Emmy Squared Pizza
Pizzeria$$$$
Williamsburg, Brooklyn
"The Roni Supreme is delicious, but not for those who dislike spice."(19 Tips)"The okonomi fries are a must in addition to any pizza"(9 Tips)
"Emmy Squared pizza is magnificent & Angel Pie is great as well!"(8 Tips)
"Big Matt burger is simultaneously amazing and challenging."(6 Tips)
167 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- roni supreme
- lively
- burgers
- casual
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Thom FinnarnMay 27, 2016The Roni Supreme is delicious, but not for those who dislike spice. Also, head for lunch, way easier to grab a table...
JocelynMay 12, 2016Omg Detroit pizza where have you been all my life. Don't forget to order the amazing fried cheese curds!
Excellent pizzas. If there's a wait go to 20 Sided Store next door, where you can play games while waiting to be seated.
John McDermottJuly 23, 2016Pizza, had the Lou Wow!! Cocktails and drinks, staff was attentive and friendly, atmosphere was on par as well!
DrewskiAugust 1, 2016Had the spicy chicken sandwich and Emmy pizza. Both were absolutely delicious. Might even like this better than Emily.
Natalie VJanuary 21, 2017Love the pizza here! Get the colony2 which has honey and chili for a sweet and spicy kick. So good.
Key: two people = 2 pizzas, take home some pieces. Three people is optimal. Burger is the ultimate.
Meg FarmerOctober 18, 2016Omg this place was so good! Try The Emmy- unique spin on pizza, very filling and tasty.
Ram NJuly 22, 2018This is a top-tier, Detroit-style pan pizza spot. Don’t mistake this for a NY-style spot. Highly recommended!
marcy stoneJuly 17, 2017Meatball sandwich is yummy and a bit spicy. I loved the flavor but if you dont like spicy might not be for you.
Claudia FilthOctober 17, 2017Continues to be the best pizza in New York. Try their signature pizza, you won’t be disappointed.
C-Line EatsJanuary 19, 2017Went for the vodka sauce pizza but was most impressed with the Classic - simple but perfect.
Kelly AhearnAugust 27, 2016Get to the burger bar around 6:30-7 on a Friday to snag a seat- it's a Matty good burger for a Pizza Place
Splitting a burger and a Roni Supreme with my lady is one of my favorite meals in NYC.
Dan DickinsonMay 31, 2016Get over your "eww Hawaiian Pizza!" nonsense and feast upon the Lou-Wow. The perfect blend of savory, spicy, and sweet.
Jarel HillMay 27, 2018Had the colony, the Emmy and the roni supreme. All delicious but the colony was so good!
Abdulelah Al-GosaibiAugust 25, 2017Cheese pizza is. Great, and if you're having take out, make sure to have them mix your okonomi fries.
DanNovember 1, 2016Roni Supreme and the cheese curds are the best items on the menu. If you're not a pan pizza fan steer clear.
Phil KatzMay 3, 2016Some of the best and most unique pizza in the city. And the sandwiches are spot on too.
BrooklynBoyOSeptember 10, 2016If you grew up on Elio's or DiGiornio microwave pizza, this'll be right up your alley. Otherwise, if you're not a fan of convection/toaster oven pizza, STEER CLEAR.
Roniel TesslerJune 11, 2017I'm not a huge fan of deep dish because most of the taste is bread rather than cheese/sauce, but if you get something, get the white truffle cream one
Neel BhargavaJune 4, 2017Ridiculously good pizza. If you've never had Detroit style you are in for a great surprise
Jessica M.October 8, 2017As insane as it looks on Instagram. Roni Supreme, The Emmy, and a side of okonomi fries. 👍 You're welcome.
Brooke ChampagneJanuary 20, 2017You must go downstairs to gat the burger! Pizza was delicious but the burger was the bigger star!- Ashley MowreyJune 26, 2018Detroit style pizza at its finest. Nice, attentive staff and a homey environment. The dishes are well curated and executed.
Arthur ShihJuly 21, 2016One of the best pizzas I have ever had. And try the duck wings if they are available!
All pizza has right angles and it is on point. Best is Williamsburg.
Alex PyatetskyJune 17, 20171) came for burger not pizza 2) pricy but excellent 3) exactly 1 burger on menu, not 50. Know what that means? They believe in their food. Refreshing. Maybe a bit salty, but no complaints.
Ira BAugust 9, 2018Still has what I sincerely believe to be the best burger I've ever had.. hands down.
MikeJune 20, 2016Pizza is obviously the best of north brooklyn, but the lunch-only burger is the #1 thing on the menu
Spicy chicken sandwich and the margarita are going on point
Ben GaspariniAugust 14, 2016Such good pizzas and chicken sandwiches. Good beer. P.S. It's always dark in here
Daniel van der StelSeptember 22, 2016Kale salad was nice, Good vibe & the square-pies are very tasty.
365 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Emmy Squared is an American Fast Food restaurant located in the Williamsburg neighborhood of New York City. The restaurant specializes in Detroit-style pizzas which are essentially deep-dish square pizzas with generous toppings of cheese, sauce, veggies and meat...
Open until 11:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 5:00 PM–10:00 PM
- Fri
- Noon–11:00 PM
- Sat
- 10:00 AM–11:00 PM
- Sun
- 10:00 AM–10:00 PM
(718) 360-4535
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 9.1
"Top 3 pizza in NYC. Terrific flavor in the dough and some intriguing topping combos. Well worth the visit."
Victor C - 9.2
"The best pizza in the city!! The hometown bbq brisket pizza was delicious."
marcy stone - 9.1
"Burger is best ever! On Earth... Emily white Pizza w pistachio and truffle is outstanding"
John M
Places people like to go after Emmy Squared Pizza
- 9.1
"I love this place. Ask the employees for recommendations, they're knowledgeable and super passionate."
Cameron Gidari - 9.1
"Great cocktails. Really enjoyed The Brown Derby (bourbon, fresh-squeezed grapefruit & honey)."
Gabriel Hayes - 8.2
"Great happy hour, good vibes with bartenders and the owner, and skee ball"
Samantha Vanderhoof
Appears on 1,780 lists
A State-by-State Guide to America's Best Pizza
Created by Foursquare Swarm
51 items • 568 followers
The 25 Best Pizza Places in NYC
Created by Foursquare Swarm
25 items • 397 followers
17 NYC Restaurants To Try in 2017
Created by Foursquare Swarm
17 items • 462 followers
