Portobello Cafe
Italian Restaurant and Bar$$$$
Eltingville, Staten Island
"Our waitress Alyssa"(3 Tips)"This was our first time at Portobello Cafe."(2 Tips)"We had chicken Francese and the house pasta and both were delicious!"(3 Tips)"Chicken parm was delicious as always, my favorite!!"(9 Tips)
1,311 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- chicken parmigiana
- great value
- waitress alyssa
- good for dates
- comfortable
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 17, 2019The food is superb never an off day. The staff go above and beyond to make your dining experience perfect.
- LysperApp For iPhoneNovember 6, 2018Excellant! Our waiter was great. Food was out of this world. The music need a little upgrade but all was fabulous
- LysperApp For iPhoneSeptember 26, 2019This was our first time here and we are extremely impressed. Definitely will be back. Nick was serving us and he is fantastic.
- LysperApp For iPhoneOctober 26, 2019David was great and enjoyed my birthday dinner. All recommendation were great as well as service
Aeolian-Skinner Princess PastoreJanuary 20, 2017The atmosphere. Also request that your pasta be in a round dish unless you like eating pasta out of a cereal bowl.- Visit LYSPER.comApril 30, 2015The meal and the atmosphere was fantastic. The service was excellent I would recommend this place to everyone Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comMarch 7, 2015Our waitress Michelle had a wonderful bed side manner extremely friendly. We did not have to wait too long for the food, which has excellent quality. Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comJanuary 24, 2015Food was delicious service excellent highly recommend this place. Owners son was a nice touch adorable polite little guy. Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comDecember 24, 2014We enjoyed the atmosphere and the delicious foods! Our waitress Nicole was fabulous, she was very attentive and welcoming!!! Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneOctober 15, 2018As usual excellent food, wonderful service, and comfortable atmosphere. Returning customers and will continue to be!
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 27, 2018The service was excellent. We had chicken Francese and the house pasta and both were delicious!
- LysperApp For iPhoneNovember 22, 2018Excellent service and delicious food at a great price. Love the salad and roasted garlic. Da best chicken parm.
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 15, 2018We had a nice time! Our waiter was very attentive and nice! We love portobello aNd will come back often!
- LysperApp For iPhoneApril 6, 2018Wonderful! Michelle was attentive. She made the night out with my husband and I very relaxing and enjoyable.
- Visit LYSPER.comApril 13, 2014The food and service at Portobello Cafe is top notch. We frequent this restaurant quite often and are satisfied every single time. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneMarch 10, 2019Our waitress was a delight! The food was delicious. This was our first time here and we hope to be back soon.
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 5, 2018Salmon and stuffed mushrooms were phenomenal. Carlos was very attentive and did a wonderful job. Calamari was a bit chewy
- LysperApp For iPhoneMarch 23, 2019Absolutely wonderful....our server Jimmy was terrific...food was delicious....couldn't ask for a better dining experience!
- LysperApp For iPhoneDecember 4, 2018Food was really good. Only problem was we brought a coupon for a free appetizer which we could not use but on previous visits we were able to use it.
- Visit LYSPER.comJanuary 29, 2015Food was outstandingly delicious! service was great and the atmosphere was terrific! we will be back soon! Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneMarch 8, 2019I have been coming to this establishment for over 20 years and have always had a great meal and service !!!Thsank you!!
- LysperApp For iPhoneSeptember 9, 2017Melissa was a pleasure. I had a great time with good people. Memorable experience. I cant wait to come back.
- Visit LYSPER.comMay 21, 2014Food and service was excellent. The hostesses were pleasant at arrival and more than accommodating. Wonderful atmosphere all around. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneNovember 20, 2018Always a great time and great food! And Frank is an awesome server....takes care of all our needs! Love this place!
- LysperApp For iPhoneMay 2, 2017Service was excellent from the host to the manager. Kevinwas very friendly and helpful. The food was good, but not as excellent as it usually is.
- Visit LYSPER.comApril 23, 2014This evenings as a very pleasant experience. The staff was pleasant and inviting the service was great and the food delicious! Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneJanuary 15, 2019The service, quantity, quality and prices are great. Every time we're on SI we make our business to have dinner here.
- Visit LYSPER.comMay 1, 2015Fantastic service, food was delish, tortellini carbonara and sautéed chicken and artichoke pasta are top notch!! Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneNovember 23, 2016Wonderful. The food is always delicious, the service is always remarkable & the atmosphere is always pleasant.
- LysperApp For iPhoneDecember 27, 2017The food was amazing! Generous portions and excellent service. We will definitely return soon.
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 10, 2019Fantastic as always. Great food and service. Came here for my birthday and did not disappoint
- Visit LYSPER.comApril 14, 2014In the cognac shrimp and scallop special I would have liked a little more shrimp and scallops to make it a perfect dish Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 28, 2018Excellent. You put up with us. You charged my phone & answered all my questions.Love the Keto menu, please expand on it.
- LysperApp For iPhoneDecember 1, 2018Our experience was excellent. The food plentiful,and delicious. The waits staff friendly and helpful.
- LysperApp For iPhoneMarch 28, 2019We love coming back here! Our server was so friendly and attentive and our meals were superb!
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 20, 2018As usual everything is delicious. The service is always very good and the 2 for 1 can't be beat.
- Visit LYSPER.comApril 21, 2014We've visited several times with Dr. Correa from Reformed Church of Hugenot Park and the food and service is always excellent and the welcome is warm. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneJune 18, 2017It was great. Delicious. the waitress was very informative, funny and pleasant . Will definitely come again.
- Visit LYSPER.comApril 26, 2014Jimmy was a excellent server and very friendly . The food was delicious. They should have the two for one deal through out the whole week though! Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneDecember 2, 2018Simply fantastic. The food was delicious and our waiter Jimmy was polite and attentive. Portabello never disappoints!!
- LysperApp For iPhoneAugust 15, 2018Service and food was very good. Laura is very nice and personable and took good care of us. Thank you!
- LysperApp For iPhoneMarch 25, 2019Our experience was excellent. The service was great, food was great and we will definitely be back again.
- Visit LYSPER.comMay 7, 2014Food was delicious and the ambience was super relaxing. Our waitress was attentive and courteous. Would definitely come back again. Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 30, 2019Everything was excellent. The food , wine ,service and the waiter were a tribute to this resturant.
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 28, 2016My experience today was excellent! Loved the service, everyone was very attentive and the food was delicious.
- LysperApp For iPhoneApril 9, 2019The food was great and the service even better. I would definitely recommend this place to everyone.
- LysperApp For iPhoneJuly 19, 2018Everything was great. Here on a two for one and had more food than we could finish. Excellent value.
- Visit LYSPER.comApril 13, 2014Awesome restaurant; food, staff and overall appeal is remarkable. I truly enjoy every aspect of my dinner here. Read more
- Visit LYSPER.comMarch 19, 2015Very good Italian food, sauce was perfect for my veal parmiagana. Servive was excellent and very friendly Read more
- LysperApp For iPhoneOctober 26, 2018One of our favorite restaurants. The food is always delicious. The service is excellent.
14 Photos
Foursquare © 2025 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Closed until 11:00 AM tomorrow (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
- Fri
- 11:00 AM–Midnight
- Sat
- Noon–Midnight
- Sun
- 2:00 PM–10:00 PM
(718) 356-2233
Features
Reservations
Yes
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Portobello Cafe
Appears on 6 lists
Top eating spots in Staten Island, NY
Created by Erin Driscoll
7 items • 11 followersCreated by Kaitlyn Elizabeth
2 itemsCreated by Frances Amato
41 items • 1 follower