See all
91 photos

Alidoro

Sandwich Spot$$$$

Garment District, New York

Save

Alidoro

8.8^/10

352

ratings

Ranked #3 for sandwiches in the Garment District
"The Pinocchio sandwich is amazing."(7 Tips)
"Pinocchio on Semolina will change your life"(3 Tips)
"Beautiful and delicious Italian sandwiches."(5 Tips)
"... -- for example, the sfilatino bread will be ~18 inches. Easy to share one of..."(2 Tips)

65 Tips and reviews

Filter:

sandwiches
pinocchio
authentic
casual
Italian food
trendy
good for a quick meal
semolina
big portions
paninis
cute
TVs
spacious
pastries
arugula
pork
peppers
prosciutto
lunch
porchetta
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

GothamistNovember 3, 2014
Alidoro's spectacular sandwiches arrive in midtown. Get the Marina, stuffed with smoked chicken breast, fresh mozzarella, sun dried tomatoes, & arugula. These sandwiches come pretty fully loaded. Read more
GothamistDecember 29, 2014
Picking one of the classics at this SoHo sandwich shop is not easy. We're here to help, try the Pinocchio, comprised of prosciutto, sopressata, fresh mozzarella, sweet roasted peppers and olive paste. Read more
GothamistNovember 21, 2014
Alidoro's newest pastry the Donnoli (connoli+donut) is available for $4 at the midtown location. The donut portion is dusted with powdered sugar, and the filling is ricotta cheese and cream. Read more
Andrew FurmanMay 19, 2016
The Pinocchio sandwich is amazing. Sandwiches are a little expensive at $13, but they're really good gourmet sandwiches
Anthony SpicciatiNovember 14, 2014
Pinocchio on sfilatino. NEED the sfilatino! So far, sandwiches are just as amazing as their soho locale.I do miss the b&w tv playing old movies... I'm sure the owner / sandwich making god does too!
CassidyDecember 5, 2014
worth the wait and then some. don't mess with anything but the sfilatino bread and add some mushroom paste. get the namesake or the frugoletto
Daniel McDonoughAugust 25, 2016
The Il Soprano was really good. Everything was very fresh. Prices are steep but the sandwich is huge. Can get two meals out of it.
Anuj MathurFebruary 4, 2015
The sandwiches are massive -- for example, the sfilatino bread will be ~18 inches. Easy to share one of these. A good place to start is the namesake Alidoro.
Cole KennedyOctober 1, 2019
Probably the only truly great place to get lunch within, what, 10 blocks? Alidoro can’t be beat. The Il Sole hot sandwich is delish.
Cooper SmithNovember 9, 2014
If the Maserati made its way up from the SoHo location, don't even bother looking at the menu. Prosciutto cotto, hot peppers, arugula - its the perfect sandwich
Moises EskinaziFebruary 14, 2015
Best sandwiches! Avoid the long line by going before 12pm or after 2pm. You can also place your order on their website, and skip half the line
Tash ConcepcionNovember 11, 2014
Ok so now I know what the fuss is about. Tried the Alyssa on focaccia and it was really good. Lines are very long though. Go early or call in your order.
JessOctober 19, 2023
Pricy but delicious sandwich. Order ahead during peak times otherwise you will spend a ridiculous amount of time waiting.
J LMarch 25, 2016
The Porchetta with the tender pork, roasted red peppers, arugula, and sweet peppers is delicious.
Carmen NDecember 7, 2014
Been here 5+ times
The sandwiches are only subtly different from each other, but oh so tasty. Huge, split with a friend.
Kristina RudicMay 10, 2016
The sandwiches are true standouts but also ginormous! Split one with someone!
Barry HottApril 11, 2016
Been here 10+ times
Perfectly executed authentic Italian panini's. All prosciutto everything.
nathan archambaultMarch 15, 2015
Best authentic italian sandwiches you can get outside of Italy or Eataly.
Regina ChanMarch 28, 2015
Excellent cuts. I like upgrading my bread. It's delicious.
Travis BloomJuly 11, 2016
The sandwich options can be overwhelming. First timers should try the Pinocchio
PierreJune 19, 2015
Love the sandwiches here but after they lost mine twice, and kept me waiting for 20minutes each time, I decided it's not worth it.
Abner AcevesMarch 31, 2015
Been here 5+ times
Really huge and delicious sandwiches. Try the Nutella cappuccino!
Martin MaguireSeptember 27, 2016
Great spot to get a fresh sandwich. It's long worth the wait.
Alex RobertsonJuly 19, 2019
was shocked to see the breakfast sandwiches prices at $4.50 but they’re tiny. porchetta joint was good
Alex RavenelJune 21, 2017
Spectacular, massive sandwiches. The Pinocchio is excellent.
Tim RossiApril 29, 2016
Great sanwhiches but i prefer a slightly better option in fidi called Pisillo
Cristian VFebruary 18, 2016
Italian sandwiches are unlike any I've ever had. The spreads make a huge difference.
Drew MinnearNovember 2, 2015
Great sandwiches! Large portions at a good price!
brendan colganDecember 8, 2016
Been here 10+ times
Great and large sandwiches. Usually enough for 2.
Gianna NebbiaAugust 1, 2019
Really good sandwiches on the menu. Doesn’t make sense to build your own- way too expensive
MischaMarch 28, 2015
Been here 10+ times
Breakfast sandwiches and pastries are the bomb to make your day
Jason BrewSeptember 5, 2015
It's very expensive for a sandwich shop, but I did feel I got a great sandwich. The Fiorello was quite good
David BrahlerMay 20, 2015
Been here 5+ times
The best sandwich shop in Midtown. Try the Pinocchio
Cathy CervenkaMay 9, 2017
They now let you customize your sandwich!
Luiza NunesOctober 10, 2018
The worst capuccino ever. The milk was almost boiling, combined to that terrible lid that you have to tear a hole made it impossible to drink on my way to work. Walk few blocks and go to Blue Bottle.
P. D.November 14, 2022
This was my first time post chainification. Not nearly as good as the Soho original. Too bad.
Janice KarbachinskiyJune 3, 2016
This sandwich is what dreams are made of
Mike ShermanJanuary 23, 2017
Among the best lunch options in midtown
Ryan GallagherJuly 23, 2018
Good sandwiches. They keep the line moving during the buy times.
Virgínia RodriguesJune 30, 2016
I recommend the Alyssa on a white bread.
Ryan AmbsJanuary 19, 2016
Lacks the bristly New York charm of the downtown location but retains the quality sandwiches.
Lou CarulliAugust 26, 2015
Everything
bretMarch 20, 2015
Pinocchio on Semolina will change your life
Leigh FerreiraFebruary 10, 2015
Gabriella on Semolina FTW!
JessicaDecember 14, 2016
Excellent hot sandwiches
JPApril 16, 2017
Been here 5+ times
Quality Italian sandwiches like the original, without the nasty attitude
Doug WamplerJuly 17, 2018
Known for the excruciatingly long wait times
John McDermottJuly 25, 2016
Marcello was great.
Ben CombesNovember 5, 2014
Best sandwiches in Manhattan!
Drew NicholsNovember 3, 2014
Been here 10+ times
Not quite as orderly as the soho location but just as tasty

1 2

91 Photos

Alidoro

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Alidoro

Appears on 398 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.