Important Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.Sea Fire Grill
Seafood Restaurant$$$$
Turtle Bay, New York
Has a stamp of approval from The Wall Street Journal and The Corcoran Group
"The Lobster Mac & Cheese here is excellent — piping hot and creamy"(4 Tips)
"Lobster salad is worth a try."(3 Tips)
"Great place to try fresh oysters and long drinks."(5 Tips)
"Spanish Octopus and a glass"(3 Tips)
50 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- shellfish
- desserts
- good for dates
- happy hour
- great value
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Andrew BelangerMay 5, 2017Great food, ambiance, and fun. Can't go wrong with any dish- NY strip was the best I've had. Shoutout to our waiter Jaime for making it a night to remember.
Cristina DimouDecember 30, 2013Lobster Mac &cheese my 10yr old loved it. Ny strip great steak. Not a kid restaurant so I called ahead of time for them 2 accommodate. I will have to come back soon.Great dining area roomy a must try
Very classy new seafood restaurant in midtown east with a handsome bar, an appealing happy hour 4-7 with half off on select drinks and oysters@$1.50 each. See Kate at the bar: she'll hook you up.
Jassim alhajriOctober 31, 2014You will have to try their tuna tartar which is amazing. Loved their new York strip and rib eye. The Apple pie is superb
Greg Wong 🎯March 27, 2013snag fresh east and west coast oysters for $1.50 each (not bad for midtown) and wash them down with half priced glasses of wine, draft beer and well drinks
Lalaina RamanantsoaDecember 26, 2014The crew is so friendly and we were kind of very vip... the food is fresh and amazing!!!!! Excellent place to eat fish and seafruit
Jing NMay 9, 2013Delish starter: Lobster salad. For fish, the Halibut and Red snapper were very good. End with the chocolate molten cake.
Betsy CFebruary 3, 2013one of my favorite restaurants in the city. get the lobster mac and cheese and the seared tuna and thank me in the morning.
Sonya NilsenSeptember 11, 2013Very good. I got the swordfish blt and it was amazing. Recommend the cheese platter for desert as well.- Andrew KMay 29, 2015Great place to try fresh oysters and long drinks. Tasty food, customer oriented staff and sophisticated people around.
Lindsey HoganMay 1, 2015Scallop special was delicious but not very generous in portion size - 3 scallops only. The gnocchi side was fabulous.- Sara PinedaFebruary 21, 2018Good service and delicious food, I tried Spanish Octopus and a glass of italian white wine
- Lindsey HoganJanuary 17, 2015Amazing fresh seafood. Loved the seafood tower-hard to go wrong with jumbo lump grab.
Nicolette RomeroSeptember 27, 2014Great spot to sit at the bar and grab drinks. Love the lobster bisque and crab cakes!
Tamara DMay 25, 2016Great fish special, macarons, crab cakes and coffee. Service was very good as well.
Alejandra VargasMay 21, 2015Cocktails at the bar are really good! Three different spaces. Very nice place!
Yvonne W.June 8, 2013Incredible whitefish spread for your warm, toasty bread and crackers that is complimentary - SO good!!
Patrick CasteloMarch 14, 2015The Food & Service is off the chain. Request Alban as a server he will take good care of you.
ReemMay 31, 2015Average comparing to burger and lobster in London ! lobster roll was good and the atmosphere is great ..
- Aolani SmytheDecember 23, 2012A plus restaurant! Good food Good service! Thumbs up! Definitely recommend!
April Kate 🍴November 2, 2014Service is the undeniably great here but that's pretty much all it's worth. Food is okay. Crab cakes are a safe bet.
- Davy ZoneraichDecember 8, 2019Very, very underwhelming mediocre for a high priced meal. The lobster macaroni was a rendition of cheese wiz and noodles with microsized pieces of lobster. The tuna entree lacked any flavoring.
KathJuly 3, 2013Never imagined that I would have such a good piece of ny strip here!!! But IT WAS AMAZING!!!
Maria RosatiMay 17, 2013Kind of cheesy atmosphere.. Felt like I was in a hotel restaurant in Vegas. Food okay. Fellow diners commented that the fish had no taste. Stick with the scallops.
Meg FarmerFebruary 24, 2015Nothing special. Friendly staff, typical midtown joint. An okay option for after work drinks.
167 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Seasonally sourced contemporary American seafood with an elegant yet classic experience where consistency is key and service is impeccable.
Closed until 4:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 4:00 PM–10:00 PM
(212) 935-3785
Features
Credit Cards
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 8.2
"Front table great for people watching. Crabmeat starter absolutely delicious. Swordfish tuna griddle rice and broccoli rabe w feta all fabulous. Topped off w shared flour less chocolate cake:)"
Mary - 8.0
"Amazing. The the whole black sea bass is absolutely the standout. Besides that the soft shell crab appetizer, the salmon, and the fish and chips. For dessert the strawberry sundae and chocolate mousse"
Corbin Blankenstein - 8.3
"Extraordinary seafood in meat packing district. Must try the hamachi appetizer... it's to die for."
Angela
Places people like to go after Sea Fire Grill
Appears on 131 lists
Created by Kino
256 items • 37 followers
Created by Andrea Brown
66 items • 16 followersZagat Top 100 Restaurants New York City 2015
Created by Allan Beaufour
100 items • 5 followers
