See all
308 photos

Grey Lady

Seafood Restaurant, Bar, and American Restaurant$$$$

Lower East Side, New York

Save

Grey Lady

6.7^/10

422

ratings

"Happy hour $1 oysters 4-7 so worth it"(5 Tips)
"The lobster rolls and fries are both equally to die for."(4 Tips)
"... done filling up on oyster happy hour, check out the bacon wrapped scallops."(2 Tips)
"But selection of Cisco brews on tap is good."(2 Tips)

64 Tips and reviews

Filter:

oysters
good for dates
great value
bar
alcohol
music
rum
casual
comedy
coconut
turkey
painkillers
well
honey bourbon
dinner
cardamom
city
small plates
pigs
performances
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Treats ThreadsApril 1, 2019
The happy birthday section prefix section where you share a lobster and 16 oysters with shrimp is killer. Makes you feel better about dropping 80+ with friends. Be split it
Melissa RosenthalSeptember 22, 2014
One of the best oyster places in the city. The staff here clearly cares about their oyster program and takes pride in their selections. Excellent variety as well as small plates. Will be back asap.
Upvoted 6 hours ago
Melissa YuSeptember 11, 2016
Super rad bartender (I think his name was John?). If you're feelin adventurous, have him whip up a cocktail for you based on your likings. You won't be disappointed. HH oysters $1 on the weekend too.
Melissa RosenthalNovember 27, 2014
One of my favorite oyster bars in the city. After you're done filling up on oyster happy hour, check out the bacon wrapped scallops.
7th.ListMay 26, 2012
New England-style raw bar. Seafood privately sourced from Maine. Fresh oysters. Expect live-edge Saxelby cheese boards. Potato-bunned cheeseburgers.Twelve taps and a grip of bottles. Read more
Jordan MApril 25, 2013
Been here 25+ times
Order a Painkiller from Chris or Terrence, tell them I sent you, and they'll give you extra cherries
Gary TorielloJune 21, 2015
'American Dandy' - Wild Turkey American Honey Bourbon, dark rum, pineapple, coconut, cardamom cream, lime
Oz LublingDecember 12, 2016
The lobster rolls and fries are both equally to die for.
Nina LoSchiavoJune 21, 2016
Try the Peekytoe Crab Toast and just about any batter-fried fish that's on the menu.
Alisha OutridgeSeptember 22, 2013
The Yellowfin Tuna burger is delicious. Spicy wasabi aioli FTW
DeannaJune 5, 2013
This place is like, if Long Island made an actually classy/casual beach bar (opposed to the ones that attempt to imitate that) and then oh yeah, moved it to the LES.
Ann Isabelle F.June 29, 2018
Oysters were top notch and very interesting cocktails as well.
Audrey OJune 19, 2015
Amazing drinks. Love the Rekorderlig ones & friendly staff.
Lindsey KimJune 14, 2016
Been here 5+ times
Fun bar on the weekends. Great music and good crowd
Julia MontiOctober 20, 2015
Wild Saturday night out. Full of yuppies. Good music, weak drinks so stick to beer. I don't think they close till 4am.
Basil ShadfanApril 23, 2015
Good happy hour 5-7pm (weekdays?). $1 oysters $5 draft beers
JD HarringtonNovember 4, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Oysters Rockefeller & the Salt Roasted Beets are the truth.
Emily SokolowJanuary 29, 2014
Great comedy every other Tuesday in the back!!! C.U. Next Tuesday!
Emily KaneJuly 6, 2015
Had my first oyster here. #memories
Andy AmendolaJune 16, 2012
Good cocktails like the south-side, very refreshing!
Kevin LillyAugust 7, 2012
The Lobster Roll was unbelievable... Don't eff around... Just order it and thank me later
Rebecca WeinerMarch 23, 2014
Floor to ceiling restored windows make the Grey Lady very classy.
Harry William Cyphers IVSeptember 28, 2012
The rum pig is a great island reminder of SWR Bars Goombay Smash!
Nidhi KayOctober 3, 2016
Happy hour $1 oysters 4-7 so worth it
Ashley BlackmonJune 14, 2015
Lobster scramble to die for!
Vaneide GiacobeMay 16, 2019
Great happy hour. $1 oysters
Michael KretchmarAugust 31, 2013
Happy hour 5-7p, $1 oysters!!!!! So good.
Andrei GheorgheAugust 25, 2015
1$ oysters @ happy hour = brilliant
James AntonizickOctober 14, 2012
The apple crisp is 100% worth the wait.
Kathryn SAugust 26, 2013
The oysters were amazing. Service wasn't the greatest.
Hannah GMJune 25, 2015
Fantastic cocktails and lobster rolls!
Amanda KellyFebruary 11, 2015
This place makes me want to be on the beach! Check it out yourself! Read more
Jonathan RobinsonAugust 5, 2012
Billed as a Nantucket bar. It ain't. And it's kinda dirty. But selection of Cisco brews on tap is good.
Geraldine AlvarezSeptember 23, 2013
Love the live music on Sunday afternoons/early evenings.
Amanda AlbergoAugust 27, 2012
Gorgeous natural light, average brunch. The egg sandwich wasn't bad.
Leah FeuerJune 14, 2012
The Wren but with better burger's and a few blocks south
Ashlie GeorgeMarch 8, 2014
Whiskey Diablo. Bacon. French toast.
Ryan AmbsJune 24, 2015
You can do better in this area of the city
David FejesApril 6, 2016
The Bloody Marys were good
Gianna NebbiaJanuary 23, 2020
Fun music for a night out
David HoltzNovember 16, 2015
Get the Brussels sprouts.
BonSeptember 16, 2012
Pretty small portions. Plan for meal #2.
Kate LSeptember 2, 2012
We found Cisco beer!
Monti BrayFebruary 1, 2015
Cute ambiance for dining but the staff is so-so.
Jessica IampolskaiaJanuary 5, 2014
FRENCH TOAST!!!
Angela WuApril 25, 2017
Oyster happy hour
erin byrnesAugust 22, 2014
jalapeño margarita
EstherJune 15, 2014
Food is pretty good. Don't get the coffee though.
Arun NandiJune 7, 2014
Oysters aren't great
Maurice FontenotSeptember 15, 2012
Beer was $7. With tax it was $7.60. Gave the guy $10. He gave me back $2. Math, anyone?

1 2

308 Photos

Grey Lady

Related Searches

Places inside Grey Lady

You might also like

Places people like to go after Grey Lady

Appears on 329 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.