- ice cream
- cookies
- pretzels
- milk
- chocolate
- Popular
- Recent
- Staff PicksMarch 22, 2017Their unique desserts are reminiscent of that perfect sweet and salty milk left at the bottom of your cereal bowl. Try the birthday cake truffles, or if you're up for it - the boozy milkshakes.
- all of the typical milk bar offerings, including a sprinkle wall for optimal Instagramming
- Paige CMay 9, 2018Very friendly staff. They let you sample whatever you would like. Can’t get enough of the chocolate covered pretzel ice cream!
- Just by Christopher Street metro station and open late. Love the cereal ice cream and I just can't resist birthday truffles from this place. Seriously, it is becoming a problem!
- K MApril 11, 2019Cereal ice cream forever! Make sure you get the corn flakes crunch on it. Also: the corn cookies are amazing.
- Michelle WilesJune 24, 2017The extra crunchies at the bottom of the cereal soft serve are a great touch.
- Autumn ChoiApril 11, 2022The hype was before similar better cookie stores popped up everywhere. The cookies are pre-packaged and not freshly baked
- Aditi LuthraJuly 22, 2017The ice cream really truly tastes like milk. I skip the cereal, find it salty
- Christopher DoyleOctober 4, 2019They do a $20 "Greatest Hits" deal which has everything you've seen on the Netflix documentary!