See all
88 photos

Bantam Bagels

(Now Closed)

Bagel Shop$$$$

West Village, New York

Save

Bantam Bagels

31 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

PureWowJuly 1, 2014
Try the “Weekend Brunch,” an everything bagel filled with lox, tomato and red-onion cream cheese. Read more
Samantha SaltielSeptember 4, 2013
Try the cinnamon, peanut butter and jelly, and the everything with cream cheese. Those 3 are amazing!
Colleen McAndrewAugust 6, 2014
Try as many as you can! Everybody's favorite and Grandma Jojo are my favs. The 'dessert' ones can be on the very sweet side.
Caroline LeFebruary 23, 2015
the biggest variety of bite size bagels I've ever seen. so many great flavors to choose from!
Meredith BMay 9, 2015
Ty the pesto bagel. Stumbled upon this place walking by. Wouldn't go out of my way to Ty but worth going in if you're in the neighborhood.
AmandaSeptember 7, 2013
I want more of the everything with veggie cream cheese!! Really neat and fun concept. The owner is very nice.
CitygirlAugust 20, 2014
Been here 5+ times
I've tried every one-- strongest flavors are buffalo chicken, bleecker st pizza, grandma jojo, hangover
Kim GlassmanSeptember 10, 2013
Brand new as of a week ago - mini bagels with different flavors including French Toast. Amazing!
Courtney HorwitzSeptember 4, 2013
Get a dozen. Seriously. Just try them all. More balls the better.
Jency Pallathu JohnJuly 6, 2017
Try the Hot Pretzel. So delicious!
Kate FurmanMarch 8, 2016
Bagel balls stuffed with cream cheese. Eat them right out of the oven or else they'll get stale.
jiresellJuly 11, 2015
Wanted to try it as they were on Shark Tank. The stuffed bagel balls were good, but a bit pricey.
Michael IsraelOctober 19, 2013
Such an awesome concept and great flavors. Try it out!
Joanna KamienMarch 30, 2014
Get the hot pretzel that honey Dijon cream cheese is to die for
Darleen SchererSeptember 15, 2013
i could eat a dozen of the Bleecker Street and the Cinnamonster, too.
Shrutika SachdevOctober 12, 2013
Amazing invention! Cream cheese ready for you inside bite size bagels!
Chloe BecquetFebruary 15, 2015
Bagel balls!!! Get the pepperoni one!! It's a pizza flavor burst in one bite
Paul AndrewMarch 27, 2014
They were amazing ! Everyone must have them
BonDecember 22, 2013
Pizza ball yes. Classic, skip and have that Murray's or essa instead.
Elena SorJanuary 21, 2015
More novelty than anything. $1.50 for a bite size bagel. It's good, but I wouldn't mind not going back.
Wolfe MikelicMarch 6, 2014
Every flavor is good! Go there.
SimonSeptember 4, 2013
Take them home and toast them yourself , they are 10x better
Jeremy BassSeptember 6, 2013
Try 'me for the novelty, but then go to a real bagel place.
MerissaAugust 16, 2014
Fun concept, but the bagels are just "eh". They'd be cute to bring to a brunch party.
Kati McKinneySeptember 14, 2013
The hot pretzel was the best out of my bunch!
Greg ColellaSeptember 7, 2013
Erika has beautiful eyes. Amazing.
Nina GOctober 20, 2013
Hot pretzel is to die for
Nannette SimmonsApril 6, 2014
Yummy and great staff!
Joy FarabeeOctober 12, 2013
Filled bagel concept is better savory than sweet
Kunjan PunatarJanuary 13, 2017
Wrong timings. Open only till 3pm
CityReviewerMay 10, 2014
They are so good!

88 Photos

Bantam Bagels

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Bantam Bagels

Appears on 138 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.