Important Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.Portobello Cafe
Italian Restaurant and Bar$$$$
Eltingville, Staten Island
"This was our first time at Portobello Cafe."(3 Tips)"We had chicken Francese and the house pasta and both were delicious!"(3 Tips)"Chicken parm was delicious as always, my favorite!!"(9 Tips)"prix fix family style menu"(3 Tips)
1,311 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- great value
- chicken parmigiana
- good for dates
- comfortable
- prix fixe menu
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- LysperApp For iPhoneFebruary 15, 2020Great service very attentive & professional. Will def be back love the food. Excellent ! All a favorite place for date night
- LysperApp For iPhoneMarch 16, 2019Great as always! Food was delicious and service was excellent! The Martinis are always great also. We are very happy coming here!
- Visit LYSPER.comMay 29, 2014The food was delicious & the service was delightful! The entire staff was helpful & wonderfully friendly & nice. We enjoyed the whole experience =) Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comApril 29, 2014The food was excellent and the service was great. You can not go wrong with any of the mains. It is less expensive than eating at home. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 6, 2017This was our first visit and we will DEFINITELY be back again. The food was very good but our waiter, Joey, feels like part of the family.
- LysperApp For iPhoneApril 6, 2018Our experience today was great! Alyssa was super friendly, very professional and overall a great waitress. She looks like my cousin Gina (but is a lot nicer !)
- LysperApp For iPhoneJune 13, 2019Excellent! Jimmy our waiter was patient, helpful, and sooo nice! Food was delicious!Everyone at Portobello are welcoming and friendly!
- Visit LYSPER.comMarch 5, 2015Carol was an excellent waitress! She was very attentive & personable. Based on Carol's service along with the excellent food, we will most definitely be returning! Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comNovember 30, 2014Our waiter Ivan was so attentive and personable! We had such a good experience with the food drinks and service! Will definitely come back ! Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneSeptember 7, 2018Absolutely fantastic! Food was delicious... service was knowledgeable, kind and attentive! Will definitely be returning and recommend.
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 23, 2018Alyssa was a pleasure. She was respectful, courteous and attentive and created a great atmosphere for a weekday date night for me and my wife.
- LysperApp For iPhoneNovember 12, 2017Waitress was very helpful and answered all our questions!!! Food and service was excellent and really enjoyed the specials that we ordered !
- LysperApp For iPhoneMay 20, 2017Excellent food with even better service! We've been coming here for years! One of our favorite restaurants!
- Visit LYSPER.comNovember 7, 2014Excellent service. Excellent food. I would recommend this to all my friends. Especially the price fixe menu. Well worth the money. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneMarch 19, 2019We had a wonderful dinner. CJ our waiter was the best. Nice. Fun and had no problem taking our table photos. Thank you. We'll be back.
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 29, 2017Food and service were excellent. We enjoyed every part of the meal. Thank you for a very enjoyable dining experience.
- LysperApp For iPhoneFebruary 14, 2019This was our second time eating here. We enjoy it very much. Everyone is so nice and our server today was great.
- LysperApp For iPhoneMarch 15, 2018Good. Great service. Calamari had too much batter. Chicken rollatine was good but didn't like fried carrots in top. Give a full glass of wine which is nice since some places are skimpy.
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 31, 2018Food was delicious, service was prompt. I continue to come here because it is reliable for great food, my favorite Italian restaurant.
- LysperApp For iPhoneFebruary 27, 2019Everything was EXCELLENT - the service and the food! The only thing I would alter is the seating arrangement - it's a bit cramped.
- Visit LYSPER.comApril 29, 2014We enjoy so much coming to potrtabellas.food is fantastic. Service the same. Have recommended to many of my friends who feel the same. Thank you. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneApril 27, 2019Service and food was excellent. Never disappointed anytime we come to the restaurant. Staff are professional. Laura is top notch.
- Visit LYSPER.comDecember 6, 2014Everything was amazing about the experience. The waiter was very personable and was very helpful with anything that we needed during dinner. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneSeptember 25, 2019The service was impeccable. Waiters were extremely attentive and friendly. The food was delicious and the portions were above expectations.
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 16, 2018I have been here several times and the service is always excellant! And the staff always friendly! Definitely coming home.
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 29, 2018Portobello is one of my favorite restaurants on the island. Food is excellent, service is even better. Bravo!!!
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 1, 2017Excellent service!!! A great bargain for such great food! Laura was an excellent server, always attentive!! Dessert was fantastic!!!
- LysperApp For iPhoneOctober 31, 2019The service was great! Our food came out at a reasonable time and our waitress was great! The food was excellent!
- LysperApp For iPhoneMarch 11, 2018Alyssa was amazing- just a ray of sunshine. Constant smiles, super friendly and a great person.
- Visit LYSPER.comMay 31, 2014Wonderful place to eat. Never a bad meal. Food is fantastic, service was great will definitely be going back again and again. Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comApril 30, 2015Waitress was very nice and helpful. She went above and beyond to accommodate us with lean plates and fresh coffee. Food excellent. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneJanuary 26, 2018We had a great experience tonight and the food was delicious. Our waiter, Mauricio was very accommodating and so polite.
- LysperApp For iPhoneOctober 23, 2018Excellent! Our waitress made great suggestions and was quick & friendly with the dinner services. Food was great & everything tasted fresh!
- LysperApp For iPhoneMarch 21, 2019There was no need to enhance our experience today Our waitor Paolo was courteous, prompt and professional and the food was just as expected.... Delicious!!!!
- Visit LYSPER.comDecember 30, 2014The waitress was amazing. The service was great and the food was amazing. Only complaint about the food is that is was too Great!!! Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comMay 4, 2014Server was frank and he was very attentive. The food was delicious and portions were huge, we were extremely satisfied. Would recommend and come back again. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneOctober 2, 2018Excellent like always. The clams with linguine were delicious with ample clams. The chicken Alfredo was also good.
- LysperApp For iPhoneMarch 6, 2019Wonderful! Food was delicious as always. The Keto menu is a great addition :) waitress was friendly and attentive
- Visit LYSPER.comDecember 16, 2014Absolutely WONDERFUL SERVICE! Very impressed with the staff and the food was AMAZING! We will definitely be coming back ?????? Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 14, 2018Everything was very good. Service, food and atmospher was all excellent. Looking forward to returning.
- Visit LYSPER.comMay 18, 2014We've been coming here for 15 years & have never been disappointed. The food & service is always great. Always a great variety of food. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneMay 17, 2019Wonderful experience as usual..... Our server, Laura, was especially helpful, friendly and knowledgeable. Will definitely return!
- Visit LYSPER.comFebruary 11, 2015Delicious meal, great service, cozy and fun atmosphere! Definitely recommend esp for the 2 for 1 during the week. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 3, 2018Everything was great! I've been coming here for a long time and never a bad expirence, best chicken parm!
- Visit LYSPER.comNovember 9, 2014Jimmy our waiter was superlative in every aspect of his service. There are two issues that should be addressed. First too much garlic on the spinach and more importantly Italians enjoy olive oil ... Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneDecember 27, 2018Excellent service. Food was delicious and came out hot and fast. Will be back again for the 2 for 1!
- Visit LYSPER.comApril 9, 2015Excellant service. Loved our dinner, Cooked as we requested. The prix fix dinner was really a great deal. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneOctober 31, 2018As always a very enjoyable mean. Tasty food, healthy portions and wonderful service.Couldn't ask for a thing more.
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 17, 2019The food is superb never an off day. The staff go above and beyond to make your dining experience perfect.
- Visit LYSPER.comDecember 24, 2014We enjoyed the atmosphere and the delicious foods! Our waitress Nicole was fabulous, she was very attentive and welcoming!!! Read more
14 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 10:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri
- 11:00 AM–Midnight
- Sat
- Noon–Midnight
- Sun
- 2:00 PM–10:00 PM
(718) 356-2233
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.1
"I thought the service was great and the food was amazing ! Can't wait to return with friends !"
Visit LYSPER.com
- 8.1
"The hamburger wrap is a must!!! Yummy"
Rita Galante - 8.9
"The dinner was excellent and Stacy was an excellent server. This was our first time here and I would definitely come back again."
Places people like to go after Portobello Cafe
Appears on 6 lists
Top eating spots in Staten Island, NY
Created by Erin Driscoll
7 items • 11 followers
Created by Sean Fisher
27 items • 3 followersCreated by Kaitlyn Elizabeth
2 items