Important Reminder:The Foursquare City Guide app officially sunset on December 15, 2024, with the web version following in early 2025. However, your check-in journey doesn’t end here! Join us on Swarm, where new adventures await.

Foursquare City Guide

See all
1,144 photos

John's Pizzeria

Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant$$$$

Theater District, New York

Save

Share

John's Pizzeria

8.4^/10

1,219

ratings

Ranked #7 for NY style pizza in New York
The experts at The Corcoran Group and New York Habitat recommend this place
"Actually the best pizza in NYC."(10 Tips)
"Great atmosphere and wonderful NY style pizza."(4 Tips)
"Try the Traditional Pizza - Some of the best pizza I've had."(5 Tips)
"Half Margherita, half Traditional pie-- the best!!!"(13 Tips)

316 Tips and reviews

Filter:

pizza
good for groups
casual
good for dates
calzones
great value
desserts
sausage rolls
spacious
murals
big portions
salads
dinner
bar
cheesecake
crowded
garlic rolls
lunch
eggplant
church
(15 more)

Log in to leave a tip here.

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Justin AnastosJanuary 11, 2023
The traditional cheese pizza is incredible.
Brian CriderMay 30, 2012
Awesome pizza, even carry-out was great!
Melody EwingSeptember 7, 2010
The pizzas are enormous. A small will yield 6 generously sized slices. If you're not in the mood for pizza, the eggplant parmesan is a tasty alternative.
Amy CummingsMarch 19, 2017
Been here 5+ times
The cheese on their pizza is to die for.
Mr. Mu~ © 🚗April 14, 2017
Yummy, margarita pizza was great
Wim Van GuchtApril 4, 2013
Not the cheapest, but definetly the best pizza I have had in the city so far.
TomMarch 12, 2014
Wow, follow up awesome pizza with over 15 Italian desert choices!
Hilary SSeptember 19, 2016
Fantastic pizza and authentic calzones.
Taj W.December 27, 2011
The pizza is OKAY; I wouldn't call it amazing. For some reason, the place was packed to the gills on December 26. I don't know if they were giving stuff away.
Josh WarfieldAugust 6, 2015
Get the Margherita pizza!
Raul AlvarezMay 12, 2016
Great for groups, amazing pizza
Tami PriceSeptember 15, 2013
The garlic rolls and the Pizza Bianca w/ spinach are amazing!
Kevin VaughnAugust 22, 2014
The pizza! What can I say? So fresh and thin and NOT greasy!
Saleh NasserAugust 10, 2018
I was expecting a wow pizza. It was decent and not so special. Though I loved that interior design.
Brenda BurroughDecember 30, 2021
Pizza is great! Lots of seating.
Ann Marie DeMauroApril 15, 2013
Margherita pizza delicious ... Bathrooms were a disgrace
BurkeMedia ProductionsJune 8, 2011
Mushrooms and pepperoni are the way to go! Some of the best Pizza in Manhattan!
Kelsey WarrenSeptember 29, 2015
Make sure to look up and check out the stained glass!!
Katie ConnellJanuary 22, 2014
This used to be a church the stain glass is amazing in the daytime.
Uygar DJuly 5, 2015
Nice pizza, great value, though long wait times...
Diana SalamehJanuary 26, 2011
Actually the best pizza in NYC. Try the linguini with pesto sauce, and add chicken cutlet and sun dried tomatoes.
Shanelle R.May 2, 2012
This pizza place is HUGE inside. Perfect for large groups. Located right in the heart of the theater district.
glennf 🦀April 21, 2015
Marinara is amazing
Melissa ChapmanAugust 31, 2017
Fabulous New York pizza. Just what i was looking for
The Daily MealSeptember 6, 2012
The pizza is cooked in a coal-fired brick oven, the same way it's been done there since 1929. Read more
SJuly 24, 2015
Busy and kinda noisy place but the pizza is good. Last order at 11
EDDecember 7, 2012
I think it's the best pizza in New York City try the sausage rolls
Kathryn DSeptember 16, 2016
Good pizza forced into Times Square ambiance.
Sinan ArkonacMay 15, 2017
Great pepperoni pizza but not as good as bleeker st
Nic MirandaJune 9, 2012
Try John's traditional with pepperoni and fresh basil. You won't regret it!
Brigette K.December 15, 2012
Hawaiian pizza was awesome! Loud but it is in a neat setting.
Jodi LaughlinJuly 13, 2014
Order the Bianca white pizza, add chicken - delicious!
Kelsey WarrenSeptember 29, 2015
Had one of the best pizzas I have ever eaten!!
AnoudJanuary 23, 2018
The traditional pizza is sooooo good
Rachel AlbaneseJanuary 2, 2012
the "margarita" pizza is exactly the same as the regular cheese pizza except they add basil for an additional $6.00 !!
Türker AtaşNovember 23, 2018
Pizza and red wine...
Vero RoaNovember 15, 2013
The calzone is the most delicious Thing in the world!!!!!
Greg ShadowensJuly 13, 2013
Great thin slice pizza. Try it with a Black & Blue.
John WmsonFebruary 26, 2010
Just try any of their thin crust pizzas, among the best in the NYC area. And they also serve Sierra Nevada Pale Ale for those interested! Read more
PizzaSnobo pizzasnobo.comFebruary 2, 2011
Good pizza but for a real treat, cross the street and go to Keste where you can have the best of the best.
Maina KhojaSeptember 8, 2019
The female hostess were extremely rude, males servers were nice , the mozzarella sticks is tastes like cheap mozzarella and the pizza is overrated lacking taste and salt.
Heather MorrisAugust 17, 2013
Try the garlic knots. They are absolutely delicious!
Alex AJanuary 30, 2017
Been here 5+ times
Pizza margarita
Shuaa AldarwishNovember 20, 2014
Had really yummy giant margarita pizza 🍕
Appa VMarch 9, 2013
Been here 50+ times
Fantastic pie, but you on't be seated unless all your guests as present.
Raghda MakAugust 14, 2016
They have a huge range of meals, not just pizza
Shawn PhillipsMay 26, 2012
Get the Pizza Bianca! It just sounds like a cheese pizza, but it's very good!
Natalie B.May 21, 2012
Some of the BEST pizza I've had!!! Huge slices!!!! But so good.
Jamie PerutzMarch 28, 2013
Half Margherita, half Traditional pie-- the best!!!
Andrew CurrieApril 20, 2014
I take it as a fairly bad sign when the garlic balls are the most recommended item on the menu—and no, they're not even that good...

1,144 Photos

Related Searches

john's pizzeria new york •
john's pizzeria new york photos •
john's pizzeria new york location •
john's pizzeria new york address •
john's pizzeria new york •
260 west 44th street new york •
john's new york •
john's pizza new york •
john's pizzaria new york •
john's pizzeria new york •
john's pizzeria 260 w. 44th street nyc, ny new york •
john's pizzeria- no slices!! new york •
john\'s pizza new york •
johns new york •
johns pizza new york •
john's pizzeria theater district new york

More Great Places in New York:
a
b
c
d
e
f
g
h
i
j
k
l
m
n
o
p
q
r
s
t
u
v
w
x
y
z
#

Foursquare © 2024 Lovingly made in NYC, CHI, SEA & LA

You must enable JavaScript to use foursquare.com

We use the latest and greatest technology available to provide the best possible web experience.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser settings to continue.

Download Foursquare for your smart phone and start exploring the world around you!