Fitzcarraldo
(Now Closed)Italian Restaurant and Bar$$$$
East Williamsburg, Brooklyn
23 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Michelle WendyDecember 24, 2014Total gem in industrial Bushwick. The venue is intimate, so perfect for a date or small group dining and you can book the space for small events. I love the open kitchen that churns out deliciousness
EaterOctober 30, 2013Expect a few pastries and market-driven egg dishes in the morning, sandwiches in the afternoon, and a dinner menu that has charcuterie, cheeses, and Italian seafood dishes.
Sarah SpagnoloApril 22, 2015My scallops were delicious, but the lamb was cold and the soft shell crab, soupy. Loved the Moroccan tiled floor, though it makes the tables uneven. Try yours for steadiness before sitting down.
Mara LecocqSeptember 7, 2014The setting is beautiful and can be very romantic (beautiful windows), but the food, as good as it is, didn't strike me as extremely memorable for the small portion and high price it was at.
Jeni BulcockJune 1, 2014This place is beautifully styled! I would come here just to enjoy the decor. Prices are great too.
Kushal DaveOctober 13, 2013From the folks behind Rucola, a beautiful spot with a similarly tasty Italian menu and great cocktails (get the One Tricky Pony!).
Maya Jimenez 😬June 28, 2015Hidden gem of a place! Perfect for a cute low-key brunch. Highly recommend the soft scrambled eggs.
marc kozJanuary 3, 2015Delicious and expertly crafted food. You really cannot go wrong with anything but make sure you try that bar steak
LukeFebruary 23, 2015Northern Italian at really reasonable prices? Yes, please. Also the steak is delicious, if you just want to play it safe
Samuel SiémonsOctober 18, 2013Tailored service, short but tasty meal selection, warm and traditional decor, the place is worth visiting, and revisiting.
Lindsay FranzoniOctober 23, 2015Awesome food with a very intimate setting. Always get the farinata with tomatoes and pesto.
Joslyn HansenJanuary 29, 2015Sit at the bar to watch the chefs work! If you're patient, they'll chat to you and maybe offer a cheese tasting.
Eric BaileySeptember 7, 2015The loveliest of places, great atmosphere. But I can't say the food was very memorable considering the price. Great service though!
Owen IversonJanuary 15, 2015Empty place, the radiator leaked so I asked to move, then my bloody Mary never came (after a second reminder). Might have been an off day or just normal hipster service.
85 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Tue–Thu
- 5:30 PM–11:00 PM
- Fri
- 5:30 AM–10:00 PM
- Sat
- Noon–11:59 PM
- Sun
- Noon–11:00 PM
(718) 233-2566
View menu on http://fitzbk.com/menus
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.7
"Absolutely OUTSTANDING pizza! Would highly recommend to anyone who loves pizza and always in search of the best!!"
Randy Ireland - 9.0
"They now serve wine and liquor! Pinsas and pasta are great, so is the pistachio dessert pinsa 🤗"
Kathryn Farwell - 8.7
"Everything is great, you will want to sample the entire menu. Also love their outdoor seating area."
Marie La Rue
Places people like to go after Fitzcarraldo
- 8.8
"Burger was DELICIOUS ! Carmen was great. Most def will be coming back for more than a burger. Couple beers during Happy Hour (:"
Media Diva 💋 - 9.2
"Chill urban vibe with an in-restaurant DJ! Explore the menu! Wagyu Beef Carpaccio and 'Nduja Spicy Sausage are very flavorful!"
Philip Garcia - 8.7
"Cocktails, beer and shot special, backyard, excellent side room"
Gregory Gallagher
Appears on 161 lists
Explore your own neighborhood, jerk.
Created by Rebecca Sutter
221 items • 30 followers
Created by Rachel Lennon
200 items • 19 followers
Williamsburg To-Do (or Return)
Created by Christopherr Connolly
126 items • 181 followers
