Important Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.

Foursquare City Guide

See all
1,144 photos

John's Pizzeria

Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$

Theater District, New York

Save

Share

John's Pizzeria

8.4^/10

1,219

ratings

Ranked #7 for NY style pizza in New York
Has a stamp of approval from The Corcoran Group and New York Habitat
"Actually the best pizza in NYC."(10 Tips)
"Great atmosphere and wonderful NY style pizza."(4 Tips)
"Try the Traditional Pizza - Some of the best pizza I've had."(5 Tips)
"Half Margherita, half Traditional pie-- the best!!!"(13 Tips)

316 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
good for groups
casual
good for dates
calzones
great value
desserts
sausage rolls
spacious
murals
big portions
salads
dinner
bar
cheesecake
crowded
garlic rolls
lunch
eggplant
church
(15 more)

Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Sarah ChaseDecember 18, 2013
Best pizza in New York. End of debate.
Hal NinekMarch 27, 2013
Chicken Parm is not the best.. Pizza looks like it could be tasty
Liliana HacesApril 26, 2016
Pizza Margherita and calzone!
IOANNA SOULAHAKIApril 8, 2016
The food is ok, mostly the pizza since the pasta was not impressive. The important thing is that the stuff is rude without paying attention to customers...
Wayne PezzinoDecember 17, 2011
Been here 10+ times
Get here Early, be patient it's worth it!
MelNovember 11, 2012
Food is delicious!!!!
30 Minutes Or LessJuly 1, 2011
This pizza parlor serves the whole pie, so #DontBlowIt by asking for just a slice.
Theo YeomelakisNovember 10, 2013
Been here 5+ times
Best pizza I've had here!
Frank ColatruglioAugust 14, 2014
Pasta w/Bolanese is delish.
Lisa Marie MesaOctober 16, 2012
Pizza was amazing!! Service was terrible though
Elliott C.April 8, 2011
Lunch for two is no prob getting seated. Billy the bartender is the friendliest guy in this joint.
Jamara UjaqueNovember 23, 2018
My favorite yummy
Jamara UjaqueNovember 23, 2018
My favorite yummy
Jamara UjaqueNovember 23, 2018
My favorite yummy
Brent WilliamsJanuary 19, 2013
Come early. Wait times are extraordinary.
aaron casseseMarch 19, 2012
Been here 10+ times
The garlic rolls are the bees knees!
DustinNovember 7, 2011
Try the eggplant on your pizza... delicious!
Wei VaynSeptember 30, 2012
Come here on a rainy Sunday afternoon. There would have no line.
Brent GatewoodAugust 8, 2014
Been a while, but I always come here for the pizza...
Aiden KirchnerSeptember 13, 2011
This place has the best pizza, so good & yummy
marjolijn kamphuisMarch 21, 2011
Enjoying that delicious pizza? Check your food in on Foodzy.com to stay fit!
Jennifer DrewelSeptember 13, 2014
We hear that this is the for pizza in Manhatten
EuniceDecember 20, 2011
Thin crusted bianco pizza with spinach is divine
Marisa GreenMarch 11, 2010
The "default" pizzas are very low on cheese - you might want to ask for extra as a topping, if you like a positive ration of cheese to sauce.
Adam QRMarch 21, 2011
Amazing pizza's! So delicious and big too...
Alexis RollinJuly 13, 2011
Arrived at 8:40. Waiting time : less than 10mn. Just avoid peak hours before theater !
Kim JonesFebruary 1, 2014
Infamous mural.
Doe ZagatMarch 18, 2010
This place had great food. The pizza by the pie and not by the slice. Grab a salad also.
Bobby HarrisJune 1, 2011
Just learned if u sit in the lobby.. All the folks leaving for shows give u food!!
Gregory VillanoNovember 11, 2013
Wow. This used to be a church... Guess I'm breaking bread again today
sean tenneyOctober 15, 2023
Post show drink
AdaMarcomDecember 18, 2009
Their pizzas are one of the best in Manhattan; love the restaurant atmosphere
Amelia DyeMarch 11, 2018
Pizza is great, but service is really really bad. Be willing to wait
Vicki GambleDecember 28, 2010
The place reminds me of the Spaghetti Factory except that SF has good food.
Aki TykkiSeptember 11, 2012
Pizzas not as good as expected, but they're okay. Prosciutto chunks were extremely salty, should've taken some pineapple with them. Nice atmosphere though.
Logan DorseyOctober 13, 2012
I just had the best pizza of my life!
Georgie CastillaMarch 31, 2013
Been here 10+ times
I really really LOVE this place!!!
Kristina SJanuary 12, 2020
Good pizza! Service was lacking and pizza honestly took forever to come. :/
Benny SpoelstraDecember 12, 2011
Who doesn't have free refills? Gimme a break! Good pizza though
Mark GramagliaOctober 21, 2012
Pizza and vodka ravioli is da best
Peter BuonocoreAugust 21, 2012
Been here 25+ times
Good pies, but over priced and they rush you to turn tables!
Faith KastenAugust 9, 2011
They do not service Pizza by the slice. The Pizza was good. Disappointed that they do not have garlic powder. The atmosphere was nice and it is a renovated church.
Debra SalleyMay 14, 2013
Delicious Original.
Katy VerhoevenSeptember 10, 2014
Best pizza ever!!!!
Johnny VegasAugust 28, 2016
Pizza rocks
Hans GOctober 19, 2013
Great place
Mandy VDecember 17, 2012
Ridiculous that they can't seat us when 8 out of 9 of us are here during lunch!
Jimmy KastnerAugust 22, 2014
They don't serve by the slice so don't come here alone.
Rando PärnaJune 20, 2015
Real pizza
Michael LeeAugust 5, 2013
Get the pizza!

1,144 Photos

Related Searches

john's pizzeria new york •
john's pizzeria new york photos •
john's pizzeria new york location •
john's pizzeria new york address •
john's pizzeria new york •
260 west 44th street new york •
john's new york •
john's pizza new york •
john's pizzaria new york •
john's pizzeria new york •
john's pizzeria 260 w. 44th street nyc, ny new york •
john's pizzeria- no slices!! new york •
john\'s pizza new york •
johns new york •
johns pizza new york •
john's pizzeria theater district new york

More Great Places in New York:
a
b
c
d
e
f
g
h
i
j
k
l
m
n
o
p
q
r
s
t
u
v
w
x
y
z
#

Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA

You must enable JavaScript to use foursquare.com

We use the latest and greatest technology available to provide the best possible web experience.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser settings to continue.

Download Foursquare for your smart phone and start exploring the world around you!