Foursquare City Guide

Nearby:

Get inspired:

See all
703 photos

New York Pizza Suprema

Pizzeria$$$$

Chelsea, New York

Save

Share

New York Pizza Suprema

8.9^/10

1,314

ratings

Ranked #3 for NY style pizza in New York
Has a stamp of approval from Serious Eats and Gothamist
"Best place for pizza by the slice near Penn Station."(20 Tips)
"Cosy place with amazing pizza, loved Upside down and Hawaiian."(13 Tips)
"The upside down slice was good and cheap... good service also"(10 Tips)
"Def on of the best NY style pizzas in town."(7 Tips)

308 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
penn station
upside
casual
good for a quick meal
good for a late night
lively
upside down slice
good for groups
cheese pies
white pies
gardens
whole pies
cheese
sausage
delis
Sicilian
city
spinach
inexpensive
(15 more)

Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Gabriel HayesJanuary 18, 2016
Best place for pizza by the slice near Penn Station.
Ashlyn AiuDecember 28, 2016
Best New York pizza. Will be back often. :)
Klelia RamosOctober 8, 2022
Best pizza ever!!! Super deli!!!!
Bogdan GunaSeptember 3, 2015
Great pizza, lively place, good for groups
Polina WeitzDecember 10, 2016
Love this place. Great success, large variety.
Greg WeinsteinMarch 8, 2014
Best regular slice in NYC hands down.
Erika ArreaSeptember 2, 2018
Margarita all the way!!!!!!
Tamara RussellSeptember 14, 2013
Mushroom slice was pretty tasty! I will be going back
David AitkenMarch 20, 2015
Great slice - marinara sauce is great!
Seline JungJune 6, 2016
Plain cheese pizza is on the salty side and the crust can get hard. But it is tasty enough.
Tom Crypto UKJuly 13, 2017
Best Pizza I've ever had in NY hands down!
Lisa MMay 10, 2013
Possibly the best slice in the city. Try the upsidedown
LilySeptember 27, 2015
Quick and simple. Love the mushroom pizza
PizzaSnobo pizzasnobo.comFebruary 9, 2011
If you find yourself at Penn Station or Madison Square Garden, this is the best pizza in the hood.
Douglas WidickJuly 6, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Fresh cheese, sweet onion sauce...what's not to like?
Cutter HouckApril 2, 2012
Save yourself some dough before going into Madison Square Garden and grab a slice.
Teresa MansbachFebruary 28, 2014
Chill place by penn station. The bar tender with the gap in his teeth is cute
Diego RufoApril 5, 2011
The Upside Down Pizza and the NY Cheese are the two best (and famous). Read more
Emily CampoSeptember 30, 2014
Excellent margherita and suprema special
Chris BarredoJuly 25, 2013
don't get creative with your ordering. stay with the tried and true ny-style pizza offerings.
Annemarie CullenAugust 3, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Surprisingly good slice. Didn't think you could get that in midtown!
estherSeptember 3, 2014
The upside down slice was good and cheap... good service also
Vic C.August 11, 2014
Amazingly good slice...great crust
Carlos SarziJune 10, 2016
the best pizza ever!
Michael JaccarinoDecember 16, 2013
Best pizza and Greek salad! Worth the wait!
Ryan QuigleyOctober 29, 2016
Either they make it bigger or they make the pizza worse.
Lance FiascoOctober 29, 2016
Been here 5+ times
You won't leave without trying one of everything 👌
Ron LMarch 10, 2017
Sausage pizza top notch
Sage WohnsJune 6, 2014
Note for Alan: the upside down pizza is only figuratively upside down
Janet De bieJuly 28, 2015
The pizza crust was awesome
Shaun Farrugia🌹September 15, 2011
Been here 50+ times
Plain slice is best in the city!!!!!!!! My taste buds crave it!
Brian DeVitoJune 26, 2013
Allegedly ranked the best slice in the city with news articles to prove it.
Aaron WertliebApril 27, 2018
All the pizza sauce is great
Nichole Shrom-KucFebruary 20, 2019
Tons of options and great atmosphere.
James SpotaFebruary 17, 2013
great pizza, terrible service. The guy at the counter couldn't tell the difference between sausage & pepperoni
Lacey S.May 5, 2011
GOOD pizza! One of the best slices of white pizza I've ever had :)
e MLApril 21, 2014
Pizza's ok but definitely pricier than most.
Paul NovareseMarch 16, 2020
THE BEST. Go no further.
Dean SilfenJuly 31, 2022
Been here 5+ times
I mean this place rules. Just go
ElizabethMay 25, 2011
Meat lovers is delicious. By far one of the best pizza places in NY!
Bruno AlvesMay 21, 2016
Amazing Pizza!
Katherine SungApril 28, 2011
The best pizza made fresh with quality ingredients, I'm not kidding!
Tonê Bologna1 week ago
a slice or two please… 😋🤤
Greg MacDonaldJune 24, 2018
Best pizza near Penn Station.
Jeffrey YJune 23, 2017
Been here 5+ times
Upside down slice is superb!
EmilyJune 24, 2015
One of our favorite quick slice stops
Jake CohenJune 15, 2015
Best pizza by the slice around.
Sarah McClutchyApril 23, 2012
Only pizza spot with a perfect rating on Slice Harvester
Gennady BarskyApril 13, 2016
Best pizza in NY hands down!
Gary GibbonsDecember 29, 2011
Voted best pizza in New York http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970203935604577064641987645430.html?fb_ref=wsj_share_FB

703 Photos

Related Searches

new york pizza suprema new york •
new york pizza suprema new york photos •
new york pizza suprema new york location •
new york pizza suprema new york address •
new york pizza suprema new york •
new york pizza suprema new york •
ny pizza suprema new york •
ny pizza supreme new york •
pizza suprema new york •
pizza supreme new york •
suprema pizza new york •
new york pizza suprema chelsea new york

More Great Places in New York:
a
b
c
d
e
f
g
h
i
j
k
l
m
n
o
p
q
r
s
t
u
v
w
x
y
z
#

Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA

You must enable JavaScript to use foursquare.com

We use the latest and greatest technology available to provide the best possible web experience.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser settings to continue.

Download Foursquare for your smart phone and start exploring the world around you!