Important Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.Pink Pony
Pub and American Restaurant$$$$
Mackinac Island
"Great Outside bar area and patio - whitefish dip is amazing."(4 Tips)
"Pink Pony Punch is delicious!"(3 Tips)
"Outside bar area"(2 Tips)
"Make sure you get the Rum Runners, they're amazing."(2 Tips)
60 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pink pony punch
- scenic views
- outdoor seating
- rum runners
- live music
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- Justin LockeJuly 16, 2016Great Outside bar area and patio - whitefish dip is amazing. Solid selection of craft beer and wines as well as mixed drinks. Also indoor seating and TVs
Upvoted Aug 17 
Matty Ice 🍺🏈🐱July 17, 2013Upstairs patio is a beautiful place to enjoy lunch or dinner. Music couldn't be more depressing. Live music or radio over the PA system. Liven it up we are on vacation!
Danielle ZwergJune 27, 2016The French Dip, fish tacos, and sweet potato fries are good. I love the scenery.
Patrick CallahanMay 18, 2016Good food, great view, greater service from Kelly who went above and beyond. Even offering to go to the store and buy Advil for our throbbing heads. 10 outa 10 coming back.
PennyJune 23, 2016Food and drinks were good. Music was amazing. Our server was subpar to be nice. Over all I will come back but the service detracted from the experience...massively.
Stacy Bo BacySeptember 26Go downstairs for attentive service at the bar and watch the gulls and water.
Stephanie MeermanSeptember 25, 2017I had the Kale, Beet salad with ginger/teriyaki dressing. It was delicious!
Michele KeprosJune 28, 2017Unfortunately they give their booths for larger parties to parties of 2 just because they request a window spot.Our party of 5 was offered a 4 top with a 5th chair squeezed in, we left!
A sailor's classic! Must see on nites with live music and boats on the dock. Hop in the hot tub out back!
Great bar and outside patio. Huge hot tub with a view of the lake.
Phyllis BoxAugust 16, 2019Nice eatery on Mackinac island. Close to ferry. Ask to sit outside. Great view on water.
The best thing to get is a Michigan craft brew and the warm pretzel sticks.
Steve PollackAugust 22, 2013The porch in back is not to be missed, and the whitefish dip and fingers are great!
Carolina MirandaSeptember 25, 2011Skip the main room and hit the bar out back, which has views of the water and the docks. Perfect spot for a pre-ferry beer.
TobyJune 2, 2013Fun fun! OMG, the BBQ pulled pork chips and blue cheese is GREAT! And the servers were great.
KayleeJune 6, 2015This is the first bar to open and where the party is at! The art is strange though...
Sam KalaminskyAugust 16, 2013Have a drink outside on the patio. Then finish at the bar, and enjoy the live music!
A'Mitch Wilsonator'tAugust 21, 2011Avrg dinner meal is $20, sammich's $11-14. Multiple environments for what ever the mood. Sometimes live music, sometimes very sports bar.
JohneSeptember 4, 2021Too loud and too packed for our tastes. If you're looking for something quieter, there are better options. (We ended up at Smokey Joe's around the corner and sat out on the balcony overlooking the bay
Frankenmuth BreweryMay 21, 2012What's a good fish taco without a Frankenmuth Brew... Try Pilsener Lager Bottles or Hefeweizen on Draft!
Hang at the bar, request tunes and don't forget to tip the musicians and bartenders.
Arianna HoltwickJuly 5, 2013We arrived at 10:30 for breakfast and were told that they had already stopped serving breakfast even though they had it posted as going until 11. We took our business elsewhere.- J Jeffrey BroderickJune 7, 2018Outside bar area is nice, but they don’t want you there if you don’t order dinner.
Kelli Faino-BoelkinsOctober 5, 2012With a name like Pink Pony you would think the staff was friendly. Not the case.
374 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
The Pink Pony is the Island's foremost entertainment establishment, offering mouthwatering dining options and a full complement of refreshing beverages.
Open until 2:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 8:00 AM–2:00 AM
(800) 241-3341
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Music
Live Music
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 7.9
"Chicken salad is a combination of savory and fruity. Great service and awesome view of the harbor. Every time we eat here we never have had a bad meal."
Sarah Cronk-Greenhill - 6.4
"We had the best service here. The food was very good. Get the White Bean Chili - if you are into chili."
Jerri McClenthen - 5.6
"Our server was amazing and the food was phenomenal! Do yourself a favor and try the steak, cheddar, and ale soup. So good!"
Allycat
Places people like to go after Pink Pony
- 6.3
"Buffalo chicken flatbread, fully loaded potato soup and sausage tortellini with vodka saucer were amazing. Warm rolls were served with homemade pesto sauce, must try. Best restaurant in the entire MI"
Jococo C - 7.2
"Great fish sandwich and friendly staff!"
Char Monges - 8.5
"We LOVED the fieste cheese sticks! Delish!"
Dana Haupt
Appears on 25 lists
Guide to Mackinac Island's best spots
Created by Ben Greene
3 items • 1 followerCreated by Jordan Howes
12 items • 2 followers
Created by Steve Severino
33 items • 3 followers