- The seafood at Peg Leg Pete's is a can't miss
- shipwreck
- casual
- good for groups
- trendy
- gumbo
- (15 more)
- Popular
- Recent
- Dave LeachOctober 31, 2010Don't miss out on the Pirate Sauce on your table. It's not crazy spicy, and cinnamon, cloves and allspice work suprisingly well with the heat.
- Terra RoseFebruary 25, 2013The grouper is very cheap here but has good quality. I would definitely recommend the grouper.
- Lindsay HerndonMay 15, 2015The grilled shrimp and crab legs were good, so was the grouper! Little pricey
- Cathi DenhamFebruary 20, 2011Chicken in key west salad is burned! Not enough chips for the toppings in the nachos then tjey want $.75 to get more! Drinks are good though. Service is good too.
- Christopher ByrdMay 1, 2013Good stuff! Great service, decent food. The Cajun chicken sandwich is good, but ask what's on it first. Lol
- Sarah KentApril 18, 2012The won't put your food in until the appetizer is served. If u get hungry, put some pirate sauce on some crackers but be ready for the long lasting kick.
- Matt DurrOctober 24, 2011Grouper nugget appetizer is great, but avoid the Cajun fried seafood platter: way over-fried, and Cajun sauce is essentially just a horseradish mix.
- Harris HesterApril 7, 2012Oysters are good, kids love the playground. Upstairs gets pretty full but down stairs usually has room.
- Matthew CaldecuttJuly 19, 2015There are so many oyster dishes that I had a hard time ordering just two.
- Dietrick HardwickMay 25, 2012Try the Oysters Lafitte - Baked Gulf Coast Oysters w/Bacon, Cheddar and diced Jalepeño
- Mary MixonOctober 11, 2011The scallops were so good. The grouper sandwich was also a hit. What a great place
- Giavonna PeadenAugust 8, 2012There cajun sauce is delicious !! With a taste of horse radish, but without the spice.
- Dietrick HardwickMay 25, 2012Try the Oysters Imperial - Gulf Coast Oysters Baked with Crabmeat Stuffing and Alfredo Sauce
- Baked oysters are great. My favorite oyster place in the Gulf.
- Grouper nuggets make a good appetizer to share. Too many good things to choose only one.
- Carl PruettAugust 15, 2014Oysters , oysters and more oysters with Jami, Russ, Rachel, Cara, Scott & Jon
- David HolderOctober 11, 2010Parmesan Oysters are my favorite! Love the Key West Salad! Anna is a great server too!