See all
67 photos

The Big Slice - 5th Ave

(Now Closed)

Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$

Flatiron District, New York

Save

38 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Lily FAugust 26, 2015
Pizza so good, you eat the crust. Good sauce/cheese ratio. Stick with classics like plain or pepperoni. Buffalo chicken slice is a fun alternative though.
Giselle Gigi RiveraMay 14, 2012
Been here 5+ times
The white cheese pizza is the best!! If your a cheese lover you have to try it!!
Arthur SabintsevMarch 28, 2013
Random tip. This place has the Best buffalo chicken pizza in the Flatiron area. It's so good, that you have to come early to get it, or they'll be all out.
Rudy ValentaFebruary 22, 2016
Can't go wrong. Eat the first slice that looks good to you that day. Don't think twice about your decision
Lianna シNovember 25, 2014
Arguably the best pizza in the flat iron district. You won't be disappointed!
Matthew CaldecuttMarch 12, 2016
Stop in for a slice. There are always plenty and they always look fresh.
macfixerApril 12, 2019
Been here 10+ times
Try their Sicilian “upside down” slice. To die for! 🍕
Annie BullerMay 9, 2015
Pretty solid for a quick slice when you're in need. The crust leaves something to be desired but the sauce & cheese gets the job done.
Jeff PetrielloJanuary 26, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Skip the pizza and head straight to the pasta bar for a HUGE helping of pretty decent rigatoni vodka for cheap.
jeffrey arnoldMay 25, 2018
Grandma slice is surprisingly excellent.
Cheyenne VOctober 16, 2013
They have a build your own pasta in the back , sooo good .
NancyOctober 10, 2017
Even if the pizza is fine- the place is filthy- surprised they got an A from DOH
Leslie OroMay 26, 2012
Great fresh mozarella pizza though very small. Best sauce ever!
Jenna TyrangelDecember 7, 2011
Arguably one of the best slices I have ever had and I'm a pizza junkie
Susan OMarch 6, 2016
So yummy!! Will definitely be back!
David DunhillSeptember 18, 2015
Heavy, mid-west style pizza. It will do in a pinch, but not an essential slice shop.
Michael CareyAugust 24, 2012
The broccoli and chicken stuffed pizza is GOOD!
Paige CJuly 22, 2014
Been here 5+ times
They have the best white slice!
EvanMay 30, 2014
Chicken parm hero seems to be made from Tyson chicken patty.
Lisa ONeillMarch 28, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Chicken and broccoli stuffed pizza is amazing, and addictive!
macfixerMay 16, 2018
Been here 10+ times
The Wi-Fi password is Pizza123
Xavier BMay 11, 2013
Best pizza in the neighborhood!
JoeyJanuary 27, 2012
Best Chicago slices in the city
Versha SharmaMay 24, 2011
Been here 25+ times
The garlic knots here are soooo goooood.
Lisa FrommkeJune 10, 2019
Garlic Knots!
Cole KennedyApril 6, 2018
The sauce is too sweet.
InterFACEJune 20, 2012
Love the salad bar here!
Armagan AksoyOctober 12, 2013
Great slices....
Rob StenzAugust 15, 2014
Chicken caesar slice is light and crisp and packs on plenty of salad. Delicious option for anyone craving pizza but not looking for a heavy greasy slice.
Jude RosenstockAugust 17, 2010
The plain pizza is perfect.
seth meyerowitzSeptember 7, 2012
Pizza was burnt and as stupid a this sounds, they only have shitty plastic utensils that can't even cut thru a slice.
Benjamin CoatsJuly 18, 2016
Overpriced and nothing special
Mike KJune 26, 2011
Cockroaches!!!!!!
Nina LoSchiavoJuly 9, 2014
Mediocre. So. Painfully. Mediocre.
Aguchi RebagliatiSeptember 7, 2019
Buenísimas las pastas Alfredo + pizza
Dani JaraSeptember 10, 2012
Si pide 2 pedazos! La bebida es gratis!
Husen AsMarch 2, 2011
bingung juga
Gunawan WitarsaOctober 17, 2014
Pizza Nya enak. Crunchy

67 Photos

The Big Slice - 5th Ave

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after The Big Slice - 5th Ave

Appears on 20 lists

More from Bravo Pizza

Is this your business? Claim it now.