Important Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.Rice to Riches
Dessert Shop$$$$
NoLita, New York
This dessert shop is famous for their rice pudding. It's one of the most popular in the city!
"French toast rice pudding, magarita rice pudding - all excellent."(148 Tips)
"French toast rice pudding with graham cracker crumble!!!! Amazing!!!"(13 Tips)
"Sex, Drugs and Rocky Road is one of the best to try."(8 Tips)
"rice pudding by the bowlful in flavors like “Fluent in French Toast"(6 Tips)
376 Tips and reviewsFilter:
- rice pudding
- desserts
- graham
- French toast
- cheesecake
- (15 more)
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
Alvin UrbanoAugust 29, 2012Get as many samples as you can... That way your not there all night...Other than that, it's a place worth mentioning, just in that high of a regard..
Jessie De La RosaFebruary 27, 2012Try the Coast to Coast Cheesecake. It's the best!! Then try the Marscarpone(has cherries already in it!) & the Mr & Mrs Graham!! Yummy
Jess BolseiAugust 16, 2013The "take me to tiramisu" rice pudding is phenomenal. First time eating rice pudding and I am NOT disappointed- Sex, Drugs and Rocky Road is one of the best to try. The store invites you to stay and laugh with the quotes and jokes around the place. That's a mandatory place to go.
Alex FishJune 15, 2015A staple in NYC, any flavor you choose will taste like its supposed to. The containers are also weirdly awesome
Efrain VasquezSeptember 1, 2014Love the rice pudding! Everything taste so good. I would recommended everything- My favorites are the Category 5 Caramel, Hazelnut Chocolate Bear Hug, and Coconut Coma. This place is carb-tastic.
Angel RafaelJune 17, 2011Very cool place to go if you want something sweet. It tends to be full still worth going. I loved the honey graham and the cheesecake.
JasonOctober 16, 2014Pumpkin rice pudding in the fall. The small is so big that you can only eat a quarter of it before it's too much.
Samantha ChengJuly 17, 2014Go with the butterscotch. Other flavours seem to be overwhelmingly sweet after a could spoonful.
Pei 👻 WenApril 29, 2016I've never seen these many flavors of rice pudding in a single shop, so wow! Fluent in French Toast was indeed greet. Slightly overpriced.
Ryszard SzopaApril 27, 2015Normally I'm not a fan of rice pudding... But this is different. It's delicious. You'll never look at rice pudding the same way.
Kristy LambAugust 5, 2012I didn't think I liked rice pudding, and now I crave it. Ask for a bag to take your empty container home - very handy!
SecondMarketNovember 3, 2011Get two different kinds of rice pudding and ask to combine them into one bowl - the pecan pie and tiramisu is amazing.
Go-to flavors: mascarpone and banana coconut. Every. Damn. Time.
Amy MaJune 3, 2013Make sure to sample your interests before buying as some of the rice pudding flavors may not quite taste as you'd expect!
R*March 17, 2011After the big success in the movie Hitch I tried this place and I simply loved it! Try the hazelnut chocolate rice, simply lovely!!!
Vincent SteursNovember 14, 2013Rice pudding goodness! Amazingly fun interior design, great experience!
Kelsey LeeJune 20, 2014The graham cracker topping will transform any flavor from good to great. Just do it.
Melanie Loff-BirdAugust 7, 2014Cinnamon or rocky road are my favorites (splurge and get a topping #worthit)
KevinJuly 18, 2010Haven't been so huge on rice pudding, but they have such a wide variety of flavors and toppings, you won't even know its rice pudding you're eating. Very very good.
Linda SongNovember 15, 2014Also, each purchase comes in a cute, lidded, reusable plastic bowl! Take it home!
Tom MaximAugust 13, 2014Yes- this is the spot where Eva Mendes eats rice pudding after Will Smith takes her to Ellis Island in "Hitch."
Pros: baskin Robbins of rice pudding. Fun atmosphere.... Cons: overpriced for the product & wasteful dishes (if you throw out vs take home & re use)- GRAE New YorkDecember 11, 2011Hazelnut Chocolate Bear Hug is the best. Make sure you add the Black Magic topping for more chocolate goodness.
Matt DePersisAugust 31, 2011You MUST try "Sex Drugs & Rocky Road." It's so incredibly indulgent. You wont be sorry. That is, unless you don't like chocolate, marshmallows and nuts.
Billy Kuan-yin ChenMay 19, 2014A large variety of unique flavored rice pudding. Yet a little bit expensive.- Samantha ChengNovember 16, 2011The rice pudding here is absolutely delicious! I love that they give out their rice puddings in a reusable container!
Simon CaoJuly 23, 2011Must visit this place! Awesome choice and variety of rice pudding flavors. Great store design too!.
- Billy Kuan-yin ChenMay 19, 2014A large variety of unique-flavored rice puddings. Yet a little bit expensive and limited seating space.
RoryAugust 29, 2013Really good. Really rich. Be prepared and wear your elastic waisted pants for afterwards!
Stephanee GermaineNovember 12, 2011Omg this is a must see. Amazing pudding, awesome spoons and whitty wall hangings! A must see!!
Try the "Category 5" Caramel - You must try the "Category 5" Caramel! It taste soooooooo good!
2,021 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Open until 11:00 PM (Show more)
- Mon–Thu, Sun
- 11:00 AM–11:00 PM
- Fri–Sat
- 11:00 AM–1:00 AM
(212) 274-0008
Features
Credit Cards
Yes (incl. American Express)
Wi-Fi
Yes
Outdoor Seating
No
Food & Drink
Menus
Dessert
See More
You might also like
Appears on 1,296 lists
Single-Item Restaurants in NYC
Created by Jorge Ortiz
33 items • 176 followers
Quirky NYC Places that Sell Only One Thing
Created by Foursquare City Guide
10 items • 145 followers
