Planning a trip to Baltimore?
Foursquare can help you find the best places to go to.
"Best pizza in Baltimore."(3 Tips)
"... Anna's Stuffed, and Crab pies. All are great! Spring for the large ones..."(2 Tips)
"Strictly deep dish style."(6 Tips)
"Try the new Shrimp Fra Diavlo Pizza!!! It's spicy!!!!! Ohhhh yeaaaa"(3 Tips)
48 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- pizza
- fra diavolo
- house salad
- spicy food
- casual
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Cole TNovember 12, 2018Lot of people will tell you this is the best pizza in Bmore—I have different preferences but it is certainly good, with a very home-like atmosphere inside frequented by locals. Crab pizza is A+.
Kenny TDecember 16, 2016I really enjoyed the 2 cheese pizza. Nice twist of flavor. The Fra diavolo tasted like sriracha and I enjoyed it thoroughly! Reminded me of Pizza Hut crusts with modern flavor
Kaila SquiresOctober 3, 2013The Margherita pizza was Delish! The crust is thick and has a crunch too it. And it's nice n cheesy too.😋😁
- I have tried the Everything, Four Seasons, Anna's Stuffed, and Crab pies. All are great! Spring for the large ones when you have a choice and take the leftovers home.
Greg S.January 19, 2015Looks like your mom and dad's pizza joint; the interior is still stuck in 1943. Don't let that fool you-- they have great deep dish style pizza. Try the 4 Seasons pizza.
David SmithDecember 29, 2015Stopped in while visiting from Atlanta. Staff was friendly and the pizza and sliders were great. Will definitely be going back the next time Im in Baltimore.
Angie OsmanskiOctober 21, 2015Loved the pizza here!! Crispy crust, with delicious sauce & just the right amount. The meatball topping is amazing!!
Serious EatsFebruary 1, 2012Go with the pepperoni; it curls, crisps, and releases little pools (ok, big pools) of spicy grease into the absorbent dough, flavoring each bite. Read more
Ben BrassoDecember 7, 2014Great local atmosphere, service and pizza. Everything pizza is great. Tomato and mozz crostini appetizer was delicious starter.- The Caprese Toast w/ Shirmp is probably the most delicious item on the menu. Fresh Mozzarella and Roma Tomato, Basil EVOO and Balsalmic!!! Beat that!!!
Rachel LFebruary 10, 2016Old World Italian Specialities at Matthew's Pizza in Highlandtown - try the meatballs, garlic bread, or pizza! http://liketheteaeats.com/2016/02/10/matthews-pizza-highlandtown/- Chad HolbeinSeptember 25, 2016Deep dish pizza. Get the 2 cheese kind, not 3 cheese. Meatballs are in my atop 3 in Baltimore.
Melissa McCartySeptember 28, 2013One of the best pizzas I've ever had and huge house salads! I highly recommend. Its a favorite stop for us.
TV Food MapsSeptember 29, 2015Check out Matthews Pizza as it was featured on Food Paradise for Anna's Stuffed Pie Read more
Bryan KellyNovember 5, 2014I am from Chicago. This isn't deep dish. Pillowy crust boosts up the cheese and toppings, but it isn't deep dish. The price isn't bad, but I didn't like the stuffed pizza or the pizza sauce.
Stacy AdamNovember 30, 2010Get a large pizza and the house salad to split for 2 people. Any place were 2 people can eat really good food for less than $20 total is great!
FtomSeptember 28, 2019Absolutely phenomenal!!!! Never tasted anything like it, don’t think I ever will IT WAS SO GOOD !- John SmithNovember 20, 2017This place is resting on its laurels. The next time you think to bully one lowly prospective customer like me, remember that your reputation is built on customers and we are not here to serve you!
mishmashmargieSeptember 6, 2013Didn't have the time to waits for a full pizza. Has the pizza sub instead. Delicious.
Check out the bar down stairs on Friday and Saturday .- House salad and a Lg Pizza. Perfect dinner for 2 under $20. Can't beat it!!!
Mark WakefieldJanuary 15, 2010The crab pie is awesome but only if you don't mind shelling out $15+ for a personal pizza...
Dankwa BrooksFebruary 8, 2012Having the leftover pizza from yesterday & it's STILL CRISPY out of the microwave!
Have a drink in the bar dowstairs while you wait for the best pizza in Baltimore.
Sean LazaroMarch 19, 2011Pizza is good. Prices are bad and size of portion is terrible. Spend 12 and leave hungry- Try the new Shrimp Fra Diavlo Pizza!!! It's spicy!!!!! Ohhhh yeaaaa
77 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Matthew's Pizza
3131 Eastern Ave (btwn SE Ave. & S. Robinson St.)
Baltimore, MD 21224
United States
Baltimore, MD 21224
United States
Closed until 11:00 AM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
- Sun
- Noon–9:00 PM
(410) 276-8755
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
Yes
Wi-Fi
Free
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Drinks
Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Matthew's Pizza
- 8.6
"Try the Omlette - Loaded w/ braised pork cheeks, feta and beet greens. Rockin'!! And great hash browns & toast. That's right, toast - try it - it's not your mama's toast!"
Lisa Kleinwort - 8.9
"Great park to walk around. Beautiful pond & Pagoda"
Angie Osmanski - 6.1
"A little expensive, but a super fun local hangout. BYOB."
Chris Richards
Appears on 63 lists
Created by Scott Cover
21 items • 56 followers
Created by Best of Foursquare
10 items • 36 followers
Canton Restaurants, Bars, and Taverns
Created by Elliott Plack
78 items • 63 followers
