Close Icon
Gear IconImportant Notice:We have made the tough decision to say goodbye to the Foursquare City Guide mobile app, effective December 15, 2024, with the web version to follow in early 2025. Visit our FAQ for more information or to download our Swarm app.
Learn more
Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens
Prime Meats is one of Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens.

1. Prime Meats

465 Court St (at Luquer St), Brooklyn, NY
New American Restaurant · Carroll Gardens · 236 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: i normally get porterhouse, but this is the best ny strip steak i've ever had.

Ted & Honey is one of Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens.

2. Ted & Honey

264 Clinton St (at Congress), Brooklyn, NY
Sandwich Spot · Cobble Hill · 139 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: all the breakfast sammies are a win, especially the meatloaf. the yogurt/fruit/granola is a great lighter meal as well. get it to go and eat it next door in cobble hill park.

Fragole is one of Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens.

3. Fragole

7.8
394 Court St (btwn 1st Pl & Carroll St.), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Carroll Gardens · 49 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: bolognese bolognese bolognese

4. Seersucker

329 Smith St (President and Carroll), Brooklyn, NY
Southern Food Restaurant · Carroll Gardens · 91 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: pork chop FTW

Colonie is one of Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens.

5. Colonie

9.2
127 Atlantic Ave (btwn Henry & Clinton St), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · Brooklyn Heights · 246 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: the drinks, apps, small plates and crostinis are better than the mains. you can't go wrong with any of those and it's a lovely atmosphere.

Henry Public is one of Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens.

6. Henry Public

8.9
329 Henry St (btwn Atlantic Ave & Pacific St), Brooklyn, NY
Gastropub · Cobble Hill · 192 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: the burger. and a fancy libation from a moustached mixologist.

Lucali is one of Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens.

7. Lucali

9.2
575 Henry St (btwn Carroll St & 1st Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Carroll Gardens · 251 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: some of the best brick oven pies in the five boroughs. put your name in early and then go somewhere for a drink; they'll call your table is ready. oh, and it's BYO and they only serve pies and calzone

8. Sal's Pizzeria

305 Court St (at Degraw St), Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Boerum Hill · 36 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: quality pizza-by-the-slice and italian ices. real old-school.

Van Horn Restaurant is one of Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens.

9. Van Horn Restaurant

231 Court St (at Baltic), Brooklyn, NY
Restaurant · Boerum Hill · 96 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: excellent sammiches and sides and a nice back garden. my faves are the fish sandwich and potato salad.

Frankies 457 Spuntino is one of Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens.

10. Frankies 457 Spuntino

9.2
457 Court St (btwn 4th Pl & Luquer St), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Carroll Gardens · 237 tips and reviews

EaterEater: The cavatelli pasta alone is worth the trip, but, then, so is the rest of the food and scene here, which is quintessentially Aging Hipster in the best possible way. [Eater 38 Member] Read more.

11. Nine-D

462 Court St, New York, NY
Thai Restaurant · 14 tips and reviews

J CrowleyJ Crowley: My favorite thai food in Carroll Gardens / Cobble Hill. Super reasonably priced. Massaman chicken curry is my staple. Crispy calamari for your app.

12. Petite Crevette

8.8
144 Hicks St. (btw Union & President St), Brooklyn, NY
Seafood Restaurant · Carroll Gardens · 47 tips and reviews

Jason Y.Jason Yovanoff: Some of the best seafood around. No reservations, but well worth the wait.

Buttermilk Channel is one of Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens.

13. Buttermilk Channel

8.8
524 Court St (at Huntington St), Brooklyn, NY
American Restaurant · Carroll Gardens · 354 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: fried chicken over cheddar waffles is their specialty, but it's all great.

Brucie is one of Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens.

14. Brucie

234 Court St (at Baltic St), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Cobble Hill · 98 tips and reviews

J CrowleyJ Crowley: OH MY GOD. The tagliatelle in tomato butter sauce with roasted brussel sprouts might be my favorite dish in brooklyn. i wanted to order a second one!

15. Pok Pok NY

117 Columbia St (at Kane St), Brooklyn, NY
Thai Restaurant · Cobble Hill · 341 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: excellent, inventive Thai fare. some of the best chix wings evar and the skrimps with pork belly and glass noodles were faaaantastic. big backyard is opening in time for summer. do it.

Mile End Delicatessen is one of Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens.

16. Mile End Delicatessen

8.9
97A Hoyt St (btwn Atlantic Ave & Pacific St), Brooklyn, NY
Sandwich Spot · Boerum Hill · 315 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: i never thought i'd say this, but their smoked meat rivals katz's pastrami for best jewish sandwich in the city. montreal-style jew food mecca that moses would be proud of.

17. Rucola

9.3
190 Dean St (at Bond St), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Boerum Hill · 232 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: amazeballs. deelishicious food in a great atmosphere and a lovely staff. faves were the crudo and the homemade pastas. spots like this are why brooklyn wins.

18. Hibino

9.2
333 Henry St (at Pacific St), Brooklyn, NY
Japanese Restaurant · Cobble Hill · 156 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: A slice of Tokyo in BK. You won't find better, more authentic tofu in NYC. The agedashi and the home made varieties are delicate and delicious. Everything else is fantastic, esp the nightly specials.

19. Dassara

271 Smith St (btwn Degraw and Sackett St), Brooklyn, NY
Noodle Restaurant · Carroll Gardens · 116 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: Momofuku-lite, and that's a really big compliment. I'd suggest getting most all of the non-ramen options and then splitting a ramen (if you're with your honey and splitting a soup isn't soups awkward)

20. Krescendo

364 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Pizzeria · Boerum Hill · 41 tips and reviews

jake f.jake furst: Pete Wells raves about the Finocchio Flower Power pizza, "an essay on the theme of fennel."

Pazzi Pasta is one of Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens.

21. Pazzi Pasta

227 Smith St (Butler St), Brooklyn, NY
Italian Restaurant · Boerum Hill · 20 tips and reviews

Kilian W.Kilian Walsh: This place is proper old school Italian. The elderly gentleman who oversees the operation and speaks only Italian is the man; his pasta is awesome!

Bergen Hill is one of Must Eats in Cobble Hill / Carroll Gardens.

22. Bergen Hill

387 Court St (at 1st Pl), Brooklyn, NY
Cocktail Bar · Carroll Gardens · 22 tips and reviews

Jeremy G.Jeremy Goldstein: Absolutely fantastic small plates. Get the octopus.