Portobello Cafe
Italian Restaurant and Bar$$$$
Eltingville, Staten Island
"Our waitress Alyssa"(3 Tips)"This was our first time at Portobello Cafe."(2 Tips)"We had chicken Francese and the house pasta and both were delicious!"(3 Tips)"Chicken parm was delicious as always, my favorite!!"(9 Tips)
1,311 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- chicken parmigiana
- great value
- waitress alyssa
- good for dates
- comfortable
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- Visit LYSPER.comMarch 9, 2015Loved our server! She suggested the bacon scallops, and they were wonderful. We were not thrilled with the bacon slab. It was not very tender. Both main courses were very good. The cherry cobbler... Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comOctober 29, 2014Such am incredible experience every time we come! From service to taste the quality at this establishment has raised the bar for restaurants across the island. I would highly recommend the buy on... Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comJune 24, 2014Came here for an after vacation dinner and it was a great end of my weekend treat. My steak dinner was delicious but I could barely finish it due to my two appetizers. The price for the amount of... Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comApril 22, 2015This is one of THE BEST Restaurants on the Island. I would never be embarrassed to bring any guests here and we come here as often as we are able. The staff is ALWAYS top notch. we love Carol!... Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comMay 20, 2014The food is absolutely delicious and the drinks were just as perfect! The servers were extremely attentive and wonderfully polite. Definitely a great place for beautiful conversation, and is righ... Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comMay 22, 2014This is one of our favorite go to restaurants for both us as a married couple and if we want to bring friends. The food is delicious , service is excellent, and the prices are very reasonable. W... Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneMarch 10, 2018Melissa was amazing!!!!! The bacon wrapped filet potatoes were cold n bacon was not cooked. The rice balls was an awesome appetizer. We would come back again as long as we had Melissa as our ser...
- Visit LYSPER.comMay 22, 2014My friend and I ordered the house pasta and the chicken parm. Both were delicious! Frank was our server he was awesome. They took very good care of us I will definitely be back! Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comNovember 13, 2014Great experience every time I come here. Love the specials and best cappuccino on SI. Manager Jen is a doll, and the wait staff is very helpful and know how to give great dining experience. Will ... Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneNovember 7, 2018The food and the service were amazing. Our waiter Joey was great and helped us decide what to order. This was our first time coming here and we will definitely be back.
- Visit LYSPER.comJune 1, 2014This was my 1st time here and sitting in the garden could not have been more relaxing and the cherry on my Sunday was my server Donna. She was more than wonderful. When she noticed I was chilly s... Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneSeptember 23, 2018My family and I had such a lovely dinner and experience with out server. She was always checking in making sure we were statisfied and our drinks were always filled. Even engaging in conversation...
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 26, 2018Amazing place with amazing people. We wish we could treat ourselves more often, but we're here for the guilty pleasures: moms Sunday sauce, da best chicken parm, and the fettuccini Alfredo. Even ...
- LysperApp For iPhoneOctober 9, 2019Our waiter Nick was absolutely the best, never had to wait for anything always had a smile and was always pleasant, would recommend him to any one who comes to eat at this establishment...
- LysperApp For iPhoneJune 2, 2019My experience was excellent. Mauricio was very welcoming, friendly, knowledgable and extremely patient with my toddler, who was extremely energetic. Mauricio came by multiple times to try and cal...
- Visit LYSPER.comNovember 24, 2014I live in the area come to eat here very often. Best service and food by far. Always Reccomend Portabello's for friends and family to go to for dinner or even lunch. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneFebruary 22, 2019Our dining experience was excellent, primarily due to our outstanding waitress. She was professional, attentive, courteous, and offered on point recommendations. I will most definitely return and...
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 27, 2018The service was excellent the waiter was polite and curteous and friendly the food was delisious as it always is we always enjoy the eating at Portobello awe come often.
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 4, 2016Atmosphere was pleasant. Food was great and the service was excellent, I am a waitress for over 15 years and joeys service was polite receptive and pleasant. No complaints except from the window ...
- LysperApp For iPhoneJune 16, 2019Portobello is always our go to Italian restaurant. Food and service are always top notch. Our waitress Amy is amazing, she is the best. Very attentive and accommodating.
- Visit LYSPER.comDecember 28, 2014Service was excellent, food (as always) delicious! It's so nice to have a great place in the neighborhood to stop in and have dinner that never disappoints! Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comMay 22, 2014The food and service and portobello is always exceptional. The wait staff is always professional and willing to go an extra step. We dine here often and will continue to come back Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comDecember 9, 2014The bread and roasted garlic to start, perfect. Bottle of wine, Frontera Cabernet, delicious "can,t believe we finished the whole bottle. 2fer, chicken franchise. Prepared flavorful. Crochet exce... Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneSeptember 21, 2019Our server Vivi was polite and very informative. The manager Carlos spent several minute talking to us to tell us about all the new changes. We are so excited to come back and see the new menu it...
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 2, 2018Our experience was excellent. The wait staff was courteous, quick to respond, and on top of everything. Our waiter specifically was very responsive to a birthday dessert request for my wife.
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 9, 2019Great meal, The chicken Alfredo was rich and creamy, came out nice and hot. Our server was very attentive refilling our water and drinks. Love the 2 for 1 value!
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 29, 2016My experience at portobello cafe tonight was great. The food is consistently delicious and the service from my waitress, Kim, was excellent. She was very knowledgable and attentive.
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 26, 2018The food was absolutely wonderful. Our waiter was fantastic- very polite and friendly. The fries were a little salty (but Daddy likes). 10/10 would come back!
- LysperApp For iPhoneSeptember 30, 2018Service was excellent & she was very polite. Also service was quick which we liked. We didn't feel rushed to leave and they made sure we were doing great and checked up on us.
- Visit LYSPER.comNovember 11, 2014Excellent food and service at Portobello cafe. This was our first time here. Melissa our server was knowledgeable with the menu and she made us want to come back again real soon. Cheers! Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comFebruary 4, 2015We had Frank as our waiter. He was very cordial and attentive. We had a special martini which was very tasty and a delicious sangria. We will come back again. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 8, 2018Our experience was perfect. The food never disappoints and the service is always so pleasant and enjoyable. Kids meals are very large portions. Highly recommend.
- Visit LYSPER.comNovember 23, 2014Portobella cafe is so warm and cozy! The staff is very friendly, our waiter was so nice and checked to make sure the eggrolls did not have any meat in them. He kept our drinks full and always che... Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneOctober 28, 2016This is our first visit but certainly not our last. Our server was attentive helpful and very pleasant The specials were delicious. We are leaving here very satisfied.
- LysperApp For iPhoneApril 12, 2018Everything was great. Both entrees were quite delicious and you can't beat the two for one special. Our waiter Joey provided excellent service. We will be back again.
- Visit LYSPER.comMay 8, 2014The food is wonderful. The service is excellent. Your never left waiting for your server to accommodate you . The 2 for 1 meals are of exceptional value. The owner is always there to over see h... Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 11, 2016Such an amazing dining experience. Alyssa was an extremely fantastic waitress. She was friendly and attentive. The food was delicious. Will most certainly be returning.
- LysperApp For iPhoneMay 17, 2017Our server Frank was fantastic. Food excellent. Everything was just so good. Can't say enough how great the service and food was. Will definitely come back.
- LysperApp For iPhoneMarch 25, 2019Food was delicious We were a little disappointed that we arrived at 6 pm and were unable to order off the happy hour menu. Waitress was attentive. We will definitely return, but will make sure to...
- Visit LYSPER.comDecember 3, 2014Love the food and our waitress Laura r. Was great and they have the best sangria around I tell everyone I know to go and eat there love portobello Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comJune 10, 2014The service was great. Very timely and courteous. The food was amazing and the entree size was extremely generous. The value is amazing and I will definitely be back. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 18, 2019Upon entering the restaurant, we were greeted with friendly people. We were seated and immediately greeted by our waiter. His name is David. He was quite pleasant and professional. He took our or...
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 25, 2018The food was delicious. Our waiter Joey was prompt, professional and courteous. His pleasant sense of humor made our dining experience a positive one. He missed his calling to be a double for a y...
- LysperApp For iPhoneDecember 2, 2018Amazing!I love coming here with my boyfriend and friends. Fast service and amazing servers. Food is good portions and delicious. I always leave stuffed !
- Visit LYSPER.comNovember 14, 2014The food and service was great as usual! Our waitress Alyssa was extremely attentative, and eager to provide us with the best dining experience. The manager visited our table numerous times to en... Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 28, 2018As always, a wonderful night out here! The food, service & ambiance is sways top notch! The GM, Jen is always great, that now my son calls her "aunt Jen"
- Visit LYSPER.comApril 22, 2014We have been customers of Portobello cafe for many years and frequent your establishment practically as often as we go out, The food is always great and the service is excellent. The wait staff ... Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comDecember 31, 2014Portobello is always packed...perfect place for 2 for 1, but only if u have 6 or.less! Bring cash...but portions are worth it! Theyve been skimping on the salad & charge u for a refill...not happ... Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneOctober 16, 2016Excellent!! Loved The waitress was right on the spot and helped with whatever we needed. This was exceptional especially because we had twin children with us!!
- LysperApp For iPhoneOctober 30, 2016We love dining at Portobello Cafe! The food is absolutely delicious. The servers are always friendly and accommodating. The sangria is to die for!
14 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 11:00 AM tomorrow (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri
- 11:00 AM–Midnight
- Sat
- Noon–Midnight
- Sun
- 2:00 PM–10:00 PM
(718) 356-2233
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Portobello Cafe
Appears on 6 lists
Created by Kaitlyn Elizabeth
2 itemsCreated by Frances Amato
41 items • 1 followerTop eating spots in Staten Island, NY
Created by Erin Driscoll
7 items • 11 followers