Important Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
32 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Serious EatsMay 2, 2013This great little cheese shop always has a grilled cheese sandwich on the menu, with ingredients changing with the seasons.
Gilt CityJune 1, 2011Everything at Lucy’s Whey is American-made and procured from local farms and small-scale, artisanal cheese-makers. And don't forget about fromage-friendly items like chutney, honey and pickles.
Michael Fox-RabinovitzSeptember 27, 2015Fantastic place for artisanal cheeses and tasty compliments around them. Try the panini here with fig and cheddar- best place for cheese in manhattan, plus there toasted cheese sandwiches are amazing. try the garlic pickle version, available but off the menu
Adrienne SMarch 28, 2012Great selection of domestic cheeses plus yummy grilled cheese sandwiches like cheddar and dill pickle or fig to take away. (4 of 4 petals via Fondu) Read more
Old AmsterdamDecember 20, 2012Try Old Amsterdam Cheese next time you stop at Murray's Cheese Shop-- we produce delicious aged Gouda, Find out more here
Layla Khoury-HanoldOctober 20, 2012Great selection of American cheeses & super friendly and knowledgeable staff.
There's always abut of a wait...but I can promise you it's well worth it. Fig & Cheddar is their staple.
Ask lots of questions and follow their recommendations - amazing American artisanal cheeses and tasty local snacks. Try one their grilled sandwiches for lunch. Read more- Simran JaisingJanuary 28, 2013fig spread and gruyere (or some cheddar) on ciabatta. her grilled cheese press transforms the sandwich.
NearSay NYCJuly 25, 2011The Prarie Breeze and Fig Panini is too good to put into words. It is everything you could possibly dream of when it comes to scrumptious sandwiches!
Hot Bread KitchenJanuary 17, 2012Try one of the many delicious American made artisan cheeses sold here with some Hot Break Kitchen Lavash!
Roman MarkhMarch 22, 2013Prairie Breeze cheddar, sea salt and olive oil with a touch of fig jam on Amy’s Bread
Cihan YılmazMarch 12, 2012Grilled cheese sandwiches are awesome. Must try their famous cheddar + fig panini !
- get the prairie breeze cheddar + fig spread sandwich to go & eat it up on the high line
Taylor RobertsMay 15, 2012Great service! Even if you know nothing about cheese they can help you figure out what you want.
- Annie WApril 17, 2011They are the select few places that actually carries my favorite cheese: Prairie Breeze Cheddar.
The grilled cheese sandwich is, unsurprisingly, excellent.
The Prairie Breeze cheddar and fig spread sandwich is you best friend.
35 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
This Lucy’s Whey outpost offers a curated selection of American artisanal cheeses, in the convenience of the bustling Chelsea Market.
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Sat
- 10:00 AM–8:00 PM
- Sun
- 10:00 AM–7:00 PM
(212) 463-9500
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. Discover & Visa)
See More
Other places inside Chelsea Market
You might also like
- 9.3
"This is my heaven. All of the cheese your heart could possibly desire. Super friendly and helpful staff! Take their suggestions because they know what they're doing!!"
Courtney Lewis - 6.1
"Mozzarella sticks are absolutely fantastic, get them. Stay away from chicken parm bites, charred bits of dough wrapped crap"
Michael Fox-Rabinovitz - 9.5
"They do a lot of fun events and classes upstairs. Really good selection and gourmet items downstairs!"
Paige C
Places people like to go after Lucy's Whey
Appears on 48 lists
Stevenson's Favorite NYC Speciality Groceries
Created by Robert Stevenson
118 items • 3 followers
Created by Slow Food NYC
124 items • 150 followers