Untamed Sandwiches
(Now Closed)Sandwich Spot$$$$
Garment District, New York
The folks at Eater and Serious Eats like this place. Would you agree?
107 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Jackson IsaacsonMarch 19, 2016Amazing sandwiches and sides that are incredibly balanced and flavorful. Delicious sides and drinks as well. And all the meat and vegetables are ethically and locally sourced!
Bernie DominikMarch 29, 2018Good atmosphere and the sandwiches are interesting takes of specialty dishes. I recommend the General Zapata the chicken tinga is wonderfully delicious and not too spicy. Great experience overall.- Nate BeattyMarch 15, 2015You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. These guys honestly make some of the best sandwiches I have had in my life. Get a side of broccoli rabe, too - it's delicious
Emanuela EliasOctober 27, 2016The meat is so good. I'm newly GF and the gf bread is ah-maze. It's biscuit-like.
Staff PicksJuly 30, 2014Untamed Sandwiches just unleashed its breakfast sandwich menu. The Jacquelyn Park is the meatiest, with cider-braised pork, cheddar, beans & black pepper aioli, topped with sunny side-up eggs. Read more
All sandwiches are pretty much delicious. And if you're not crazy about carbs, ask for one of the alternatives.
Amy SelwayJune 6, 2014Perfect spot for a Friday lunch. The food is great, good wine and you can even catch a bit of sun through the open front. The staff are also very friendly. Will definitely return!
David CancelApril 8, 2015Had the Hot Goldie, it's freaking delicious. Girlfriend had the General Zapata, she reports it's good as well. The bread is crunchy, the meat is tender, and Grumpy's chili will warm your soul. Go.
Caroline LeDecember 15, 2014wow. that is all I have to say about this place. can't go wrong with the Hot Goldie -perfectly cooked and the sandwich is well balanced
Cynthia LinSeptember 23, 2016Bold bold selections! You can get each sandwich in the form of a platter too!
Omar HarounMarch 5, 2014Best sandwiches in NYC. Hot Goldie is unreal. Fine dining quality in casual setting.- AmberMarch 17, 2016Solid sandwiches, great quality ingredients, committed to keeping things sustainable and responsible = I'm a fan.
Nikki 🌺February 27, 2014Never had the sandwiches but OMG their broccoli rabe is great! Spicy, chargrilled tasting, and light on the olive oil. Yum. I'm sure it's amazing on sandwiches too.
Dr. PloinkyAugust 9, 2014Sandwiches are good and made quickly. Half sandwich and a beer or wine is a great deal for $11. House made limeade and lemonade. Clean and rustic decor. Staff was friendly. Eco-conscious.
Delicious sandwiches. Go with two and split with a friend
Daniel De MenaFebruary 17, 2015Went today again with the family and ordered a Hot Goldie, Chupacabra, Chili Soup and 2 delicious sude orders...priceless!!! Every time i come to NYC im landing at Untamed!!! Cudo's!!!
Emily GiglieranoAugust 21, 2018Insanely busy at lunch! Highly recommend ordering ahead or using MealPal. The Carla Bruni is an awesomely delicious sandwich.
Andrew FurmanOctober 20, 2015The Hot Goldie sandwich was really good. Gotta come back to try the pork butt tho
Jonas WilstrupDecember 27, 2014The sandwiches are really good, the staff is nice and it's affordable. A great place - which is hard to find in midtown.
Matt ZoufalyAugust 9, 2014The pork butt sandwich is the way to go. The mustard is especially spicy and delicious.
Jonathon KirkAugust 19, 2014Unexpected and welcome find in lower midtown neighbourhood. Smashing sandwiches, the thought of another pork butt sandwich makes one salivate
Ok...new one, just tried the general Zapata and it's delicious, I cannot call it 'tinga' as it is sold but that does not take away the awesomeness
Stan TranNovember 23, 2015$1 from each Frere Jacques order will be donated to the Leukemia & Lymphoma Society! #lls
Christina ChinAugust 16, 2015Got the butt..tasty with a little kick. Sandwiches are good but a bit pricey at $12-15 per sandwich
Serious EatsFebruary 4, 2014The short menu consists of hefty, filling braised meat sandwiches. We're fans of the brisket.
Loved the Hot Goldie sandwich & Aleppo Peanut Butter cookie!- drew tarvinMay 13, 2015One of my current favorites for sandwiches in NYC. My goal is to become a sandwich tamer.
Carmen NSeptember 2, 2014Now that I've been back and tried the Carla Bruni, a slow roasted vegetable sandwich, I have a much more positive opinion of this place.
Meg FarmerDecember 29, 2014Solid lunch spot in midtown. Carla Bruni was a win, adore the lively atmosphere.
Ross Whittow-WilliamsMarch 25, 2015Gluten free roll one of the best I've had. Ginger ale was great too
Angela IsabelSeptember 13, 2014Get the smaller breakfast sandwiches for a quick delicious bite at a cheap price! $4 ✅
Willem OckhuysenAugust 20, 2014This is one of my regulars for good reason. Best sandwiches in the city. The Butt!
Maz AmbatMarch 2, 2014The chupcabra was delish. The chilli is great too and comes with a side of cheese bread yummm
Mindy NguyenApril 24, 2015Loved the veggie sandwich! I don't normally love sandwiches and wanted more!- Oh-My-God!!! Hot goldie's just changed my life, and will change yours too.
137 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Braised meat sandwiches made with sustainable ingredients
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Fri
- 11:00 AM–9:00 PM
- Sat–Sun
- 11:00 AM–5:00 PM
(646) 669-9397
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
No
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Wine
See More
You might also like
- 8.7
"Sandwiches are fresh, all the food is delicious with organic ingredients and lots of options. Staff really friendly too."
Mairéad Ní Dhubhthaigh - 8.7
"Really tasty espresso made from Counter Culture Coffee beans, decent nitro cold brew during the summer, and the breakfast ham sandwich is my favorite!"
Rick Nelson - 8.6
"I prefer this franchise to Starbuks, cozy and calm."
Yasaman Mahdian
Places people like to go after Untamed Sandwiches
- 9.5
"This place never fails to impress me. Probably my best park in the big apple. Yoga classes, live music, nice surroundings, books and great waffle place, could you ask for more?"
Joury Al - 9.0
"#fabuLIST #dubiDO one of the best spots to grab a coffee in the area and relax after shopping. Love the flat white and latte. Seats are limited."
Chelsea Balkan - 9.3
"Beautiful ceilings. Great space to duck in and chill with a good book."
Rochelle Gilliard
Appears on 424 lists
Created by Gloria Chin
194 items • 47 followers
Created by Rana Rouhana
158 items • 56 followers
Created by John Xie
29 items • 19 followers