See all
157 photos

Grimaldi's Coal Brick-Oven Pizza

(Now Closed)

Pizzeria$$$$

Coney Island, Brooklyn

Save

"Excellent pizza."(2 Tips)
"white pizza the best & the brooklyn bottled root beer."(2 Tips)
"You can only order a pie, no sliced and cash only."(5 Tips)
"Great place after a Coney Island day"(2 Tips)

32 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
great value
root beer
good for groups
good for working
casual
salads
island
cash only
dinner
clean
sodas
lunch
alcohol
(9 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Luna Park Coney IslandJuly 8, 2012
Perfection in a slice. Grimaldi's has some of the best pizza in the 5 boroughs. Can't order by the slice, but it's worth it to buy the pie anyway - you'll wish there was more when you're done!
Noel SelegziJuly 28, 2012
Almost impossible to get someone to take your order. The DUMBO original was the best, but this isn't bad. Coney needs more restaurants. This place ought to carry Coney Island Brewery here.
Bryant BalatbatApril 24, 2017
Similar to other Grimaldi's. We did have to wait just an hour before the beginning of dinner while they cleaned the oven. So try to not to go at an off hour.
David LópezJune 19, 2015
Best pizza in N.Y.. If you are in the city, you must go.
Ritchie MolessoOctober 25, 2012
Good tasting pizza love the white pizza the best & the brooklyn bottled root beer.
DoloresJune 8, 2013
Place is new. the atmosphere is nice. Cash only! Salads are a must try!
Dan SohaydaSeptember 23, 2016
Servers looked like they were being held against their will. They looked miserable. Outstanding pizza close to the boardwalk though.
Silene LimAugust 1, 2018
Decent American sized pizzas. We had the small and we were stuffed. Haven’t tried other pizzas in the area but decent.
ellen resnickFebruary 17, 2015
Its a grear place, authentic Brooklyn pizza
AnneAugust 31, 2013
Pizza should taste great without topping. Last nights plain pie was just ok. Pizza was just warm when we got it, got cold and dry fast. Not as good as Juliana's Pizza.
Leandro BariniMarch 14, 2017
Great pizza!
Samar TariqJune 1, 2013
The chocolate truffle is beyond amazing
Greg McMullenMay 5, 2013
The best coal oven pizza and root beer
Rooster BirdAugust 26, 2016
Great place after a Coney Island day
Christine GeigerMay 26, 2013
Cash only. Which they do not tell you when you order. atm is out of order. Also no beer which kind of stinks. Make sure you bring cash. And go to the freak bar across the street for an apres cocktail.
GloriaAugust 28, 2013
Can not go there by yourself. You can only order a pie, no sliced and cash only.
Carl Pinal Jr.August 7, 2014
Pizza is f@$!#/g great!
Eduardo DeleonAugust 20, 2017
Cash only. They don't accept credit cards.
DianaSeptember 1, 2012
Must try the olde brooklyn sodas!!
Bogdan PopaAugust 20, 2015
Excellent pizza
Carolina BorbergNovember 29, 2014
Bring cash!
Joseph AkbrudMay 4, 2013
Been here 10+ times
FYI: It's cash only.
Mooney MjAugust 7, 2014
Excellent pizza.
Joseph NielsenJuly 4, 2013
About 25 carbs per large slice.
Сергей ЗиминJune 28, 2015
I'll try it:-)
Max KhaskinMarch 30, 2014
Caprese leaves much to be desired.
M GAugust 16, 2013
Good pizza
Sherri FeldmanAugust 17, 2012
They still need their liquor license.
Noel SelegziJuly 28, 2012
Anchovies are too salty.
Yura LeeOctober 6, 2014
Chicago pizza is better..
Victor MartinMarch 14, 2017
Ótima opção para comer pizza em Coney Island
Mahir KarimJune 1, 2013
Chocolate soufflé. You won't regret it!

157 Photos

Grimaldi's Coal Brick-Oven Pizza

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Grimaldi's Coal Brick-Oven Pizza

Appears on 45 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.