Important Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.Pepolino
Italian Restaurant$$$$
Tribeca, New York
"Definitely try the mussels and the ricotta cheesecake is to die for!"(16 Tips)
"The ricotta cheese cake is a must!"(3 Tips)
"Great veal pappardelle"(4 Tips)
"off menu black linguini with seafood"(2 Tips)
110 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- Italian food
- cheesecake
- good service
- cute
- spacious seats
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Micah MoreauSeptember 23, 2016In priority order: 1). Ricotta cheesecake; 2). Veal and ricotta meatballs; 3. Squid ink linguine; 4). Ricotta gnocchi. They're all outstanding dishes. Place is a goldmine.Upvoted 4 weeks ago
Bruce HaydonApril 23, 2017Cozy & popular - make reservations early! The tomato plate they serve with the bread is unlike anything I've had before - very distinct, very good! Daily pasta specials that have always been amazing.
Rubén GarcíaMarch 6, 2018Apps: grilled eggplant, calamari and shrimp. Mains: The fettuccini with rabbit was incredible, and can also highly recommend the black linguini with seafood. For dessert, ricotta cheesecake FTW!
- DoubleDeuceJanuary 5, 2020Solid Italian food options with great service, a good wine list and spacious seating. It also seems more Italian and less American Italian for those looking for more Italy and less Olive Garden.
Elizabeth BursteinOctober 7, 2021Really good tuscan. Ricotta cheesecake is a must. Rabbit pasta and crispy burata great. Montepulciano good. Gnocci can pass on.
Janae RedmondMarch 16, 2014The closest you will come to a taste of Italy! Lovely experience, veal ragu was fantastic, so was the smoked eggplant and mozz! Won't be disappointed!
Nouf JJune 16, 2019One of the best Italian food I’ve ever tried!! we enjoyed every single dish .. even the welcoming bread and spread was so yummy. Don’t miss the creme brulee 😋- Ernesto GutierrezApril 22, 2018Incredible experience for lunch outside. You must have the off menu black linguini with seafood, spinach toast wit cheese and the mussels in cilantro garlic butter sauce.
Megan JohnsonNovember 24, 2013Puréed cannellini bean soup and butternut squash soup both to die for; tagliatelle with Italian ham was almost too rich. The ricotta cheesecake was sold out before we could try it. Good for groups.
Darren LachtmanDecember 24, 2012Just finished meal and it could be favorite spot in city now. Sausage crostini, homemade pastas, branzino and ricotta cheesecake are legendary. Endless fresh bread basket and authentic ambiance. Go!- Andrew StellaOctober 15, 2016The mussels were on mars, out of the shell in an orgasmic butter and garlic sauce. Bless these dons
Ricky SombornJanuary 23, 2014Hands down one of the best Italian restaurants I've been to. Food is great and the staff makes you feel like family.Order the Crostina di Salsiccia e Stracchino as an appetizer.
Andy ChapmanDecember 21, 2016Cozy spot, upstairs is great though a bit tight. Special papardelle with pork was excellent and mussels appetizer should be at top of your list
Jo RoNovember 7, 2013Great food, amazing service!! Cheesecake is a must, and the chocolate cake is also amazing! They Gave us a free dessert on top of what we ordered!
Wonderful Italian restaurant - one of my favorites in all the city. Must do for the area or searching for date worthy or best Italian.
Lynnelle WilsonJuly 4, 2011Pappardelle Pepolino is not to be missed. Home made pappardelle with tomato sauce & fresh thyme. A half-order is the perfect pasta starter. Read more
Rana AlfiFebruary 26, 2019Very delicious authentic italian food ..great service and they are so helpful 👌🏻
Village VoiceAugust 15, 2014Nothing in town quite matches the perfection of the cheese and spinach ravioli, or tagliata, a sliced steak served with greenery; or inzimino, a dense calamari sludge not for the squeamish. Read more
s vMarch 31, 2015They do COMBOs.... As in you get half of 2 diff pastas !!!...Waiter offered when we each could decide btwn 2: "Why not have both"? Wish more places did this
Linda ChowMarch 16, 2015Had a lovely experience here with great service, delicious Italian food, and the most amazing ricotta cheesecake ever.
Saverio CianfroneApril 6, 2014Possibly the best Italian restaurant I have tried in nyc! Great service too, and the ricotta cheesecake is a must!
Wayne FordMay 16, 2011Great traditional Italian restaurant, good wine list, excellent menu, and what may be the finest ricotta cheese cake in New York. (via Scoville) Read more
Patrick BaskinJanuary 15, 2017Cute Italian restaurant, bread appetizer is awesome, must save room for the chocolate cake
Lui SiehDecember 27, 2015Pasta, Fish, creme brulee, flourless chocolate cake, Italian wines, service, ambience
Brian McGAugust 17, 2022Must try the meatballs - can even get as a side with you main (highly recommend)
Navya ChitimireddyMay 26, 2013Go for the cheese cake. It's the lightest yummiest dessert to finish off the awesome dinner menu.
MarissaFebruary 1, 2014Food was amazing! Definitely have to try their desserts esp. Ricotta cheesecake and chocolate flan
Edu PouNovember 16, 2014Meatballs and malfatti are delicious. I'm half way there, but I wanted to stop and share the goodness. That's how fantastic they are.
Nikki StadniukJuly 31, 2015Had the veal and ricotta meatballs very good! Try the ricotta cheesecake for dessert.- Anastasia SmolinaApril 13, 2019Authentic Italian (not American Italian) food, delicious, and the service is awesome!
Mike GattyApril 24, 2013If I had children, I would want them to cook like this. OMG, everything is fantastic, but the cheesecake: The best ever.
Don't go to Little Italy. Come here. Amazing food and service! My highlights: Tuscan bread soup, rabbit Raghu with pasta
Laura VitaroMay 23, 2013Cheesecake. It's like a cloud of magical creamy deliciousness. I've never had anything like it.
Daniel BairdMarch 29, 2013Try the Spaghettini Ai Gamberi - #nom yumm yumm yumm excellent #garlic and #oliveoil pasta and perfectly cooked #shrimp
get the spaghetti with leeks and the spaghetti with tomato and thyme sauce.
Vongell LugoMay 5, 2011Excellent service...amazing food and captivating atmosphere! What else could one ask for! You've gotta check this place out!
Tim WallaceDecember 15, 2011Great small Italian restaurant. Good food. Atmosphere. Fast service but professional. Spinach souffle was amazing.
Monica Juniel ByersDecember 7, 2013The tomato flan is a masterpiece. I love it so much I want to marry it....
Wonderful place, great food, cheese cake the best, homemade))
Annie SilvaFebruary 16, 2014Amazing ambiance, entire staff is Italian and have net met a friendlier crew.
Margaret ScarboroughJuly 7, 2010they give you a little appetizer when you sit down, delicious, and they may offer you a dessert with your cafe....very generous and great service! it's actually spelled "Pepolino" Read more
141 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 11:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- Noon–11:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- Noon–Midnight
(212) 966-9983
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Pepolino
Appears on 453 lists
Created by Kino
272 items • 19 followers
Created by SMKN 5 Pandeglang
51 items • 71 followers
Created by Audrey Bartow
200 items • 16 followers
