See all
670 photos

St. Anselm

American Restaurant and Steakhouse$$$$

Williamsburg, Brooklyn

Save

St. Anselm

9.1^/10

1,226

ratings

Ranked #2 for steakhouses in Brooklyn
The experts at The New York Times and Eater recommend this place
"The butchers steak is probably the best value steak I've ever had."(52 Tips)
"Sardines, whole mackerel, pan fried mash potatoes are the bomb!"(7 Tips)
"The spinach dish is amazing and the Hangar steak is tasty."(15 Tips)
"Really enjoyed the butcher's steak and the spinach gratin."(5 Tips)

308 Tips and reviews

Filter:

steak
good for dates
trendy
mashed potatoes
luger
casual
burrata cheese
pork chops
spinach
great value
bar
desserts
sweet tea
chef's tables
root beer
bacon
chicken
salads
gluten-free food
veal
(15 more)

Sort:

Popular
Recent

Rate My ProfessorsAugust 29, 2012
Saint Anselm College is #10 on our 2011-2012 Top Schools List, based on your student ratings. See the full list and rate your schools and profs at RateMyProfessors.com. Read more
Red FabbriAugust 9, 2014
Meat, meat, and more meat. Go lamb anything and of course beef.
Oliver DelgadoJune 22, 2015
Honestly one of the best steaks in the city, at any price.
emily chenAugust 7, 2014
when you are craving a (really good) casual steak without that steakhouse pomp.
Kika GMay 30, 2012
Butcher steak FTW. Bibb Salad. Fried Mash potatoes. Get a bottle of the Pinot Noir Rose!
James BishopMarch 7
Probably my all time favorite place in BK
Upvoted 2 weeks ago
David DunhillSeptember 21, 2015
The quality of the food (very good) is dampened by the authoritarian and seemingly arbitrary rules.
Michael GoldsheftJuly 22, 2012
Sit at the bar. Get the butcher steak and the eggplant and clams and peppers and potatoes.
CompassJuly 24, 2013
The reasonably-priced steakhouse serves cheeses, beef cuts, and seafood to a hip clientele.
Sliced AppleMay 11, 2019
The chicken blew my mind. Still thinking about it a month later
Tom WolfsteinMarch 29, 2015
This is the side of bacon. Need I say more?
Ioannis IliadisDecember 28, 2017
What’s good here eh ? Everything !
Jessica AprilSeptember 15, 2011
The lamb chop for $39 is worth every penny. It's big enough for two people to share with a few sides+apps.
Ari PaparoJune 29, 2017
Fennel is delicious. Secret ingredient is hazelnut.
Justin KalifowitzSeptember 5, 2012
Butcher steak + Lobster Mushrooms (veg). Avoid the absurdly difficult to operate bottle of Eli Miller Seltzer. Tables are easy to snag at 7, impossible by 7:15.
Aaron PangDecember 13, 2020
Been here 5+ times
Butcher steak, spinach, potatoes
Upvoted 2 weeks ago
Anna BlumeApril 5, 2018
Most amazing salmon in my life :-)
Jenny GregoryNovember 5, 2013
On Free Williamsburg's 20 Best Restaurants in Williamsburg, Greenpoint and Bushwick
Jordan CrookSeptember 24, 2014
Oh boy mashed potatoes lamb with yogurt any and all wine and burrata.
Sefi KeiniJune 7, 2014
The butcher steak is one of the best deals in the city
Mateo Hernandez-YsasiJuly 7, 2015
Lamb and butcher's (hanger) steak were both bomb
Mahesh Paolini-SubramanyaAugust 24, 2014
Been here 10+ times
A 53oz ax-handle and a Thackeray.#WhatsForDinner in a *very* decadent way
Chloe CapewellAugust 23, 2014
Bacon and artichokes with aioli both fantastic
Jane DoeMay 11, 2018
Don't miss out on the artichoke app and fennel side 🌞
Kappie FarringtonOctober 15, 2014
Grilled fennel and haloumi are to die for.
Aliz AJuly 31, 2021
Exorbitant prices for less-than-average steaks🤬 The ribeye came with chewy texture and bland taste, which compliments their bland-tasting mashed potato and cauliflower extremely well. Do not go!
Grace RobertsonMarch 5, 2013
The food is awesome. And while you are waiting, go next door for good beer!
Todd MohneyAugust 1, 2014
All of the meat dishes are crazy-ass good, but don't overlook the scallops.
Kimberly LaBluesJanuary 2, 2016
Amazing food. Drinks next door while you wait 🍷
Chris StrengDecember 16, 2013
Try the pan fired mashed potatoes and the seared octopus !!... Yum!!
Alex RobertsonNovember 13, 2019
I thought it was pretty good. Mostly just impressed with that German beer wowie
ZombieFebruary 14, 2015
Steak is great, grab the mussels if they are on special.
atomly leeFebruary 9, 2015
The Butcher Steak is unbelievable, especially for the price ($16)!!!
AnyaNovember 20, 2016
Follow us on Instagram nyc_adventureaddicts for more tips 😉👌🏻
Rob NeroFebruary 10, 2017
The most amazing meat you'll ever eat.
OutwithBabyDecember 29, 2015
Unsurprisingly, no high chairs, but surprisingly other babies and kids. Come at 5pm or risk a very long wait.
Nina YiamsamathaFebruary 20, 2012
Butcher's steak with pan-fried mashed potatoes, yes please!
Zayed KhanAugust 22, 2013
The hype is real! $16 will get you one of the best steaks in New York!
Benjamin HaasNovember 15, 2012
They do magic with the grill. Beware, however, that the prices on the draft list are for an 8oz pour of beer.
Chris KorhonenAugust 9, 2014
Been here 5+ times
Can't go wrong with the $16 butchers steak.
Jordan DaileyMarch 25, 2019
Butcher Steak. Long beans. Pan fried mashed.
Phillip RosehillAugust 29, 2013
I've had a few better steaks, but the Butcher's steak is AMAZING for only $16
Kevin WalshJune 20, 2016
Best steakhouse value in the city
Elysia MannAugust 6, 2015
1 steak, 2-3 apps is good for 2 people
jason chinAugust 2, 2016
Best steakhouse in BROOKLYN
Katie SweeneyFebruary 17, 2019
I got the shrimp and grits and now I’m coming for dinner this week - can’t wait!
Alejandro León MuñozNovember 7, 2018
The Butcher's Steak is delicious
Jeremy FisherSeptember 2, 2017
Been here 5+ times
Egregious waits but excellent steaks
Stephanie KimMarch 17, 2017
The thick-cut bacon was deliciously smoky, but disappointingly not crispy enough.
JoanneOctober 3, 2013
Bacon to start and Butcher's steak medium rare every time. Cannot fail!

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

670 Photos

St. Anselm

Related Searches

You might also like

Places people like to go after St. Anselm

Appears on 2,914 lists

Top places in the area

Is this your business? Claim it now.