See all
984 photos

Guy's American Kitchen and Bar

(Now Closed)

American Restaurant$$$$

Theater District, New York

Save

190 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Minnie BrownOctober 13, 2013
Food was great but took way too long to get a waiters attention for anything. We asked for a dessert menu, the waiter passed us 5 times so we asked for the check instead. 😞
Sumitra GuruMarch 19, 2014
Best nachos we've ever had!
Nora ChangSeptember 23, 2016
Decent food. Overpriced but typical of times square/theater district. Quality was acceptable and wait was shorter compared to surrounding area eateries.
Steve FigsJuly 20, 2013
Good food..though many of the staff dont look happy to be there.
Scott AndersonJune 24, 2014
Amazing food.....Service was HORRIBLE!!
Jenn VargasJune 7, 2013
Wow...I was hoping all of the negative reviews were an exaggeration, but it turns out this place is a glorified TGIFridays.
🆗🆒Lindsey WeberSeptember 11, 2012
FYI the PBR tallboys are $7. Enjoy!
Sharon SkFebruary 1, 2013
No tall, grande, venti at this place- donkey sauce is only served in slathers. The menu alone could be published...as a gift book of American sadness.
Linda CarrionMay 26, 2014
I love Guy and am a huge fan of triple d but I gotta admit I was disappointed. Ordered the a Rotisserie Chicken sandwich and it was average and way over priced. First and last time here.
Jim NasbyMay 13, 2013
Awesome food! The beers were a bit disappointing.
Maribel LaraNovember 17, 2012
Don't drink the donkey sauce through a straw.
Joanne MartinezSeptember 14, 2014
Everything
Tim FogartyNovember 17, 2012
Go off menu, order the vegetarian chili.
bobby fingerSeptember 11, 2012
Gorgeous waitstaff. Delicious carbs.
Tony SmithSeptember 24, 2013
Only been here 5 mins and service great
InnaFebruary 24, 2013
Not sure how everyone raved about great service, but I didn't get silverware, they forgot to bring appetizers and took 10 min to get ketchup. Burger was surprisingly good though.
Paull YoungDecember 2, 2012
The Donkey Sauce is made from REAL donkey!!!
Becky GoldenbergJanuary 11, 2014
Great waiter Paul k. Surprisingly good food
C. FergyJuly 26, 2013
Food was great. Sevice was good.
Mark FoxMarch 14, 2013
Bring mints if you order the garlic frys
David RahtzMarch 18, 2013
Don't remember ordering the Cold Burger but I got one anyway and I wouldn't recommend it.
Sean LodgeOctober 4, 2012
Heard in the news that my man Guy Fieri opened up a new 'rant in The Big Apple?! Supposed to be rockin', and breakin' all the rules!
M. G. StellaOctober 31, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Good meat loaf
Jackie ChanNovember 22, 2012
Sashimi tacos are amazing!
Jason OstranderFebruary 2, 2013
This place looks cheap and sad... Where is guy?? Their redemption is my super strong drink
ShahOctober 12, 2014
Welcome to Flavortown.
Ryan WilkersonMarch 27, 2013
Avoid the food, the service, and the decor, and you'll be good.
Jenna HellmuthApril 18, 2013
The big dipper was amazing!
Andrea De La CruzDecember 16, 2013
I was looking forward to amazing food, but I found average food! Unfortunately I was not impressed with the food at all! Our waiter had an attitude. Sorry Guy but I won't be going back:( nothing great
Mats S.November 2, 2012
Cajun chicken alfredo is awesome.
Andrea RosenSeptember 11, 2012
Tell AJ you work for VH1 and he'll put out.
Cass COctober 3, 2012
The Guy-talian nachos are SO MONEY!!
Max RodriguezJune 23, 2013
Well when I placed my order for tea at 2:20 and 2:45 rolled around and I hadn't see the guy...I had to leave
Gene AndersenAugust 16, 2013
Go here, it was great!
Raveen SingamMarch 26, 2014
Guy-talian Nachos for the win!
Raveen SingamMarch 26, 2014
GAKB wifi password american123
🌟Bex SchwartzSeptember 11, 2012
This Jimmy Fallon Boozy Creamsicle is very soothing to my very hurty throat!
Jason BNovember 29, 2012
Fender room is kind of a neat spot. Not as noisy. Ribs are pretty good.
Iraís SoriaJanuary 5, 2013
44th New York Strip so tasty!
S WJanuary 30, 2013
They charge extra for substituting fries with sweet potato fries
Christina TroitinoSeptember 13, 2012
I came, I saw... I got fieri'd
David GardinerFebruary 28, 2015
Great beer.
Estelle DavisFebruary 20, 2014
Try the burger!!
Scott FiorettaFebruary 13, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Food so good it blew my mind. Out of my ass.
Lou CarulliJanuary 13, 2015
It's was ok. Went for a corporate event in the lower level. Nothing stood out from the items I had.
Dory MacielDecember 18, 2013
Butternut squash soup and jack nog!!! Yea!
Jeffrey LovellNovember 19, 2013
Vegas Fries were awesome!
Al BradleyJuly 31, 2013
Great pulled pork sliders
Travis SwinglerApril 30, 2013
Wifi password: american123
Ally MillarNovember 15, 2012
Get the onion rings.

1 2 3 4

984 Photos

Guy's American Kitchen and Bar

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Guy's American Kitchen and Bar

Appears on 88 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.