Important Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.

Foursquare City Guide

See all
435 photos

The Lobster Roll Restaurant

Seafood Restaurant$$$$

Amagansett

Save

Share

The Lobster Roll Restaurant

8.3^/10

403

ratings

The lobster at The Lobster Roll Restaurant is a can't miss
"My first lobster roll in years was just as good as my very first!"(67 Tips)
"Try the puffers if in season, I hear the pie is great too."(6 Tips)
"Fun ambience with great services located right at the Montauk Hwy."(4 Tips)
"The seafood chili was amazing"(3 Tips)

111 Tips and reviews

Filter:

lobster rolls
montauk
puffers
good for groups
lively
casual
french fries
pies
gluten-free food
cocktails
great value
cole slaw
good for a quick meal
lemonade
sandwiches
sliders
cookies
beer
lunch
parking
(15 more)

Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Abby FinkelSeptember 1, 2015
The lobster and shrimp rolls are both excellent
Elias GuerraJuly 8, 2011
You won't have room for the strawberry rhubarb pie with cinnamon ice cream after dinner... get it anyway.
Kate FurmanJuly 19, 2015
Long lines, even at off peak hours. Get a lobster roll, duh.
Ben GaspariniAugust 31, 2016
Such delicious swordfish for those of us allergic to shellfish :/
Burk JacksonAugust 6, 2011
They have an entire gluten free menu for those looking for such things, including lobster rolls and cupcakes!
DonJune 1, 2018
The hot lobster rolls are the best!
Olivia FabbroJune 22, 2015
Been going here forever, decent food, nice beachy atmosphere
Justin FerrantiJuly 26, 2016
The mussels appetizer is always a good idea
Joshua LiblingAugust 17, 2014
Fresh, yummy lobster rolls and fish and chips.
Vincent AcquavivaAugust 28, 2014
Lobster roll Maine size servings and NY prices!
Trevor RennieJuly 13, 2019
The original Lobster roll & beer! Fantastic!!!
Linz SheltonMay 13, 2012
free mimosas for moms on mothers day ... highly suggested to borrow a wallet full of pics of a friend's kid ;-)
Sam KirschAugust 31, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Full gluten free menu! Get the GF lobster roll..it's awesome!
Kev SkinnyAugust 14, 2014
Such a classic. If you drive by after 12pm there is no excuse not to stop.
Liz CohenJuly 19, 2013
when visiting with a small-ish group, sit at the counter to avoid long waits!
Tonie WanJuly 2, 2018
As the name suggests, get the Lobster Roll
Barry HottSeptember 17, 2010
Been here 10+ times
The lobster roll here is better than any I've had. HUGE chunks of lobster!
Julie KorostelevaAugust 31, 2018
Absolutely delicious with the fastest service ever
Lynn MullaheyAugust 10, 2014
Lobster rolls!!! And the homemade burgers.
Sam PropisSeptember 9, 2018
Lobster roll!
Wayne BennettSeptember 13, 2015
In truth, it's all about the lobster roll here and the fruit pies. Everything else is hit or miss. Drinks so so.
Jeff StoneJune 9, 2014
You must eat the fried puffers + lobster roll.
Larissa VerdeAugust 23, 2014
Unreal cold lobster roll!
reece pachecoOctober 1, 2011
have a lobster roll, then the strawberry rhubarb pie... pat yourself on the back and smile.
NancerellaJune 20, 2016
Food was yummy!!!
Josh MateoJune 16, 2015
Go for the cold lobster roll.
Ashley RoseJuly 17, 2016
LUNCH!!! Warm lobster and a frozen cocktail.
Christina WardMay 15, 2021
Crab cakes are great!
Sasha BMay 18, 2013
Check in on yelp for a free beer
Dana 🦋September 13, 2014
The best lobster roll I've ever ate
Danie BJuly 2, 2013
Yes! There are vegetarian options available!
James MichaelAugust 31, 2011
Been here 25+ times
charbroiled tuna steak (medium rare) sandwich is amazing!
sarah paytonJuly 29, 2012
Order the lobster roll with butter. Delicious.
Lisa MJune 16, 2011
Awesome food! Most amazing lobster roll and clam strips ever!
Amber NagleAugust 31, 2015
HOT LOBSTER ROLL AND CLAM CHOWDER
Karen McAnanamaDecember 29, 2014
The food is great
Charles BJune 12, 2011
Get some chowda before a solid lobster roll (which is not as good as the hype, but solid)
Gary FeigelmanJuly 2, 2021
The Lobster Roll
Matt HantzJuly 22, 2012
Very kid friendly. Among other things, they have a cabinet full of toys.
Daniel MaldonadoAugust 23, 2014
Seafood chili and lobster roll
Scott McAllisterJune 20, 2010
Puffers are super delish when they are in season. Mini and deep and deep fried for dipping.
Nicki DoyamisSeptember 15, 2013
Amazing lobster roll!!
Jenny PennySeptember 3, 2018
Be prepared to wait
Josh MaitOctober 16, 2010
The soup rocks...and with a lobster slider it is plenty of food.
Sophia GiardinaJune 29, 2012
1 word. AH MAY ZINGGG. MUST DO IN THE HAMPTONS!!
Emil HMay 19, 2013
Um, get the lobster roll!
Peter AppelAugust 7, 2014
Soft shell crabs sandy
Olivier AmarMay 7, 2017
Not much. The casino clams were overpriced and lacked taste. The lobster bowl was covered in mayo and unseasoned.
Brian MooreJuly 31, 2012
Tasty tasty. Pricey pricey.
Sam EdelmanJuly 16, 2013
The Best Lobster Roll

435 Photos

Related Searches

the lobster roll restaurant amagansett •
the lobster roll restaurant amagansett photos •
the lobster roll restaurant amagansett location •
the lobster roll restaurant amagansett address •
the lobster roll restaurant amagansett •
lobster roll amagansett •
lobster roll restaurant amagansett •
lunch amagansett •
lunch lobster roll restaurant amagansett •
lunch, lobster roll restaurant amagansett •
lunch/lobster roll amagansett •
lunchlobster roll amagansett •
the lobster roll restaurant amagansett •

Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA

You must enable JavaScript to use foursquare.com

We use the latest and greatest technology available to provide the best possible web experience.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser settings to continue.

Download Foursquare for your smart phone and start exploring the world around you!