niko is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

14. Niko

170 Mercer St (at Houston), New York, NY
Japanese Restaurant · SoHo · 24 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: On the lunch menu at this Japanese eatery, you’ll find a soft-shell crab donburi (Japanese for “bowl”) with peashoots, kimchi, bacon and a poached egg, served over rice ($16).

Ciano is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

15. Ciano

45 E 22nd St (btwn Park Ave. & Broadway), New York, NY
Italian Restaurant · Flatiron District · 47 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: This Italian eatery serves its soft-shell crabs with peekytoe crab stuffing alongside a grapefruit tomato salad ($19) all month.

Bar Americain is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

16. Bar Americain

152 W 52nd St (btwn 6th & 7th Ave), New York, NY
American Restaurant · Theater District · 167 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: Bobby Flay’s midtown American brasserie serves its soft-shell crab entree Southern-style, crispy and topped with a gumbo sauce ($33).

Catch is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

17. Catch

8.0
21 9th Ave (at W 13th St), New York, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Meatpacking District · 328 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: EMM Group’s multi-level seafood restaurant is helmed by “Top Chef” winner Hung Hunyh. The menu will be New American, inspired by Asia and the Mediterranean.

Talde is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

18. Talde

369 7th Ave (at 11th St), Brooklyn, NY
Asian Restaurant · South Slope · 269 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: “Top Chef” and Buddakan alum Dale Talde opens his own Asian-American with a “chef’s table”-style counter with views into the kitchen. Try: his signature crispy-oyster bacon pad Thai.

Nick's Lobster House is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

19. Nick's Lobster House

7.4
2777 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Southeastern Brooklyn · 416 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: For seafood with a view, hit up Nick's, a community staple since 1955.

Jordan's Lobster Dock is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

20. Jordan's Lobster Dock

7.2
3165 Harkness Ave (at Knapp St.), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Sheepshead Bay · 43 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: This family-owned-and-operated Jordan’s Lobster Dock has been “serving the finest quality seafood” in New York City since 1938. The restaurant also includes a clam bar.

Randazzo's Clam Bar is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

21. Randazzo's Clam Bar

8.0
2017 Emmons Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Sheepshead Bay · 96 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: Randazzo’s has been in operation for almost 100 years. The clam bar offers Blue Point clams, stuffed lobster, broiled tilapia and a sautéed softshell crab sandwich, among others.

Brennan & Carr is one of Nice Catch: Fish and Seafood.

22. Brennan & Carr

8.4
3432 Nostrand Ave (at Avenue U), Brooklyn, NY
Sandwich Spot · Sheepshead Bay · 113 tips and reviews

amNewYorkamNewYork: Around for 75 years, the cash-only establishment is known for its roast beef sandwiches, with both bread and beef double-dipped in a salty broth, and patrons praise the onion rings.