See all
105 photos

Gargiulo's Restaurant

Italian Restaurant$$$$

Coney Island, Brooklyn

Save

8.2^/10

134

ratings

"fresh Cannoli"(3 Tips)
"The seafood combination"(4 Tips)
"the italian cheesecake was delicious"(2 Tips)
"Great old-school place to cater an event – the food"(3 Tips)

28 Tips and reviews

Filter:

Italian food
good service
cheesecake
chicken
homemade food
dinner
island
events
caters
bar
rice balls
parmesan
lasagne
dresses
alcohol
well
lunch
(12 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Mary JasenAugust 2, 2021
The eggplant rolls Toni with prosciutto and the sauce is so flavorful! The filet of sole was fresh and juicy, and the fried soft shell crabs were so meaty and delicious!
Gian PedullaDecember 28, 2018
The best Rice Balls and Baked Clams in New York... Make sure you leave room for dessert, home made Italian Cheese Cake and fresh Cannoli
G TMay 14, 2018
A solid restaurant choice where you cannot go wrong with anything on the menu. This place made me the foodie I am today.
The Corcoran GroupApril 15, 2011
Great old-school place to cater an event – the food is really spectacular, especially the home-made lasagne, manicotti or ravioli. Be sure to dress to the nines.
Buford BarnesMay 29, 2012
Established 1907, continuously operated. Interior has been renovated somewhat. Neapolitan cuisine with a grand ballroom available as a venue for weddings and social functions.
Tina MaffeoJuly 23, 2021
Suggestion:party goers enter on the street side. The people paying for parking enter the surf Ave side & also a bathroom needs to be on the party room floor not the downstairs
James CMarch 25, 2016
Fantastic food very classy. Really worth a trip. Cannoli was out of this world.
Nate FolkertFebruary 15, 2021
the italian cheesecake was delicious
Argante ColageoOctober 13, 2014
The food is outstanding. Family owned, Italian restaurant great for couples or family our events.
Luna Park Coney IslandJanuary 17, 2013
This tasty restaurant is the perfect place to unwind in Coney Island if you're looking for a finer dining experience.
Samantha SkarinAugust 31, 2012
Excellent authentic Italian. Been coming here for as long as I can remember. Well worth the trip.
Nate FolkertFebruary 15, 2021
half cannoli is a good small dessert for a little one
Dawn :o) DamnYourNosey!March 10, 2012
Amazing food. And catering hall. My cousin was married here and everything was simply awesome.
NYC: The Official GuideJune 21, 2013
A Coney Island icon, Gargiulo's has served the neighborhood since 1907.
Aeolian-Skinner Princess PastoreApril 5, 2017
Great for functions!
Sal CappiAugust 20, 2013
The linguine with crab fra diavolo is off the charts!
Daddy's Sunshine!!December 2, 2011
Been here 10+ times
The Chicken Scapriella is awesome. Especially with a nice glass of white.
Steve B.October 24, 2018
Great for catered affairs.
✨#IamRomdelacrème✨September 24, 2012
The service was GREAT! However, there were 4 of us and we tried each other's dishes and agreed: 3 of the 4 entres were not very flavorful. :-(
Bob GoldenAugust 13, 2014
Been here 25+ times
The seafood combination
Joe MarinelliDecember 3, 2012
Nice Place. Great Food
Tina MaffeoJuly 23, 2021
The food was better this time around
Theresa RoldanOctober 13, 2015
Good but I expected a lot better
Patrick ToyJanuary 14, 2010
If you are local, you can call in and get great chic parm or meatball subs.
Kris N.August 27, 2010
Amazing food. Go dress to impress.
HolidayMay 11, 2019
Terrible encounter with the female manager, very aggressive and unpleasant person. Lost my appetite.
Ju VelosoAugust 17, 2017
Nada de bom. Vá bem vestido, ou seja, nada de sair da praia e pensar que vai poder comer lá. Fui barrada por estar de short, camiseta e havaianas. Ridículo.
Abby BeanDecember 19, 2011
Fra diavlo Puttanesca, no anchovies!

105 Photos

Gargiulo's Restaurant

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Gargiulo's Restaurant

Appears on 59 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.