Important Reminder:The City Guide app will be sunsetting on December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Please visit our FAQ to learn more or to download our Swarm app.Olio e Piú
Italian Restaurant and Wine Bar$$$$
West Village, New York
"The Nutella desert along with the amazing pizza!"(58 Tips)
"Great gnocchi, great service, great outdoor atmosphere."(5 Tips)
"Pizza 4formaggi is great!"(2 Tips)
"Lobster risotto is delicious."(6 Tips)
139 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- good for groups
- outdoor seating
- casual
- trendy
- risotto
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Versha SharmaMay 4, 2013had birthday dinner here and loved it!! beautiful decor, great atmosphere and awesome service. handled a group of 17 on a Friday night, no problem. excellent food!!
Upvoted 2 weeks ago
Leslie TengMay 14, 2016Lobster risotto is delicious. The cacio e Pepe is like ravioli, but also delicious. Molten chocolate cake and tiramisu are fantastic ways to end the meal
Upvoted Sep 15
Eduardo VieroOctober 2, 2015First time in NY and I didn't regret: they make the best pizza in town, as authentic as the pizzas I ate in Italy. The weather was good and I stayed outside in the sidewalk. Perfect!Upvoted 1 week ago
Abir MahmoudSeptember 8, 2018Everything we’ve ordered was delicious.. pizza, pasta, risotto and the grilled chicken highly recommended
John AAugust 8, 2015Great outside cafe to enjoy a pizza, glass of wine, and salad or dessert. Recommend: Margherita pizza (tip.. Add artichokes) and the Caprese Salad.
Niti PaudyalDecember 19, 2017super cute dinner spot, the fumo di morra cocktail is strong and wonderful, and gnocchi alla carbonara is a great pesto pasta- Kr GOctober 8, 2017Nice hip cafe/restaurant with delicious salads. Great to sit out on a warm night.
Carmen MagarFebruary 21, 2016Wasn't super fond of the place, though the atmosphere is beautiful (many flowers). But last night I indulged in the Nutella pizza dessert, and - wow!
John ShrimpMarch 17, 2018Inspired by the simplicity of Neapolitan cuisine, Olio é Piu and Chef Dominick Pepe bring Italian tradition to the vibrant intersection where Sixth and Greenwich avenues meet Christopher Street.
Luca DLJanuary 15, 2012One of the top 5 best Italian pizza in town, if it's your first time here you should start with a Margherita Extra (with mozzarella di bufala) + Peroni or Moretti beer. Haters never had a real pizza.
Miguel LopezJuly 21, 2015Great seating, decent food at decent prices. But some of their dishes fk with the classics. Why put soggy chunks of zucchini in a linguine vongole?
Elizabeth BursteinAugust 28, 2019Loved the carbonara pasta. The cab + carrot ricotta app were ok. Mushroom risotto Brady had he didn’t love. Great ambiance but unfortunately went on a rainy day. Nice service!
Leah PetrMarch 20, 2018Come for the amazing ambiance and HH half price bottles of wine (including proseccco). Prepare to be unimpressed by the expensive pastas.
NoufJuly 16, 2022If i would recommend it would be for the fried calamari and the seafood pasta!😋other than that it’s too crowded and super noisy😅
Lauren SmithJuly 18, 2016Consistently good food🍴 usually have the seafood. Outdoor tables with pretty flowers in the summer🙏🏻
Jasmine MehrabiDecember 20, 2022Cozy indoors. Good pasta but not the best. Beef brisket fusilli was my fave- gnocchi, truffle, and crabmeat ravioli were also good.
Linda AppelqvistSeptember 30, 2013Awesome Italian restaurant. The panini with pesto, mozzarella and prosciutto was amazing!! And so was the pizza.
Chris VodolaDecember 29, 2016A chop shop that thrives on heavy foot traffic. Outside looks like the set of Sesame Street. Staff is more interested in turning tables than devoting attention to diners. Food's ok. You can do better.
CharlottesFebruary 10, 2016Nothing beats a table out on the pavement on a warm spring evening, drinking good wine with yummy pizza, watching the world go by.
The Corcoran GroupSeptember 17, 2010This is the place to go for a late night authentic roman pizza fix, open until 2am Thurs-Sun. Want pizza for brunch…they have that too!
Tianqi LiaoNovember 7, 2017Probably would have been a better experience if I came during the day since the west village setting is so beautiful.
Meg FarmerOctober 6, 2014When the weather is good, it's a great open air restaurant to visit. Pizzas are pretty decent, prices are very reasonable.
Christa HoeglerNovember 30, 2016Romantic atmosphere is better for couples than groups! The pasta was so fresh and sized moderately. The constant opening and shutting of the door made it uncomfortably cold in the winter though!
Charlotte GrysolleApril 17, 2016Love the cosy athmosphere and the pizzas are some of the best of NY, can really recommend it to everyone!!
CarolynJanuary 19, 2015Excellent neighborhood staple. Good food and friendly service. Try the pizza. Good for groups--they take reservations.
Jessica WickhamOctober 22, 2017Lovely place to sit outside and walk the world go by. Great light Italian themed cocktails too
Stephanie P.January 21, 2013My presto chicken with roasted potatos and arugala was delish! My friend's linguini w/ clams was tasty but really small portion. Save your money and don't get the pizza! Good cocktails - do them!
💎TJanuary 20, 2017The carbonara is actually really good! It's a bit heavy though, you'd really only need to order this and nothing else haha
- Maximum BurgerMay 21, 2017Great gnocchi, great service, great outdoor atmosphere. Bit spending though
Chelsea SoJuly 10, 2012Adorable restaurant, with great pizza. They open the doors when it's nice out - make sure you get a table outside or by the windows!
Gilt CityFebruary 1, 2011Olio Pizza e Piú has your requisite Margheritas and diavolos, but it’s also serving up unique pies like the Vesuvio: a slice stuffed with smoked mozzarella, pumpkin cream and imported speck.
Christina BarbosaApril 7, 2015Comfortable atmosphere but, the food was mediocre. The pollo al pesto is served with salty potato wedges mixed together.It ruined the flavor of the pesto and the grilled chicken left a charcoal taste.
Milena KyznetsovaJuly 27, 2017Excellent food!!! Great atmosphere ! Awesome Service! Will definitely back here!!! ❣️
Shenan ReedOctober 27, 2013Sit outside in the sun for fantastic people watching and beautiful flowers.
Julian WanAugust 15, 2014The food is great, the service is sometimes unfriendly, but the location, interior atmosphere, and location make this an impressive 24/7 restaurant.
Carolyn ZentgrafJuly 10, 2013Romantic patio, delightful service & delicious beet salad/bruschette! Fresh clams for the win.
Check out our flowers and beautiful ivy as you dine on the terrace
Theresa PowellJuly 28, 2013Great food!!! Try & sit outside and definitely ask for Abigail Brosh to be your server! She was AWSOME!!!
Everything on menu is delicious and the service is spectacular.
John PerezSeptember 6, 2015Although every dish was salty, it was good: 4Formaggi Pizza, Organic Chikn Breast, & Pasta.
712 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Traditional Italian Trattoria & Enoteca
Open until 11:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Sun
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
(212) 243-6546
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express & MasterCard)
Wi-Fi
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar
See More
You might also like
Places people like to go after Olio e Piú
- 9.5
"Beautiful, European style park. Occasional live music and outdoor chess makes it a hit."
Gajtana Simonovska - 9.3
"Earl grey in the waffle cone! Simple but creamy, smooth and amazingly delicious."
Candace Metzger - 8.5
"Scotch Eggs to die for! My favorite bar in NYC by a long way. Great atmosphere. Stunning cocktails. Decent prices. Come here. Now."
Jon Barber
Appears on 788 lists
Created by Lauren
211 items • 34 followers
Created by Kaitlyn Soares
187 items • 24 followers
Guide to New York's best spots
Created by Royale Party - Nyc
20 items • 20 followers
