Toby's Public House
(Now Closed)Pizzeria and Bar$$$$
Greenwood Heights, Brooklyn
The experts at The Corcoran Group and Gothamist recommend this place
101 Tips and reviews
Sort:
- Popular
- Recent
I don't think I could live without the artichoke dip quattro stagoni or the dessert calzone.
The bathroom is wallpapered with Playboy mag covers. This caused some *awesome* conversation when I took my 5 year old in to take a leak.
Tartufata all the way. Everything I've had here is excellent. Fabulous staff and very friendly atmosphere.
Spinach pizza is the best tasting pizza I've ever had. Toby's calzone is just perfect.
Gabi MooreSeptember 21, 2010If you're looking for something light the Tomato Carpaccio is delicious.
Daniella TaginoMarch 1, 2014Bartender was counting money for a long time and ignoring our call for more beer, just really bad for the bar reputation.
Pizza is awesome, but do NOT sleep on the antipasto plate. Bountiful doesn't even cover it.
if you have chris as a server ask her what she recommends. he recommendations are always on point.
renee iselinMay 20, 2010go to toby's and get the calzone. tastes just like the one i had in sardinia!
- Pizza is delicious but the waitress is the mayor so don't get your hopes up.
Adrian SchaeferJuly 27, 2013Terrible customer service!! Don't sit by the air conditioner or ur pizza will be cold in 10 min. After all the hype, it was quite a disappointment.
Some of the best pizza I've had in NYC -- and remarkably nice folks.
- Eric BeugOctober 28, 2009be sure to order the "bam special"! named after the friendly bartender, "bam"
- Terrible bartender , please someone tell owner about workers . Been going to Toby's for years unfortunately won't go back ever again!
Get the black garlic pizza and Bam's Kill Me jerky.
141 Photos
Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA
Brick oven cooked goodness.
Want to try some of the best pizza in Brooklyn and Nolita? C'mon down!
Permanently closed (Show more)
- Mon–Thu
- 4:00 PM–1:00 AM
- Fri–Sun
- Noon–1:00 AM
(718) 788-1186
Features
Reservations
No
Credit Cards
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Food & Drink
Menus
Brunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks
Beer, Wine, Full Bar, Cocktails
See More
You might also like
- 9.2
"The pizza is awesome. The toppings are unique. Pour some spicy oil to enhance the beautiful flavors. Wear your hipster garb."
Yesbelt Fernandez - 9.0
"Probably the best pizzeria in East New York, really affordable too."
Stephanie - 9.2
"Margherita pizza was fantastic. Friendly staff, and great outdoor seating nearby. Will go back and try some of their other pies."
Will Harahan
Places people like to go after Toby's Public House
- 8.3
"Love the fact they let U have a sample before ordering a beer. Especially as a visitor to the city. Wonderful place!"
Adrian Schaefer - 8.9
"The fish tank is mesmerizing. Nice place, glad to have it in the neighborhood!"
Marianne Nieman - 7.8
"Awesome staff, great vibe, strange jazz in the back room, great tasting food!"
Gus Gus
Appears on 186 lists
Created by ballsohardbmore
197 items • 280 followers
Created by Tristan
13 items • 214 followers
Created by Adam Kuban
67 items • 837 followers