Malatesta Trattoria
Italian Restaurant$$$$
West Village, New York
Has a stamp of approval from The Corcoran Group and Village Voice
"And the spinach gnocchi was delicious, and light for a creamy sauce!"(45 Tips)
"Excellent Tagliatelle Ragu, but ignore the Tiramisu"(10 Tips)
"Grilled octopus is amazing."(7 Tips)
"Good authentic Italian food in a cozy atmosphere."(6 Tips)
192 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- good for dates
- casual
- chicken cutlets
- bruschetta
- cute
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
samantha hankinsAugust 8, 2014*Unbelievably good.* Authentic Italian food in a relaxed atmosphere that reminded me of restaurants in Italy. Spaghetti alla chitarra! Tagliatelle in ragu! Inexpensive wine. What's not to love here!
AFAR MediaAugust 12, 2014If you come during peak hours and days, be prepared to wait, but there are plenty of places nearby to grab a drink, as well as the West Side Highway and Hudson River only one short block west. Read more
Annie TolochinskiMay 17, 2015Great pasta at this romantic dinner date spot. Snag a table outside and enjoy this quite corner in the west village, away from it all, it actually feels like you traveled to Italy.
honeywhatscooking.comMay 17, 2016Get the spinach gnocchi in Gorgonzola sauce. Rich. excellent. Bruschetta toast needed to be crisp. Grilled calamari huge letdown-not sure what ppl are thinking. Tiramisu is so average.
Dee NAugust 20, 2013Spinach Gorgonzola gnocchi is out of this world good. Pick a day when the weather is great and sit outside. Wine carafes are affordable and the location is perfect for a little people-watching. #CPL8
The Corcoran GroupOctober 24, 2011Outstanding Italian food served by cute and charming Italian waiters. Grab a table outside and dive into a plate of Spinach Gnocchi and a side of Meatballs. Make a reservation!- This is the West Village vibe that you want. Go here on a nice day, sit outside, take in the air, enjoy your meal, go stroll the West Village, grab a drink...but start it all here.
Ashley MJune 24, 2016Great location, delicious wine, and fantastic service. Made recommendations on menu items and the pasta is fresh. Cash only- highly recommend
Halstead PropertyOctober 7, 2013This neighborhood gem takes those fluffy, pillow-like gnocchi dishes to a whole new level. The homemade Spinach Gnocchi is full of richness from the Gorgonzola cheese sauce – it’s a must order!- Simon AbramsMay 14, 2017Feels like you're on a little vacation in Italy. The bruschetta is delicious; the steak and shaved parmesan is fantastic, but the lamb chops are my absolute favorite.
Alex RichardsJuly 30, 2015This place is cash only - there is an ATM in the deli around the corner. The food is great, service is whatever, but be prepared to fall asleep after eating the gnocchi - It made me pass out. :)
Anechka M.March 16, 2019It was great! Spaghetti with mussels and tortellini with ragu were delicious, wine is ca 39$ per bottle and, service is quick, waiting time no more than 20 min
Cozy, authentic Italian restaurant in the West Village, reasonably priced for excellent quality and portions. Grab a carafe of Sangiovese, order the Spinach Gnocchi and relax under the stars.
Yasmin Zar-BlockJune 16, 2013This place is one if my favorite restaurants for dinner in NYC. Candlelit romantic vibe, authentic Italian fare, great staff, and chock full of gorgeous people to stare at. Prices are great too.
KESeptember 26, 2016Nice, romantic vibe. Attentive service, love that they open the windows and seat people indoors and out. $7 house red wine 👌 fish of the day was melt in your mouth!
Steven KornblitDecember 31, 2012The spinach gnocchi in Gorgonzola cream sauce is very special. If you love gnocchi you must try this to see if it's the best you've ever had.
Michael NataleJuly 31, 2015Gnocchi gnocchi gnocchi. Get the spinach or potato. Ask for whatever sauce you want - they mix and match the pastas no problem. Meatballs are great too
Village VoiceAugust 4, 2014Enjoy the stuffed flatbread piadina, or the predictably great bolognese sauce, here called by its proper name of tagliatelle al ragu. Read more
Kathryn DJune 8, 2018Go when weather is nice, sit outside with a bottle of wine, and order spinach gnocchi.
Chelsea BalkanFebruary 9, 2014#FabuLIST #DubiDO mussels (to die for), crostini (bruschetta, mushrooms prosciutto, Gorgonzola) spinach gnocchi, and spaghetti with basil and mozzarella. Cheap wine too!!
Brigette K.December 13, 2014Date night with my boyfriend! Very cozy and great food, cash only. Not too expensive. Sort of weird how they seat you, not many two tops. Be prepared to wait. Waiters nice but scatterbrained.
My favorite Italian restaurant in the city. There isn't a thing on the menu that isn't good but the piadina mozzarella are a must for appetizers.
Pratheeksha KSDecember 27, 2017Spinach gnocchi, polenta, anything with gorgonzola really. Cozy date friendly spot, they sing happy birthday in Italian! Cash only
Food is amazing - The best gnocchi I've ever had. Spaghetti and chicken melanaise were both fantastic as well. But it's a hassle - cash only, middle of nowhere, always a wait.
One of the highest value dinners in the area. Fresh, homemade pasta and sauces at a very affordable price. Highly recommended.
Asli SJuly 10, 2018Cute place for a weekend lunch. Burrata was great. Spinach gnocchi was delicious but the cream sauce was quite rich. Great service too!
Patrick BaskinNovember 3, 2014Fresh pasta is awesome and worth the trip, get the Spaghetti &/or spinach gnocchi- Nikki 🌺October 6, 2013Amazing penne arrabiata! Reminded me of my grandmas's sauces. And the spinach gnocchi was delicious, and light for a creamy sauce!
Drew JenningsSeptember 4, 2014Amazing authentic Italian food. Try the spinach gnocchi with gorgonzola sauce. It's cash only, though, so plan ahead.
Becca BaeSeptember 24, 2014One of my all time favorite Italian restaurants in NY. The spinach gnocchi can turn your day around. Cash only!
OlinMarch 24, 2018Atmosphere is beautiful, lighting is warm, staff is kind and the food, oh the food, is delicious!!
ZephanSeptember 18, 2013Everything is delicious. You can't go wrong with one of their homemade pastas. Spinach gnocchi is a bit heavy but scrumptious.
Ayca AcunJune 16, 2015Special black ink linguini with shrimp... Omg to die for.. Also raw artichoke salad is must try!!!
Cash only! But really delicious food. The gnocchi is something not to be missed, specifically the spinach gnocchi.
chin1taJune 24, 2016great local spot with walls that open onto a sunny corner . the pasta is some of the best around !!!
Nicolette RomeroFebruary 14, 2015Don't leave without ordering the spinach gnocchi. It's one of the top 3 gnocchi dishes in the city!
Meg FarmerOctober 8, 2014Was taken on a first date here and really enjoyed it. Gnocchi was delish, scene was super cute, service was superb.
Emily ButlerNovember 4, 2012The Tagliatelle ragu is delicious. My favorite pasta dish in NYC so far, it's like a big, homely hug from your Italian friend's grandmother.
Shane AntonyDecember 23, 2017Not sure why this has such good reviews. I ordered the grilled calamari. It was ok. My friend really did not like the spinach gnocchi. There are better Italian restaurants in the hood. Go to those.
Jaclyn RDecember 31, 2018Good neighborhood spot with classic pasta dishes. Good place if you’re in the neighborhood and trying to avoid a heavy wait time
HectorApril 26, 2014Excellent date spot, but be prepared to wait. Noisy ambiance, good for crowds though. Spinach gnocchi is the best.
Walker HardenAugust 11, 2013Chicken cutlet was perfectly done. Chicken arugula tomatoes and Parmesan were a perfect combination. Ate it too fast for a picture ...
Kristina PNovember 13, 2016you can't go wrong with the pasta: spinach gnocchi and tagliatelle were both amazing.
- Meredith BlechmanJune 13, 2016Grilled octopus is amazing. And of course, pasta. Small and cozy. Cash only.
Wesley BlissAugust 23, 2014Cute, casual, and somewhat romantic, with great outdoor seating. Food is superb, though the appetizers (bruschetta, etc.) were underwhelming.- New York HabitatNovember 29, 2011Good authentic Italian food in a cozy atmosphere. Definitely try the spinach gnocchi, just remember that it's cash only!
Try the Tagliatelle al ragu Bolognese - Sumptuous homemade noodles, hearty sauce and a great price make this pasta the one to beat.
There's always been a wait when I go but it's a lovely cozy place in the west village. Yummy home-made pasta but cash only!
Our New Favorite Place - Reminds us of a place we ate at in Torino, Italy. The food and service are excellent.
252 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Malatesta Trattoria
649 Washington St (btwn 10th St & Christopher St)
New York, NY 10014
United States
New York, NY 10014
United States
Open until 11:30 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 5:30 PM–11:30 PM
(212) 741-1207
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Parking
Street
Restroom
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dinner
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Appears on 1,038 lists
Created by CBM
63 items • 101 followers
Created by New York Habitat
44 items • 316 followers
Created by Pinyo™
45 items • 59 followers
