Important Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria
Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria$$$$
Key West
"Off the main street - excellent pizza and a beautiful setting."(25 Tips)
"octopus oreganata"(4 Tips)
"Cute backyard and excellent service."(3 Tips)
"Good service, chill electronic music, courtyard seating,..."(3 Tips)
42 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- good for dates
- cute
- wine
- casual
- (10 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Michael LeszczukDecember 11, 2018Small, unassuming and Key West charming. Great pizza but also great everything. Salads, pasta and entrees are all fabulous. Eat in the garden outside if the weather is good.
AleJuly 20, 2016If you say wood fire, I have high expectations. The place did not disappoint, the pizza was very good! The place is charming and the staff is kind.
Michael BelluardoJune 16, 2015Pizza is good overall. A little over priced even for key west. The staff also tried to say the pizzas were personal sized but one can easily feed two people.
Yvonnie AmetinJanuary 6, 2016Pizza hasn't come out yet but calamari, green salad, and fun atmosphere and service great!
Brad SpenceMay 15, 2014Pizza on par with the best in NYC. I had the Pruciuotto di Parma. Pasta was amazing too (fettuccini bolognese)- Tim ScoutelasMarch 4, 2015You'll have to look hard for this gem off of Duval. Be sure to ask for the specials. The homemade mozzarella is epic!
- GREAT FOOD!!! It's a little hard to find, but worth the search!!
- Mary Beth KooperApril 26, 2014Too hot to sit inside; eat in the garden instead. I had a special appetizer, octopus oreganata, and it was REALLY good!
Datsuro DesignsFebruary 24, 2013Food is awesome, great ambiance, and the wine selection is pretty good too. Dress nice and maybe you'll get good service.- Char KasprzakDecember 18, 2012Good service, chill electronic music, courtyard seating, fantastic pizza... A great date spot!
The best pizza on the entire island. Yummy great staff very attentive. Priced right and a nice setting.
Asheley UnderwoodDecember 12, 2012Awesome pizza and atmosphere! Sit in the cute courtyard. Highly recommend. Tucked in an alley off Duvall.
Delisioso! Cute place. Pizza is on par w NYC. Recommend eating in versus take out.
Linda O'BrienJune 27, 2014If this was the best pizza in key west then that's pretty sad. The pizza was not that great. The dough tasted like it was pre made and the pizza did not have that great wood fired taste.
Joe TaulbeeJuly 27, 2013The manager is very personable and the rest of the staff works very hard to make sure you are taken care of
Casey MusselmanJuly 28, 2013Food was good. Waiter got 2 out of 3 orders wrong! But they corrected the one we asked about and gave it to us for half price :)
Greg KellyJune 21, 2013Disappointing. Scallops were very hard to find in the special. Maybe one large scallop was diced into very small pieces.
Christina JewellMay 31, 2013Okay food. WAY too hot in here. It's 2013 ...time to get some better air conditioner
Claudia MartinezJuly 15, 2015Ambiente mais simples do que imaginei,porém agradável !pizza razoável.😐
83 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 5:30 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- Noon–3:00 PM
- 5:30 PM–11:00 PM
(305) 735-4412
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Wine
See More
You might also like
- 7.7
"Verry friendly and really delicious! It may be a bit more expensive; but it is worth it!"
Dries Bentein - 7.6
"Don’t be deceived by the cheesy “Hard Rock” style branding. This place is amazing. Order the dolce pizza. It’s incredible."
Ted Barnett - 7.9
"The crab cake, from someone who eats a lot of crab cakes, was spectacular. All delicious chunks of crab, held together with wisps of delicious crunch."
Naomi Thomson
Places people like to go after Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria
- 8.9
"Strawberry beer rimmed with chocolate! Also the bread pudding! Really unique place to experience"
Deanna Mitchell - 8.4
"Try the dark chocolate covered marshmallows with sprinkles on a convenient to-go stick. Good for a treat anytime."
James Marsh - 9.0
"So much information about Ernest Hemingway and His families all in one place. Beautiful home that is very well preserved. Also a wedding venue."
Debbie W
Appears on 24 lists
Created by David Minkin
36 items • 7 followers
Pizza Recommended by Aaron's Friends
Created by Aaron Landry
93 items • 6 followers
