See all
141 photos

Toby's Public House

(Now Closed)

Pizzeria and Bar$$$$

Greenwood Heights, Brooklyn

Save

Toby's Public House

The folks at The Corcoran Group and Gothamist like this place. Would you agree?

101 Tips and reviews

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Elizabeth MitchellMay 16, 2010
Been here 25+ times
Tartufata all the way. Everything I've had here is excellent. Fabulous staff and very friendly atmosphere.
Tom ConstabileApril 24, 2013
Been here 10+ times
Tartufata is a must have...
Cha 🎈🏃🏻May 29, 2013
gotta have the Nutella dessert calzone
Alexander CasanovaAugust 30, 2010
Been here 10+ times
Spinach pizza is the best tasting pizza I've ever had. Toby's calzone is just perfect.
etta yJune 7, 2011
Sausage pizza is amazing. Cash only - ATM inside but come with money in case it's out of order. Nothing around for blocks.
Evan WeissAugust 30, 2011
The Cipolla pizza is amazing. Good beer selection too.
Margarita KrupAugust 8, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Bufalina pizza is amazing
Nikos MaridakisMay 9, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Pizza is incredible. Be sure to get the nutella calzone for dessert, no matter how full you are!
Sam HorineMay 22, 2012
Been here 100+ times
Opens at noon on Fridays now - happy hour until 7pm!
Sam HorineNovember 29, 2014
Been here 100+ times
Pizza game is ON POINT.
Margie CarrollAugust 3, 2011
Been here 10+ times
I don't think I could live without the artichoke dip quattro stagoni or the dessert calzone.
Adam NunesJune 13, 2015
Pizza, calzones, s'mores
Robin WellingtonAugust 17, 2011
Been here 100+ times
Pizza is awesome, but do NOT sleep on the antipasto plate. Bountiful doesn't even cover it.
David KaplanJanuary 27, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Try the Faro, Cucumber, Tomato, Mint Salad
Brian MasefieldDecember 30, 2011
Loud crowd. Lovely pizza. Enjoy!
Adam SmithAugust 7, 2014
Great pizza!
Lindsay DugganNovember 27, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Bufulina pizza is by far the best!
Gabi MooreSeptember 21, 2010
If you're looking for something light the Tomato Carpaccio is delicious.
Theresa HendersonAugust 12, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Everything here is amazing, nutella calzone!!!
David BerkowitzApril 30, 2011
Love the truffle and prosciutto pizza
Jake LevinFebruary 13, 2010
Been here 10+ times
if you have chris as a server ask her what she recommends. he recommendations are always on point.
renee iselinMay 20, 2010
go to toby's and get the calzone. tastes just like the one i had in sardinia!
Allan TaginoMarch 1, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Great food but waitress are really slow. :(
Jason FryApril 18, 2010
Been here 25+ times
Some of the best pizza I've had in NYC -- and remarkably nice folks.
Sam HorineOctober 3, 2010
Been here 100+ times
Pizza is delicious but the waitress is the mayor so don't get your hopes up.
David KaplanJanuary 28, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Try the Nutella Calzone
Maria 909November 7, 2011
Every thing is amazin here
Catherine GoldDecember 27, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Shrimp wrapped in pancetta is amazing.
Daniella TaginoMarch 1, 2014
Bartender was counting money for a long time and ignoring our call for more beer, just really bad for the bar reputation.
David KaplanApril 22, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Try the Caesar salad pizza
Kimberley EddingtonAugust 8, 2010
Super yummy pizza & a good selection of beer.
David KaplanJanuary 28, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Try the Burrata Pizza
Eric BeugOctober 28, 2009
be sure to order the "bam special"! named after the friendly bartender, "bam"
Reuben HussmannJanuary 25, 2012
Iggy Pop is a great bar tender.
Chad BurgessJune 23, 2012
Been here 5+ times
Pizza is bomb here
Jake LevinFebruary 7, 2010
Been here 10+ times
any pizza from here is amazing. freshest ingredients.
Ian PrattJuly 11, 2011
Bam's beef jerky is available in regular or "Kill Me" Read more
Sarah B.June 9, 2011
They have the best Caesar salad
Theresa HendersonJanuary 26, 2012
Been here 10+ times
Best pizza in NYC!
MegAugust 6, 2011
Cute place and the pizza is interesting, but not a+...
stephanie jonssonDecember 12, 2010
Opt for a spot at the bar.
Adrian SchaeferJuly 27, 2013
Terrible customer service!! Don't sit by the air conditioner or ur pizza will be cold in 10 min. After all the hype, it was quite a disappointment.
Allan TaginoMarch 1, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Terrible bartender , please someone tell owner about workers . Been going to Toby's for years unfortunately won't go back ever again!
Nancy PantsNovember 6, 2009
The spinach pizza is amazing! Try it!
jaredFebruary 25, 2011
good pizza and beer
Phil CuykendallJanuary 16, 2010
Been here 5+ times
Get the black garlic pizza and Bam's Kill Me jerky.
Donny TsangSeptember 10, 2009
Been here 10+ times
The spicy pecorino is waaaay awesome
Yianns LianoglouAugust 7, 2011
Tartufata. Now.
SalinaAugust 1, 2010
Rad Pizza & Bartender's iPod rules.....
phaedra rileySeptember 26, 2009
Been here 10+ times
Try some of Bam's Jerky! Pick yer fave..

1 2 3

141 Photos

Toby's Public House

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after Toby's Public House

Appears on 186 lists

Is this your business? Claim it now.